Great service. When we arrived we were seated right away. Our waiter was amazing and very attentive. I highly recommend the seafood extravaganza broiled of course. It was perfectly seasoned and cooked. The penne ala vodka with shrimp was also delicious. Let's not forget about the platter of different breads and also the platter of peppers, olives, eggplant, and cheese; this is all complimentary and also very delicious. We were there on Valentine's Day which is usually a crazy and uncomfortable day to go to eat especially with a toddler but this place was perfect. Very organized and attentive. 10/10 highly recommend
Bella Bisono
I had a great experience at Sea Shore in City Island. Our waiter, Khan, was extremely kind and provided excellent service. Even though the menu prices were a bit high, he took the time to recommend the best and most affordable options for me and the people I was with. I really appreciated his honesty and attention. He even gave my daughter a free dessert, which was such a nice and thoughtful gesture. Everything was great, and Khan truly made our visit special. I would definitely come back because of the amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Teena Phillips
The food was amazingly fresh and the portion sizes were large so you got your money's worth.....the wait staff were attentive and kind ....the ambiance was calm and inviting....all in all a great place to eat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaitlyn Smith
The food and service is excellent. Great for group events.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carlos Ramirez
Hey, I just gotta brag about My borough's best seaside experience - whether you visit on your own or with family or friends! Whatever you order is Top Notch, so sitšŖ back and BREATHE SLOW. OH, the folks that keep an eye out for your comfort - TIP THEM GOOD Cause they treat you like family. Just say hello on the way in to the mgr for me please. š. Enjoy y'all and be blessed š. Carlos R.
Atmosphere: 5
Francis Alberts
Went for my son's birthday and had a wonderful time. Everyone was very nice and service was excellent. The food was only so-so, but the atmosphere made up for it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Melissa
We had a wonderful time for moms 80th The entire staff was so friendly accommodating - looking forward to many more trips to City Island
Lashanti Williams
Very good good!!
Michaelangelo Tabrizi
āļøāļøāļøāļøāļø FIVE-STAR REVIEW
My family and I have been coming to Seashore Restaurant on City Island for over 20 years, and it remains one of our favorite places anywhere. Everything weāve ordered throughout the years has always been excellent. A lot of restaurants have good seafood, but even now that we live an hour and a half away, we still come here at least once a month ā not just for the food, but mostly because of the service.
The entire staff is consistently kind, compassionate, and professional. They are the reason we look forward to coming back again and again. Special thank you to Debbie, the manager, and to Mani, one of the servers, who have both been there for over 20 years and always make us feel like family.
Thank you, Seashore Restaurant, for so many happy memories over the years. We appreciate you more than you know. Ps. Last but not least, I forgot to put the general managers name that he's always there and plays a big part with everything running so smoothly and his name is John.š
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alicia Sotomayor
The service is great. Everyone is very nice and the food was delicious. Will be returning again. Thank you so much.
Really enjoyed the place. It was great will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
YOUSSOUF AIZIK
Very expensive food but it's NY everything is high there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Ziobro
The Thanksgiving takeout dinner SUCKED!!! It was Stuffing with Bone Scraps of fatā¦ couldnāt even see where the meat wasā¦.Itās more like junior baby food for a nine month old childā¦. felt sick and threw it out. I wouldnāt even use this meat to make a turkey soup Thanks for ruining my Thanksgiving dinner for two!!! This is what we receivedā¦ one order of dark meat & one order of white meat, can you tell the difference?!ā¦. The dark meat in on the bottom of this photo. On the right side photo is a stuffed mushroom stuffed with whatever this is in the rest of the photo I have been to this restaurant from time to time for over 40 yearsā¦ how dare you serve the dog food to your loyal customersā¦. I donāt believe itās safe to even give this to my dog, itās nothing but fat off the bone
Donald Brown
Excellent food. Great service. The servers are very friendly and outgoing. They go out of their way to help. Best Seafood place on City Island. A favorite place when visiting back to NY.
