🎉✨ 20+ Years of Delicious Memories! ✨🎉 City Island Seashore Restaurant has been my go-to for over two decades, and they outdid themselves for my mother’s 75th birthday on August 9, 2025! 🥳💛 From the mouthwatering food to the warm, top-notch service, everything was absolutely magnificent. Thank you for making this milestone celebration unforgettable! 💐🍽️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dahye Lee
I was very satisfied with my visit. It’s rare to meet such a friendly server in New York, and both the food and the server’s kindness made it a memorable experience. My thanks to the lovely lady who served us by the window facing the parking lot. As for the food, the grilled fish was excellent, while the oysters were just okay. The portion of the risotto was enormous—it definitely felt worth the price. I would be happy to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Allie Burgess-Graham
Excellent place for family and friends 🧡
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ian
Great food, and lots of it! The relish and bread to start was delicious and the meals were very good!
Maritza Rivera
Was there for a Retirement party. Service was great. Lots of great selection that was tasty. Large portions. Wait Staff were very attentive. Only draw back, very warm day and there was no a.c.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eve
You can't beat the location on the water. Their valet service is really helpful as there is not much street parking. Go for great food and generous portions.
Luis Rodriguez
Some of the best seafood I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vic Kowal
Sea Shore Restaurant has a large variety of options on their menu. From raw to fried seafood and steak for those who don’t like sea food. The cocktail menu is extensive as well. I had the hazeltini - very sweet dessert martini. I had ordered the raw oysters, hot sea food app for two, and the fried calamari. You get your bang for your buck. Don’t be thrown off by the prices because you will leave very satisfied. !! They bring out complimentary bread (corn bread, garlic bread, and an entire roll) as well as some pickled snacks (roasted peppers, mushrooms, carrots, olives, eggplant, and some more.) !! I thought this touch was lovely to the experience. We went on a Saturday at around 1pm. At this point there was no wait or rush so we were taken to our table immediately. Outdoor dining is splendid as you get to sit by the water.
Richard Pak
The branzino was amazing. Bread was nice and warm and the wine to pair was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
linda
Super nice excellent value delicious food We were 6vwomen for lunch and it was everything we wanted
This place was very anticlimactic! I had the baby back ribs with jumbo fried shrimp. The ribs was great, the shrimp tho🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 tasted like it was straight out a nasty dirty fish tank. Felt like I’ll get sick if I ate any more. The calamari tasted so weird! Like literal deep fried tires😩 DONT USE THE TABLE SALT ! LOOK INSIDE THE CAP ITS NASTY!!!!!!! And the flies 😂 felt like I was being attacked. My husband had to keep swiping them away with the menu. What an experience 😂😂😂
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Donna Sabatino
Great food. G
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Loiacono
Wait just recommended the small lobster tails instead of the large lobster tail. I didn't like the taste wasn't Worth the price
David
First time here in many years. Convenient meeting place for one person coming from southern Westchester and the other coming from Queens. Water setting is delightful. Outside dining options are plentiful. Place is a little pricey for not being a fine dining operation. Many many food choices here, both seafood (as expected) and other things. Multiple varieties of fish available in every preparation a diner could want. The fish actually was the best part of the meal - except for the bread. The bread selection they bring out as soon as seated is magnificent. Fresh and high quality. Sets the tone for the rest of the meal. Classic mojito was ordinary. Mozzarella sticks no better or different than any tavern. Salads were fine, if undistinguished. Baked potato was enormous. And onion rings were quite poor. No room for dessert after that meal. I would return for the waterside ambience. Actually could see the World Trade Center in the far distance from my seat. One other thing. The noise level of the restaurant itself was quiet. But for outdoor diners, the entire meal was distinctively punctuated by activities at the NYC Police Department firing range at Rodman's Neck, just across the narrow bay from the restaurant marina. No, Jose we're not firecrackers. They were rapid fire gunshots.
