I’m not judging the food because I haven’t tried it, but my negative feedback goes to the service and the atmosphere. I moved to the area from Italy 4 years ago, and one day I was curious to try the pizza here. I went in and started looking at the options, but the person behind the counter became impatient, even though there was no one else in line. I asked about one pizza, and he replied, “This is a Margherita.” I said, “Sorry, what?” because it didn’t look like a Margherita at all, and he responded, “Have you ever had a Margherita in your life? Do you know how it’s made?”
I’m Italian, so I’ve probably had more Margheritas in one month than he’s had in his entire career. Maybe he doesn’t know how a Margherita should look like. His tone was really rude, and I decided to leave.
I happened to run into my neighbor on my way home, and they recommended a different pizzeria on Pondfield Rd where the pizza is not only good, but the staff are friendly too. The pizza at Full Moon might be good, but because of my experience, I didn’t feel welcome enough to give it a try.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
LEVIATHAN
Came here for lunch I ordered 2 slices of pizza peppers and sausage it really want good restaurant was clean but the staff looked mad
D.C.P for real
“Not a Fan “ one slice of pizza is so Salty you need three bottles of water with it that’s probably what they want . They are living off the legacy of previous owners.
Dietary restrictions: Be careful eating from this pizza place too much salt is in there food.
Parking: Great location
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Izzy P
Friday date night. We both love pizza and had been meaning to try this spot for a while. The place was not too busy and tables were available. Menu is more or less typical pizza shop menu. We ordered a few things to get a good feel for the food. Everything was very good. The service was great - there were a couple of people that were welcoming and personable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Johnny Santiago Jr.
The food was delicious and the staff were friendly and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
casandra tolentino
We got some takeout today but the only thing that was good was the pizza pie. I will admit, very good. The rest though was not. The potato croquette barely had potato (almost all cheese which was odd), the penne vodka was inedible, the minestrone and pasta fagiole were bland. Really really disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Walter Faust
I do not like to leave unflattering reviews, but I simply have to comment on my order. I ordered a regular 16 inch pizza and a meat calzone. The pizza arrive, looking like it was jammed into the box. It had more folds than a used one dollar bill. The flavor was blasé. The calzone was burnt on the outside. I will never order from here again.
Food: 1
Cameron Keady
I love this place - it’s become my go-to for pizza since I moved to the area. The chicken parm slice, bbq slice and classic pepperoni are my favorites. Garlic knots are awesome, too! Everyone who works there is so nice and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mohammed Nofal
It’s my second time here and I really love their wings and pizza ima just go there from now on the pizza and wings ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Rodriguez
One of the worst tasting pizzas I’ve ever tasted, they must be cutting back on the cheese and sauce. It left an awful after taste, big disappointment nothing like the one in the Bronx. The place was empty, now I understand why.
I must say that I was truly disappointed in the slice of plain cheese pizza that I purchased from this place. Not only was the slice over $4, but it was overheated, barely any cheese on it and lacked any flavor…big disappointment! I hadn’t eaten all day after visiting a sick friend in the hospital and decided to go across the street just for a simple slice of pizza…Highly disappointed. Nice place, good staff..just do better with the plain slices of pizza.
