My family and I came here to celebrate my son's 29th birthday and it was our first time dining at Mario's. A friend highly recommended it. I must say it was outstanding! The food was absolutely delicious, our waiter was fantastic, and the dessert....oh my, the dessert....I chose the tiramisu and it was literally the BEST tiramisu I've ever had!!! I even ordered a slice to take home! Everything was just great — definitely coming back!
Yvonne
We always go here several times a year. The food is amazing. The staff is lovely. Always a great time!
Brian
We had a lunch for 8 people. Food and service was outstanding. We'll definitely be going back.
Nequava
I ordered the lemon butter chicken with garlic and mushrooms. The chicken taste frozen, not fresh
Trudy
Visited Arthur Ave for the first time and this restaurant was highly recommended. Food was delicious and the wait staff was terrific. The place however is real old school and in need of some updating.
Andrew
Such a great experience. Our server was super easy to talk to and get advice from. Never waited too long for a drink refill. Seated in seconds. Would be happy to come back again.
Anne
The service was outstanding! Everyone who works there was loving and kind. The food is good! The drinks are also very good 
nicole
We had so much fun celebrating my mom's 80th birthday here. We made a reservation and got right in. All the staff was super nice and everyone that worked there did everything smoothly. Our waters were always filled by someone, someone cleaned the plates off in between and our waiter was so helpful. They even brought out a little desert for my mom and sang. She is from Arthur Ave so it made her birthday that much more special.
D M
Great service. Great food. Great atmosphere.
Madelon Koerner
Excellent service. This was truly a dining experience. Enjoyed the food and ambiance!
Hadn’t been here in years, had a few hours to kill and just had a Caesar, Chianti and cappuccino for lunch. They do Caesar’s the right way, it’s so hard to find real Italian food now and these guys are the real deal. Oh and the bread, I’ve missed real Italian bread. My old Italian hood in Brooklyn has been gentrified and you just can’t get the classics anymore. I’ll be back.
Cyndi
Family get together and we all enjoyed the wine, the appetizers, and our meal. We were too full for dessert. Our waiter was very attentive. Will definitely visit again.
Aishat Lawal
I ordered the Magherita pizza and was attentively waited on! The recipe is 100+ years old and did not disappoint. Nice quiet place for lunch, would love to return with a group for dinner as it seems more of a family-style focused establishment than a place to grab a quick bite.
Maya Goldberg
Amazing food. Pastas were out of this world. My three year old knocked so many things off the table and they were so patient and kind. Huge portions and very affordable and strong A/C!
ANTHONY
My go to family place. I come all the way from queens. Even if I ten our car on fumes. I'm still making it there. The food is homemade fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly. And the price is right. We love you guys.
My family and I came here to celebrate my son's 29th birthday and it was our first time dining at Mario's. A friend highly recommended it. I must say it was outstanding! The food was absolutely delicious, our waiter was fantastic, and the dessert....oh my, the dessert....I chose the tiramisu and it was literally the BEST tiramisu I've ever had!!! I even ordered a slice to take home! Everything was just great — definitely coming back!
We always go here several times a year. The food is amazing. The staff is lovely. Always a great time!
We had a lunch for 8 people. Food and service was outstanding. We'll definitely be going back.
I ordered the lemon butter chicken with garlic and mushrooms. The chicken taste frozen, not fresh
Visited Arthur Ave for the first time and this restaurant was highly recommended. Food was delicious and the wait staff was terrific. The place however is real old school and in need of some updating.
Such a great experience. Our server was super easy to talk to and get advice from. Never waited too long for a drink refill. Seated in seconds. Would be happy to come back again.
The service was outstanding! Everyone who works there was loving and kind. The food is good! The drinks are also very good 
We had so much fun celebrating my mom's 80th birthday here. We made a reservation and got right in. All the staff was super nice and everyone that worked there did everything smoothly. Our waters were always filled by someone, someone cleaned the plates off in between and our waiter was so helpful. They even brought out a little desert for my mom and sang. She is from Arthur Ave so it made her birthday that much more special.
Great service. Great food. Great atmosphere.
Excellent service. This was truly a dining experience. Enjoyed the food and ambiance!
Restaurantji Recommends
Hadn’t been here in years, had a few hours to kill and just had a Caesar, Chianti and cappuccino for lunch. They do Caesar’s the right way, it’s so hard to find real Italian food now and these guys are the real deal. Oh and the bread, I’ve missed real Italian bread. My old Italian hood in Brooklyn has been gentrified and you just can’t get the classics anymore. I’ll be back.
Family get together and we all enjoyed the wine, the appetizers, and our meal. We were too full for dessert. Our waiter was very attentive. Will definitely visit again.
I ordered the Magherita pizza and was attentively waited on! The recipe is 100+ years old and did not disappoint. Nice quiet place for lunch, would love to return with a group for dinner as it seems more of a family-style focused establishment than a place to grab a quick bite.
Amazing food. Pastas were out of this world. My three year old knocked so many things off the table and they were so patient and kind. Huge portions and very affordable and strong A/C!
My go to family place. I come all the way from queens. Even if I ten our car on fumes. I'm still making it there. The food is homemade fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly. And the price is right. We love you guys.
Loading...