Dr. Danielle Bryant
We gathered here for my mother's 70th birthday. This has been her favorite place for over a decade!
⸻
🎉✨ 20+ Years of Delicious Memories! ✨🎉
City Island Seashore Restaurant has been my go-to for over two decades, and they outdid themselves for my mother’s 75th birthday on August 9, 2025! 🥳💛 From the mouthwatering food to the warm, top-notch service, everything was absolutely magnificent. Thank you for making this milestone celebration unforgettable! 💐🍽️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was very satisfied with my visit. It’s rare to meet such a friendly server in New York, and both the food and the server’s kindness made it a memorable experience. My thanks to the lovely lady who served us by the window facing the parking lot. As for the food, the grilled fish was excellent, while the oysters were just okay. The portion of the risotto was enormous—it definitely felt worth the price. I would be happy to visit again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Excellent place for family and friends 🧡
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, and lots of it! The relish and bread to start was delicious and the meals were very good!
Was there for a Retirement party. Service was great. Lots of great selection that was tasty. Large portions. Wait Staff were very attentive. Only draw back, very warm day and there was no a.c.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
You can't beat the location on the water. Their valet service is really helpful as there is not much street parking. Go for great food and generous portions.
Some of the best seafood I’ve ever had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sea Shore Restaurant has a large variety of options on their menu. From raw to fried seafood and steak for those who don’t like sea food. The cocktail menu is extensive as well. I had the hazeltini - very sweet dessert martini.
I had ordered the raw oysters, hot sea food app for two, and the fried calamari. You get your bang for your buck. Don’t be thrown off by the prices because you will leave very satisfied.
!! They bring out complimentary bread (corn bread, garlic bread, and an entire roll) as well as some pickled snacks (roasted peppers, mushrooms, carrots, olives, eggplant, and some more.) !!
I thought this touch was lovely to the experience.
We went on a Saturday at around 1pm. At this point there was no wait or rush so we were taken to our table immediately. Outdoor dining is splendid as you get to sit by the water.
The branzino was amazing. Bread was nice and warm and the wine to pair was great.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super nice excellent value delicious food We were 6vwomen for lunch and it was everything we wanted
Restaurantji Recommends
This place was very anticlimactic! I had the baby back ribs with jumbo fried shrimp. The ribs was great, the shrimp tho🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮 tasted like it was straight out a nasty dirty fish tank. Felt like I’ll get sick if I ate any more. The calamari tasted so weird! Like literal deep fried tires😩 DONT USE THE TABLE SALT ! LOOK INSIDE THE CAP ITS NASTY!!!!!!! And the flies 😂 felt like I was being attacked. My husband had to keep swiping them away with the menu. What an experience 😂😂😂
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Great food. G
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wait just recommended the small lobster tails instead of the large lobster tail. I didn't like the taste wasn't Worth the price
First time here in many years. Convenient meeting place for one person coming from southern Westchester and the other coming from Queens. Water setting is delightful. Outside dining options are plentiful. Place is a little pricey for not being a fine dining operation. Many many food choices here, both seafood (as expected) and other things. Multiple varieties of fish available in every preparation a diner could want. The fish actually was the best part of the meal - except for the bread. The bread selection they bring out as soon as seated is magnificent. Fresh and high quality. Sets the tone for the rest of the meal. Classic mojito was ordinary. Mozzarella sticks no better or different than any tavern. Salads were fine, if undistinguished. Baked potato was enormous. And onion rings were quite poor. No room for dessert after that meal. I would return for the waterside ambience. Actually could see the World Trade Center in the far distance from my seat. One other thing. The noise level of the restaurant itself was quiet. But for outdoor diners, the entire meal was distinctively punctuated by activities at the NYC Police Department firing range at Rodman's Neck, just across the narrow bay from the restaurant marina. No, Jose we're not firecrackers. They were rapid fire gunshots.
We gathered here for my mother's 70th birthday. This has been her favorite place for over a decade!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...