I've been getting pizza here for years, it's been a staple of my college experience. Quality hasn't dropped off, I don't know what the other reviewers experience has been like but I haven't noticed. My go to slice is their chicken vodka, very delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ada Sanchez
The customer service in this business is HORRIBLE!!! I placed a delivery order today at 6:36p and was told that the delivery would arrive between 40mins - 1hr. An hour passed by and no order. I decide to call to verify the status on my order. The individual on the other end of the phone said it would take another 20mins for me to receive my order given how busy they were. 20 mins passed by and still no order. I of course cancelled my order given that my kids were hungry. The person I spoke with did not even apologize & had an attitude. This is not the 1st time I encounter an unpleasant experience with this business. After today I will not be spending my hard earned money at this business, I rather save myself the headache and go to a different establishment.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Kathleen
Myself and my coworkers are always ordering form here! They’ve got great food both the catering menu and regular menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
cesar rodriguez
Great Pizza and Amazing Food. Service was fantastic. Placed a phone order for my office, delivery driver was really nice. Prices compared to other was actually surprisingly low for the large portions. The guys in here can't get enough of the Meatlovers Pizza and the girls love the Vodka Sause. 2 Large house salads was enough to share with 7 people and the garlic bread was perfect. Highly Recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
C K
Got 2 slices with sausage. Way too much cheese for our liking. Cheese dominated the slice to the point you couldn't see any sauce and wasn't flavorful at all. I like a nice 50-50 ratio of cheese to sauce. There was enough sausage on the slices but no flavor like it was old. Very disappointing for the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Pablo Guerrero
First time that i stop and i order a pizza slice and a beef patty and the young lady open the beef patty in front of me without wearing globes sticking her fingers into the patty without following any quality standard. I didnt say anything and took my order just to throw it away ones i got out. Train your employees propertly or hire better.
Arvin Ramdas
No loud music Delicious pizza Good portion Affordable
LKA
Great atmosphere and fresh pizza. It's not easily assessable, and it's located in a remote hilly obscure residential area in Riverdale, but it's worth the trek if you're walking or care to drive but parking in this area extremely difficult!
Luke Allison
The food was good, that wasn’t the problem. The problem was their delivery rider(male), he was very rude and disrespectful. I paid for my food, however I wasn’t the one who called so I asked how much to know how much I was supposed to receive in tips and he came a snappy remark. Then when I sensed the attitude and he gave me my money, I was going to give him a tip but because it wasn’t the amount he wanted he said something rude. My partner went outside to address him and the driver was nice to him.
John Ludewig
Bought a sausage & ziti parm dinner and it was very flavorful. Sauce was very tasty and almost like when I was a child about a hundred years ago. Ok.. I am really not that old.
Food is okay, pretty overpriced, but customer service needs a big improvement. It’s free to be friendly.
They cater to Manhattan College so maybe it doesn’t matter, kids will still come back. But locals won’t.
Being unfriendly while overcharging prevents locals from returning.
Thamara Rios
Best pizza in the Bronx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
karol mena
I don’t know who was cooking tonight but I ordered a chicken Marsala with linguine by far the WORST chicken Marsala I’ve ever tasted in my life they literally poured half the bottle of Marsala wine in it I didn’t touch my food the linguine was dry sauce def taste unseasoned don’t waste your money there I ended making a grilled cheese for dinner ???♀️
Food: 1
Joseph Beers
Got delivery. Most pizza deliveries in area come with an overcooked stiff bottom crust. Goodfellas will, upon request, bake your pizza "Light." Very much like "Old style New York pizza." My family and I will stick to Goodfellas.
I've been getting pizza here for years, it's been a staple of my college experience. Quality hasn't dropped off, I don't know what the other reviewers experience has been like but I haven't noticed. My go to slice is their chicken vodka, very delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
The customer service in this business is HORRIBLE!!! I placed a delivery order today at 6:36p and was told that the delivery would arrive between 40mins - 1hr. An hour passed by and no order. I decide to call to verify the status on my order. The individual on the other end of the phone said it would take another 20mins for me to receive my order given how busy they were. 20 mins passed by and still no order. I of course cancelled my order given that my kids were hungry. The person I spoke with did not even apologize & had an attitude. This is not the 1st time I encounter an unpleasant experience with this business. After today I will not be spending my hard earned money at this business, I rather save myself the headache and go to a different establishment.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Myself and my coworkers are always ordering form here! They’ve got great food both the catering menu and regular menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza and Amazing Food. Service was fantastic. Placed a phone order for my office, delivery driver was really nice. Prices compared to other was actually surprisingly low for the large portions. The guys in here can't get enough of the Meatlovers Pizza and the girls love the Vodka Sause. 2 Large house salads was enough to share with 7 people and the garlic bread was perfect. Highly Recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got 2 slices with sausage. Way too much cheese for our liking. Cheese dominated the slice to the point you couldn't see any sauce and wasn't flavorful at all. I like a nice 50-50 ratio of cheese to sauce. There was enough sausage on the slices but no flavor like it was old. Very disappointing for the price.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
First time that i stop and i order a pizza slice and a beef patty and the young lady open the beef patty in front of me without wearing globes sticking her fingers into the patty without following any quality standard. I didnt say anything and took my order just to throw it away ones i got out. Train your employees propertly or hire better.
No loud music
Delicious pizza
Good portion
Affordable
Great atmosphere and fresh pizza. It's not easily assessable, and it's located in a remote hilly obscure residential area in Riverdale, but it's worth the trek if you're walking or care to drive but parking in this area extremely difficult!
The food was good, that wasn’t the problem. The problem was their delivery rider(male), he was very rude and disrespectful. I paid for my food, however I wasn’t the one who called so I asked how much to know how much I was supposed to receive in tips and he came a snappy remark. Then when I sensed the attitude and he gave me my money, I was going to give him a tip but because it wasn’t the amount he wanted he said something rude. My partner went outside to address him and the driver was nice to him.
Bought a sausage & ziti parm dinner and it was very flavorful. Sauce was very tasty and almost like when I was a child about a hundred years ago. Ok.. I am really not that old.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in Riverdale Kingsbridge area
Food is okay, pretty overpriced, but customer service needs a big improvement. It’s free to be friendly.
They cater to Manhattan College so maybe it doesn’t matter, kids will still come back. But locals won’t.
Being unfriendly while overcharging prevents locals from returning.
Best pizza in the Bronx!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I don’t know who was cooking tonight but I ordered a chicken Marsala with linguine by far the WORST chicken Marsala I’ve ever tasted in my life they literally poured half the bottle of Marsala wine in it I didn’t touch my food the linguine was dry sauce def taste unseasoned don’t waste your money there I ended making a grilled cheese for dinner ???♀️
Food: 1
Got delivery. Most pizza deliveries in area come with an overcooked stiff bottom crust.
Goodfellas will, upon request, bake your pizza "Light." Very much like "Old style New York pizza." My family and I will stick to Goodfellas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Goodfellas
Loading...