The Snug and City Island Diner are true local treasures. They’re owned by the same wonderful people and share a kitchen, but each has its own vibe and hours — and together they’re unbeatable.
The fully loaded chili here is hands-down the best I’ve ever had. It’s rich, hearty, perfectly seasoned, and also shows up in their nachos, which makes them next-level comfort food.
One of my favorite things? They have a secret menu (no longer advertised) with specialty grilled cheese sandwiches and specialty hot dogs — and we absolutely love it. The Tuscan Melt (no onion) is perfection, and the Reuben Dog is unforgettable. With the hot dogs you get two, and you can mix and match styles, which is such a fun and generous touch.
At The Snug, my go-to drink is a black & tan, which pairs perfectly with the cozy, neighborhood pub feel. Over at the diner, my favorite dish is the Corned Beef Hash breakfast — classic, satisfying, and done exactly right.
Beyond the food, what really sets these places apart is the people. Every server is genuinely kind, welcoming, and deeply plugged into the City Island community. You feel like a regular even on your first visit.
Great food, great people, and real local character. City Island wouldn’t be the same without them. 💙🍽️🍺
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pete on the go!
Fun place. Good vibes for a bite.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
wilmer rodriguez
Best bar in city island drinks are reasonable and food perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Malerba
This place is so much fun!
Atmosphere: 5
walter Thorne
A small pub with all the good feels dont go there looking for a good Teqiula , but to have a conversation. Buy a pint for a stranger or if your really lucky to meet an incredlible beautiful soul and Dog walker.
Corinne
My go to spot when visiting city island! Friendly service and great drinks!
Shepherd’s pie without a crust, $20 for mashed potatoes over a layer of hamburger meat w/ pea and carrots. (charged me $2 for asking for bread) Atmosphere : the Beer maid is dating a 55 yo, father has Cancer and mother is vague but seems to be contentious…. A lot of old people just walking in and out I wanted to enjoy it given all the Pride Flags but I was really disappointed and if I went back to Ireland and told them about this dish called Shepherds Pie in America they would die of a heart attack
We arrived early for dinner. Service was quick. The food was tasty, and portions were large. I had enough for lunch the next day.
Parking: We were early on a week day in February, so parking was simple. I am sure it can get difficult on weekends and during the summer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Panini
Michael Farrell
Great cozy pub to enjoy on a rainy afternoon! Very attentive staff, clean bathroom, excellent food and good sized menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Margo M
The Snug is terrific. The staff & owners make everyone feel welcome. We’ve watched sporting events there, and we always meet nice people. Our daughter goes to university in New York & we stay on City Island when we go to visit her. Every evening we head to The Snug for dinner or for drinks at the end of evening. It’s always fun at The Snug.
Michael Sobkow
Favorite hangout on city island
Miguel Quinones
It was a good place for lunch. The food was good and it was a welcoming atmosphere. The drinks was also satisfying. Will definitely back when I'm in the area.
The Snug and City Island Diner are true local treasures. They’re owned by the same wonderful people and share a kitchen, but each has its own vibe and hours — and together they’re unbeatable.
The fully loaded chili here is hands-down the best I’ve ever had. It’s rich, hearty, perfectly seasoned, and also shows up in their nachos, which makes them next-level comfort food.
One of my favorite things? They have a secret menu (no longer advertised) with specialty grilled cheese sandwiches and specialty hot dogs — and we absolutely love it. The Tuscan Melt (no onion) is perfection, and the Reuben Dog is unforgettable. With the hot dogs you get two, and you can mix and match styles, which is such a fun and generous touch.
At The Snug, my go-to drink is a black & tan, which pairs perfectly with the cozy, neighborhood pub feel. Over at the diner, my favorite dish is the Corned Beef Hash breakfast — classic, satisfying, and done exactly right.
Beyond the food, what really sets these places apart is the people. Every server is genuinely kind, welcoming, and deeply plugged into the City Island community. You feel like a regular even on your first visit.
Great food, great people, and real local character. City Island wouldn’t be the same without them. 💙🍽️🍺
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fun place. Good vibes for a bite.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Best bar in city island drinks are reasonable and food perfect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is so much fun!
Atmosphere: 5
A small pub with all the good feels dont go there looking for a good Teqiula , but to have a conversation. Buy a pint for a stranger or if your really lucky to meet an incredlible beautiful soul and Dog walker.
My go to spot when visiting city island! Friendly service and great drinks!
It's a bar....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Excellent Chicken Caesar Salad!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Crispy Chicken Salad, Cheeseburger Deluxe, Homemade Chicken Salad
Shepherd’s pie without a crust, $20 for mashed potatoes over a layer of hamburger meat w/ pea and carrots. (charged me $2 for asking for bread)
Atmosphere : the Beer maid is dating a 55 yo, father has Cancer and mother is vague but seems to be contentious…. A lot of old people just walking in and out I wanted to enjoy it given all the Pride Flags but I was really disappointed and if I went back to Ireland and told them about this dish called Shepherds Pie in America they would die of a heart attack
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Great cozy spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
We arrived early for dinner. Service was quick. The food was tasty, and portions were large. I had enough for lunch the next day.
Parking: We were early on a week day in February, so parking was simple. I am sure it can get difficult on weekends and during the summer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Panini
Great cozy pub to enjoy on a rainy afternoon! Very attentive staff, clean bathroom, excellent food and good sized menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Snug is terrific. The staff & owners make everyone feel welcome. We’ve watched sporting events there, and we always meet nice people. Our daughter goes to university in New York & we stay on City Island when we go to visit her. Every evening we head to The Snug for dinner or for drinks at the end of evening. It’s always fun at The Snug.
Favorite hangout on city island
It was a good place for lunch. The food was good and it was a welcoming atmosphere. The drinks was also satisfying. Will definitely back when I'm in the area.
Loading...