Great experience all around. Showed up without a reservation about 10 minutes before the start of a division series game and was able to get a table. the Hostess was very polite and ensured we got a table near a TV. The waiter was very knowledgeable of the menu and efficient with getting us in and out to get to the game. The Bison meatball appetizer was very tasty and the 20 oz ribeye was cooked perfectly. I particularly liked how it had a dark crunchy crust on the outside which gave it that extra flavor. Looking forward to coming back to try some other appetizers and desserts. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Steak Dinner, French Fries Side
Erinson Duran
I want to thank Stephanie my waiter for making our dinner more than pleasant, she was amazing and very attentive. Also wanted to thank Jayson for checking in on us every so often making sure everything was alright in our table, and I notice he does it with all the guests as well. I mention this because it’s those little details that often go unnoticed that makes the entire dinning experience a pleasant one.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomahaw Steak, Lobster Mac & Cheese
ScottW
Outstanding. Service and food is continually consistent. Not an easy task. This restaurant has really become my family's happy place when visiting the stadium. Thank you to the staff for always being so accommodating.
Rawan
The steak was cooked perfectly! Shrimp cocktail was delicious. 10/10 recommend coming here with your family before the game. Great memories were made.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe
Really enjoyed our first visit to NYY-Steakhouse. Food was very good; as was service and ambiance. The only issue was one of our filets was overcooked. For sake of game time we did not return it. It was still tasty. The corn fritters were the favorite for all. We also appreciated the size of the truffle fries order. Overall was very enjoyable. It was a birthday treat dinner. We will likely be back.
Linda
Nice restaurant with very good food and ambience. Service was good, attentive up through the order, water glasses were not refilled when low and getting the attention of the wait staff was a bit difficult, however it was quite busy. That being said all entrees are à la carte, and prices are a bit high so I would have expected more attention to the water, a missing plate and a mixup on a side ordered.
Alan
NYY Steak is a “must visit” at Yankee Stadium. Great food, great service and some of the nicest Yankee fans in the world. A good chance at seeing some Yankee Alumni and/or celebrities. Somewhat expensive, so only go for special occasions, but worth every penny. Steaks and the Seafood Tower were outstanding! Everyone is welcome here!
Rob
Great atmosphere capturing the history and spirit of the Yankees. I used to be quite critical of this place as I found the food salty and the service to be lax in the past. HOWEVER, I've noted a distinct improvement across the board in recent years. The staff is personable, attentive and very service-oriented. The shrimp are my go-to appetizer. This is not the least expensive option by any measure; however, you'll spend close to the same $$$ at the concessions in a very hectic, unattractive atmosphere while sweating in line. Shout out to Amanda, Elise, Kim, and the other great staff who have made this my go-to place before Yankee games. Kudos!
Tina
Food was excellent. Just expected it to be more special. Server wasn't that friendly and the restaurant didn't even acknowledge we were celebrating a birthday. Was kind of a let down
Eugene
Food was priced right! great food at great value, however they get you on the alcohol drinks$25 per drink..... eating in a restaurant you should pay restaurant prices not stadium prices for alcohol 
Stopped in during the rain delay, ate some steak. It was good. In fact, it was best part of the night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dry Aged NY Strip Steak
Kerry
Raw Bar Tower was excellent. Candied bacon was very fatty, accompanying frisee/apple salad was very tasty. NY strip steak was tough and fatty. Truffle fries were horrible, tasted like frozen shoestrings. Grilled asparagus were very tough and hard to cut. Overall, average, but for the price, not good at all. But we didn't care, Yankees won. Not sure if I'll be back though.
EDDIE
I have had a meal on several occasions at this venue and the value value that it has it's primarily it's location at the yankees stadium. The food is very good but overpriced. The service staff try their best and some of them are not well trained. For example removing some of the place with food on the place without asking if we were finished.
It is a nice place, pleasant and comfortable in location, the annoying thing about this is the high volume of the TV screens makes people have to talk very loud and even shout. Even the TV in the men's room was so loud that there was no way to control it... The waiters and assistants try to do the best they can. The waiting time was longer than expected and the food was at room temperature, the ribeye was well done and very burnt, it had a burnt grill taste, we had to eat it because we had already lost time to enjoy the baseball game. Despite this, our waiter tried to do the best for our comfort. We would like to return but to have a better experience as to if they take a little while with our food at least it is good cuisine.
Kenneth
Medium rare steak came out well-done. A runner got on it quickly. Lobster tail was overcooked and tough. Crab cakes were delicious. Wouldn't change a thing with them. Wine selection was very good, even by the glass. Beer choices also very good. Waitress was mostly absent. They are very lacking in their side options... only one straight veg, asparagus. How about Brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, green beans. Several carb sides but only one straight healthy vegetable.