Esther Acquah
I had a terrible experience at this restaurant. Theyāre thieves. I ate and paid $153.31 and gave the waiter cash tip because I needed the receipt for documentation, but they decided to add an extra tip of $26.69, rounding the money to $180. My advice is that you CHECK your account when you go there. Iām not going there again
Great service. When we arrived we were seated right away. Our waiter was amazing and very attentive. I highly recommend the seafood extravaganza broiled of course. It was perfectly seasoned and cooked. The penne ala vodka with shrimp was also delicious. Let's not forget about the platter of different breads and also the platter of peppers, olives, eggplant, and cheese; this is all complimentary and also very delicious. We were there on Valentine's Day which is usually a crazy and uncomfortable day to go to eat especially with a toddler but this place was perfect. Very organized and attentive. 10/10 highly recommend
I had a great experience at Sea Shore in City Island. Our waiter, Khan, was extremely kind and provided excellent service. Even though the menu prices were a bit high, he took the time to recommend the best and most affordable options for me and the people I was with. I really appreciated his honesty and attention. He even gave my daughter a free dessert, which was such a nice and thoughtful gesture. Everything was great, and Khan truly made our visit special. I would definitely come back because of the amazing service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was amazingly fresh and the portion sizes were large so you got your money's worth.....the wait staff were attentive and kind ....the ambiance was calm and inviting....all in all a great place to eat!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food and service is excellent. Great for group events.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hey, I just gotta brag about My borough's best seaside experience - whether you visit on your own or with family or friends! Whatever you order is Top Notch, so sitšŖ back and BREATHE SLOW. OH, the folks that keep an eye out for your comfort - TIP THEM GOOD Cause they treat you like family. Just say hello on the way in to the mgr for me please. š. Enjoy y'all and be blessed š. Carlos R.
Atmosphere: 5
Went for my son's birthday and had a wonderful time. Everyone was very nice and service was excellent. The food was only so-so, but the atmosphere made up for it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
We had a wonderful time for moms 80th The entire staff was so friendly accommodating - looking forward to many more trips to City Island
Very good good!!
āļøāļøāļøāļøāļø FIVE-STAR REVIEW
My family and I have been coming to Seashore Restaurant on City Island for over 20 years, and it remains one of our favorite places anywhere. Everything weāve ordered throughout the years has always been excellent. A lot of restaurants have good seafood, but even now that we live an hour and a half away, we still come here at least once a month ā not just for the food, but mostly because of the service.
The entire staff is consistently kind, compassionate, and professional. They are the reason we look forward to coming back again and again. Special thank you to Debbie, the manager, and to Mani, one of the servers, who have both been there for over 20 years and always make us feel like family.
Thank you, Seashore Restaurant, for so many happy memories over the years. We appreciate you more than you know.
Ps. Last but not least, I forgot to put the general managers name that he's always there and plays a big part with everything running so smoothly and his name is John.š
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service is great. Everyone is very nice and the food was delicious. Will be returning again. Thank you so much.
Restaurantji Recommends
Really enjoyed the place. It was great will return.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very expensive food but it's NY everything is high there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Thanksgiving takeout dinner SUCKED!!! It was Stuffing with Bone Scraps of fatā¦ couldnāt even see where the meat wasā¦.Itās more like junior baby food for a nine month old childā¦. felt sick and threw it out. I wouldnāt even use this meat to make a turkey soup
Thanks for ruining my Thanksgiving dinner for two!!!
This is what we receivedā¦ one order of dark meat & one order of white meat, can you tell the difference?!ā¦. The dark meat in on the bottom of this photo. On the right side photo is a stuffed mushroom stuffed with whatever this is in the rest of the photo
I have been to this restaurant from time to time for over 40 yearsā¦ how dare you serve the dog food to your loyal customersā¦. I donāt believe itās safe to even give this to my dog, itās nothing but fat off the bone
Excellent food. Great service. The servers are very friendly and outgoing. They go out of their way to help. Best Seafood place on City Island. A favorite place when visiting back to NY.
I had a terrible experience at this restaurant. Theyāre thieves. I ate and paid $153.31 and gave the waiter cash tip because I needed the receipt for documentation, but they decided to add an extra tip of $26.69, rounding the money to $180. My advice is that you CHECK your account when you go there. Iām not going there again
Loading...