Music wonderful place to visit. Especially when Jenny is working behind the bar. But it's beautiful decor great service. Definitely worth a visit
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Megan Robinson
I had a very disappointing experience at this bar due to the behavior of the bartender ( the Mexican guy ) overall his attitude was unwelcoming — as if he was annoyed just to be working. he appeared to be drinking on the job and made inappropriate, racist remarks about my nationality.
Service: 1
K P
I came to this local bar attractive by the live band playing ( my friend is old soul rock band type of music), the server Jules was very friendly and attentive ! My friend and I had margarita & beers we played pool was very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
redelgado99
Atmosphere is great, owner and workers are fantastic, drinks are perfect! I love this place any day and I thank them for hosting my wife's graduation party with such class and effort! Perfect place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Glenn Fishel
Great place for Brooklyn and Local Beers. Fast and friendly Bartenders that know their cocktails!
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 5
Ray
My family and I recently visited Man Overboard Bar in City Island, New York, and our experience was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we walked in, we felt welcomed and taken care of. The owner, Mike, went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. His friendly demeanor and attention to detail made a lasting impression.
Our bartender, Maritza, was an absolute gem. Not only is she a master at crafting drinks, but her warmth and friendliness made the evening even more enjoyable. Every cocktail she prepared was flawless, and her vibrant personality added to the overall atmosphere.
Man Overboard Bar is a must-visit if you’re in City Island. Whether you’re there for the great drinks, the cozy ambiance, or the outstanding service, this place has it all. Thank you, Mike and Maritza, for an unforgettable experience. We’ll definitely be back!
evan lizardo
Finally a place, I can call a local neighborhood bar worth my time and money. Mike (the owner) and Nelly the bartender are super cozy and welcoming people. They have a juke box which is a huge plus for me. The drinks are very good and affordable. No food yet, but I know it's coming. Pool table another ➕️ plus. I liked the decor, outside seating. What more can you ask for?.. I will be going back and enjoy a cold beer and a game on their tvs ? and shoot some pool while I'm at it. Can't wait to see what else is in the sea when I go over board again ? ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Isabel Rentas
We were walking to our car n my sister n I decided to go in. No regrets. Atmosphere was nice. Waitress was very great . We met the owner. Very Nice. We are definitely going back. 7/28/2024
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Natalia Hanson
It's an underwater-themed, cozy bar with friendly service and a chance to dance. A complimentary food buffet was available during the live band performance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
France Olave
Excellent place to spend some time and feel like family ♥️ its owner is a very nice and friendly man, the staff is very friendly, by far the best bar in City Island, I recommend it 100%, sometimes there is live music, the prices are very comfortable... Thank you Every time I go I have an excellent time! I will always come back
Friendly and accommodating. 2 TVs and they're happy to put on whatever game or race you want to watch. Impressive beer selection.They're rennovating the kitchen. so there's currently no food. Bottles and cans only for now, probably related to the kitchen, but said they'd have taps running again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Christopher Campbell
Cool spot to hung out. And the owner is very nice
Dominic Perez
HAD THE BEST TIME EVER HERE...I never hang out in the Bronx, but my brother Mario decided to have our mom's memorial get-together here in City Island after she passed away. I have to say that from the owner Michael to the bar-maid to all the regular people that filtered into the bar after our private get-together merged into a regular Sunday night at the bar, that I had the best time ever. The food was so tasty, the drinks were great and the energy was really friendly. I started wondering if I was in Utah or Iowa. This didn't seem like New York. The people were so kind, open and engaging. Man Overboard bar/restaurant is on top of my list of places to visit when I go to City Island again. Thank you Michael (owner). You are a gracious, kind and generous host.
Music wonderful place to visit. Especially when Jenny is working behind the bar. But it's beautiful decor great service. Definitely worth a visit
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I had a very disappointing experience at this bar due to the behavior of the bartender ( the Mexican guy ) overall his attitude was unwelcoming — as if he was annoyed just to be working. he appeared to be drinking on the job and made inappropriate, racist remarks about my nationality.
Service: 1
I came to this local bar attractive by the live band playing ( my friend is old soul rock band type of music), the server Jules was very friendly and attentive ! My friend and I had margarita & beers we played pool was very nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere is great, owner and workers are fantastic, drinks are perfect! I love this place any day and I thank them for hosting my wife's graduation party with such class and effort! Perfect place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for Brooklyn and Local Beers. Fast and friendly Bartenders that know their cocktails!
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 5
My family and I recently visited Man Overboard Bar in City Island, New York, and our experience was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we walked in, we felt welcomed and taken care of. The owner, Mike, went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. His friendly demeanor and attention to detail made a lasting impression.
Our bartender, Maritza, was an absolute gem. Not only is she a master at crafting drinks, but her warmth and friendliness made the evening even more enjoyable. Every cocktail she prepared was flawless, and her vibrant personality added to the overall atmosphere.
Man Overboard Bar is a must-visit if you’re in City Island. Whether you’re there for the great drinks, the cozy ambiance, or the outstanding service, this place has it all. Thank you, Mike and Maritza, for an unforgettable experience. We’ll definitely be back!
Finally a place, I can call a local neighborhood bar worth my time and money. Mike (the owner) and Nelly the bartender are super cozy and welcoming people. They have a juke box which is a huge plus for me. The drinks are very good and affordable. No food yet, but I know it's coming. Pool table another ➕️ plus. I liked the decor, outside seating. What more can you ask for?.. I will be going back and enjoy a cold beer and a game on their tvs ? and shoot some pool while I'm at it. Can't wait to see what else is in the sea when I go over board again ? ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
We were walking to our car n my sister n I decided to go in. No regrets. Atmosphere was nice. Waitress was very great . We met the owner. Very Nice. We are definitely going back. 7/28/2024
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
It's an underwater-themed, cozy bar with friendly service and a chance to dance. A complimentary food buffet was available during the live band performance
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent place to spend some time and feel like family ♥️ its owner is a very nice and friendly man, the staff is very friendly, by far the best bar in City Island, I recommend it 100%, sometimes there is live music, the prices are very comfortable... Thank you Every time I go I have an excellent time! I will always come back
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
A good experience
Friendly and accommodating. 2 TVs and they're happy to put on whatever game or race you want to watch. Impressive beer selection.They're rennovating the kitchen. so there's currently no food. Bottles and cans only for now, probably related to the kitchen, but said they'd have taps running again soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Cool spot to hung out. And the owner is very nice
HAD THE BEST TIME EVER HERE...I never hang out in the Bronx, but my brother Mario decided to have our mom's memorial get-together here in City Island after she passed away. I have to say that from the owner Michael to the bar-maid to all the regular people that filtered into the bar after our private get-together merged into a regular Sunday night at the bar, that I had the best time ever. The food was so tasty, the drinks were great and the energy was really friendly. I started wondering if I was in Utah or Iowa. This didn't seem like New York. The people were so kind, open and engaging. Man Overboard bar/restaurant is on top of my list of places to visit when I go to City Island again. Thank you Michael (owner). You are a gracious, kind and generous host.
Love it !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Loading...