Great experience all around. Showed up without a reservation about 10 minutes before the start of a division series game and was able to get a table. the Hostess was very polite and ensured we got a table near a TV. The waiter was very knowledgeable of the menu and efficient with getting us in and out to get to the game. The Bison meatball appetizer was very tasty and the 20 oz ribeye was cooked perfectly. I particularly liked how it had a dark crunchy crust on the outside which gave it that extra flavor. Looking forward to coming back to try some other appetizers and desserts. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Mashed Potatoes, Steak Dinner, French Fries Side
I want to thank Stephanie my waiter for making our dinner more than pleasant, she was amazing and very attentive. Also wanted to thank Jayson for checking in on us every so often making sure everything was alright in our table, and I notice he does it with all the guests as well. I mention this because it’s those little details that often go unnoticed that makes the entire dinning experience a pleasant one.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tomahaw Steak, Lobster Mac & Cheese
Outstanding. Service and food is continually consistent. Not an easy task. This restaurant has really become my family's happy place when visiting the stadium. Thank you to the staff for always being so accommodating.
The steak was cooked perfectly! Shrimp cocktail was delicious. 10/10 recommend coming here with your family before the game. Great memories were made.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really enjoyed our first visit to NYY-Steakhouse. Food was very good; as was service and ambiance. The only issue was one of our filets was overcooked. For sake of game time we did not return it. It was still tasty. The corn fritters were the favorite for all. We also appreciated the size of the truffle fries order. Overall was very enjoyable. It was a birthday treat dinner. We will likely be back.
Nice restaurant with very good food and ambience. Service was good, attentive up through the order, water glasses were not refilled when low and getting the attention of the wait staff was a bit difficult, however it was quite busy. That being said all entrees are à la carte, and prices are a bit high so I would have expected more attention to the water, a missing plate and a mixup on a side ordered.
NYY Steak is a “must visit” at Yankee Stadium. Great food, great service and some of the nicest Yankee fans in the world. A good chance at seeing some Yankee Alumni and/or celebrities. Somewhat expensive, so only go for special occasions, but worth every penny. Steaks and the Seafood Tower were outstanding! Everyone is welcome here!
Great atmosphere capturing the history and spirit of the Yankees. I used to be quite critical of this place as I found the food salty and the service to be lax in the past. HOWEVER, I've noted a distinct improvement across the board in recent years. The staff is personable, attentive and very service-oriented. The shrimp are my go-to appetizer. This is not the least expensive option by any measure; however, you'll spend close to the same $$$ at the concessions in a very hectic, unattractive atmosphere while sweating in line. Shout out to Amanda, Elise, Kim, and the other great staff who have made this my go-to place before Yankee games. Kudos!
Food was excellent. Just expected it to be more special. Server wasn't that friendly and the restaurant didn't even acknowledge we were celebrating a birthday. Was kind of a let down
Food was priced right! great food at great value, however they get you on the alcohol drinks$25 per drink..... eating in a restaurant you should pay restaurant prices not stadium prices for alcohol 
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in during the rain delay, ate some steak. It was good. In fact, it was best part of the night!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Dry Aged NY Strip Steak
Raw Bar Tower was excellent. Candied bacon was very fatty, accompanying frisee/apple salad was very tasty. NY strip steak was tough and fatty. Truffle fries were horrible, tasted like frozen shoestrings. Grilled asparagus were very tough and hard to cut. Overall, average, but for the price, not good at all. But we didn't care, Yankees won. Not sure if I'll be back though.
I have had a meal on several occasions at this venue and the value value that it has it's primarily it's location at the yankees stadium. The food is very good but overpriced. The service staff try their best and some of them are not well trained. For example removing some of the place with food on the place without asking if we were finished.
It is a nice place, pleasant and comfortable in location, the annoying thing about this is the high volume of the TV screens makes people have to talk very loud and even shout. Even the TV in the men's room was so loud that there was no way to control it... The waiters and assistants try to do the best they can. The waiting time was longer than expected and the food was at room temperature, the ribeye was well done and very burnt, it had a burnt grill taste, we had to eat it because we had already lost time to enjoy the baseball game. Despite this, our waiter tried to do the best for our comfort. We would like to return but to have a better experience as to if they take a little while with our food at least it is good cuisine.
Medium rare steak came out well-done. A runner got on it quickly. Lobster tail was overcooked and tough. Crab cakes were delicious. Wouldn't change a thing with them. Wine selection was very good, even by the glass. Beer choices also very good. Waitress was mostly absent. They are very lacking in their side options... only one straight veg, asparagus. How about Brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes, green beans. Several carb sides but only one straight healthy vegetable.
Loading...