Pugsley Pizza

590 E 191st St, Bronx
(718) 365-0327

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wanda Leon

Nice place to eat with the family. The pizza was delicious and the spaghetti and meat balls was awesome. The atmosphere was good peaceful and quiet. The service was excellent the staff was nice and friendly. The price was reasonable. I loved all the pictures on the walls. They were familiar faces and family oriented. I ordered peperoni and cheese. It was nice thin and crispy and delicious. It taste it like the pizza from my childhood and teenage years. The owner was very friendly. The spaghetti was delicious The sauce was great and the meatballs nice and big.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cake Viking

Great food, very warming and welcoming!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carl Bradley

Rustic college pizzaria next to Fordham Univ. Eclectic armosphere with wooden bench booths. Had pepperoni slices and garlic knots with can of soda = $16. I wanted to like it but both dishes were bland and disappointing. Little to no seasoning on the pizza/pepperoni, with somewhat mushy dough. Acompanying marinara sauce was thin and didn't stick to the knots when dipped. I only ate 1. Friendly service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Abi Thapa

Walked in to find that the place, despite its somewhat questionable exterior, was actually very spacious and cozily decorated inside, which was a very pleasant surprise. The pizza was delicious and the owner's friendly, jokey demeanor just added to the experience. Will definitely go again if I get the chance!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

J J

Great food Great Portions will do catering with them again.
The half tray meat and plan lasagna was very delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M R

Feels like family. Best pizza in the Bronx

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ruel Johnson

Very old school looking place. Quite charming, kinda like being transported back in time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Arjay Estrella

Went here recently and it's now one of my favorite pizza spots in NYC. Highly recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christos Stilianessis

First time there — what a great experience! The owner, this friendly older gentleman, even invited me behind the counter to bang on their bong. What a blast!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nhi Hoang

Humongous slices and the loveliest people working there!!

We got a whole penne vodka pizza and it took us 4 meals to finish, so worth the money.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Penne Alla Vodka Pizza

PAUL KOREN

Good pizza... friendly owners

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Haley Bibee

Delicious and affordable!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Briscola

This is a place that is above and beyond just a pizza place

The owners the history behind them are just incredibly sweet

And pizza is delicious

Crisp light and delightful

Bravissimi…ci vediamo presto

Thanks for sharing the gong and the vibes

Federico

Michael Camerino

Best pizza in the Bronx, great prices, comfortable atmosphere.

Eddie Pejcinovic

TWILIGHT ZONE!!!! O.M.G MY UNCLES SON FROM ORIGINAL ARTHUR AVE. BROUGHT ME HERE I SAID NO WAY ITS NOT HIM SAME NAME I WAS WRONG I WALK IN AND I SEE SO DECORATED PIZZA STORE LIKE NO OTHER THEN ON MY LEFT I SEE A MAN HIS BACK ON SAXOPHONE SINGING HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO A STUDENT, THEN I HEAR A GONG PIZZA MAN HITTING A GIANT GONG L.M.A.O NEVER U SEE THIS ANYWHERE!! I CANT BELIEVE ITS SAL PUGSLEY!!! IM 50 NOW LETS GO TO 1982 IM AT P.S 246 ACROSS THE STREET FROM POE PARK GRAND CONCOURSE 196ST BRONX ITS TUESDAY !!!! YEAH. RIGHT AFTER SCHOOL HUNDREDS OF US WILL RUN TO PUGSLEY PIZZA 196 BRIGGS AVE. FOR 2 SLICES AND FOUNTAIN SODA FOR 1.OO YES ONE DOLLAR ,WHEN I GOT THERE LINE WAS 2 BLOCKS. GUESS OTHER FAMOUS PEOPLE WHO WORKED THERE WAS TONY AND BROTHER HILL NOW FAMOUS FAMAILIA PIZZAS NYC , ALSO MARTIN OF BEDFORD PARK PIZZA, OTHERS , SAL WAS ALSO BEFORE AT 194 ST VALENTINE AVE. BLOCK UP , I CANT BELIEVE I FOUND SAL AKA PUGSLEY !! HE REMEMBERS ME EDDIE CUZ FROM DA BRONX. PIZZA IS SO GOOD HIDDEN ON 3 BLOCK STREET BEHIND FORDHAM UNIVERSITY ONE BLOCK NORTH OF FORDHAM ROAD FEELS LIKE U IN RIVERDALE OR WESTCHESTER QUIET DEAD END STREETS.

Loading...