Elvis Oliveros' channel
I don’t know where to begin. This place stinks. I went there for the first time today after visiting an ill family member over at the hospital across the street. When I got in, it was around 8:45 PM. We asked for 3 slices of pizza which they had and they just heated it up. They got us our food around 8:53 and we were happy, we asked the owner if we could eat inside because he said they were closing at 9. He told us yes if it was quick, we agreed that we wouldn’t be there for more than 10 minutes as we were just eating one slice each. As soon as we paid, he said “I’m sorry guys you gotta go because we close at 9 and we still have to sweep”. First of all, he basically tricked us into thinking we can eat inside until after we paid and then he revealed his true colors. Second of all, if he is the owner, he should make the decision to let us stay for 5-10 minutes to eat one single slice of pizza and then leave. We were forced to eat pizza outside with no table and the owner and the crew left at 9:00 on the dot. He could’ve swept up while we ate our pizza and we would have been out of his hair by the max 9:05. This is not the right way to run a business, I have been to many many places before who lock the doors to not let customers in, but allow the customers who got in before closing to finish their business before leaving. I don’t understand why he had to kick us out and couldn’t wait an extra 5 minutes.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Vincent Parlante
I'm a 66 year old native born from the Bronx. Though not having lived there in the city for many many years? Back in 2005 my late Grandmother on my late father's side past away then in 2005 at the hospital there in Bronxville . One night while I was in the city then? My late father ? A cousin also now gone my brother's and myself sat one night in this wonderful restaurant. What a great experience for me it was that evening sitting and enjoying some great great food that was Mama Mia. The place was clean ? The decor fantastic... Service superb ? And did I mention how great the food was. Madone I honestly hope one day before I pass? To get back there once again to sit and enjoy a plate of delicious food that's literally a slice of heaven to this old guy capish? Anyway though it's been a few years since I was there? The memory of that experience is still engraved in my mind. Grazie mille huh? I live in Albuquerque N.M and though there are a few fellow New Yorkers here and some pizzarias and the places here are good such as Saggios? They aren't quite the same. I really enjoyed my evening in your establishment.
Justin Richard
First of all, this is some of the most "authentic" tasting Italian food that I've ever had. I only wish I was in the neighborhood more often. I'm a black man from OLD Brooklyn, and I know good pizza. But that's not even it my step-dad got pizza and I got a calzone. But... how do I... man, I'll just say it.
The people of Bronxville aren't the most BLACK-tolerant folk on the planet. Sorry, it's not my fault y'all are unfriendly. But THIS restaurant made me forget I was IN a town like this.
My mom was here for a complicated back surgery. My step-dad and I were look-out for something fast to eat while we waited. I found the place by accident while I was smoking a cigarette.
And when we got in, I felt like family. Normally, if it's something fast and small like a slice and calzone, you pay immediately. But our server/cashier wouldn't even accept our money until we finished eating. Brought the food to a table for us and the whole nine. Made us feel welcomed. That was big.
And the food? Phenomenal! Fresh, great portions, and while I know that all restaurants, regardless of theme or menu, some hardworking Hispanic people are usually cooking... unless it's a Chinese food restaurant.. but the food still made you feel like you were on Capri. They're using SOME Italian grandmother's recipe(s), and it SHOWS.
THANK you to the gentleman that served us. I appreciate(d) not being stared at and whispered about for a little while in this town.
Lunch, dinner, SOUP... come here. I PROMISE you it's worth it. Get the chicken parm (it looked amazing) or pizza, or zeppoles, soups, sandwiches.
Come. Here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Baked Ziti, New England Clam Chowder, Meatball Parm Hero, Regular Pizza, Caesar Salad, Tiramisu, Chicken Scarpariello, Spaghetti Garlic & Oil, Cannoli, Mozzarella Sticks
Peter Uliano
Great food and great, friendly people! You should definitely have a visit and enjoy some good NY style pizza!
I’m not judging the food because I haven’t tried it, but my negative feedback goes to the service and the atmosphere. I moved to the area from Italy 4 years ago, and one day I was curious to try the pizza here. I went in and started looking at the options, but the person behind the counter became impatient, even though there was no one else in line. I asked about one pizza, and he replied, “This is a Margherita.” I said, “Sorry, what?” because it didn’t look like a Margherita at all, and he responded, “Have you ever had a Margherita in your life? Do you know how it’s made?”
I’m Italian, so I’ve probably had more Margheritas in one month than he’s had in his entire career. Maybe he doesn’t know how a Margherita should look like. His tone was really rude, and I decided to leave.
I happened to run into my neighbor on my way home, and they recommended a different pizzeria on Pondfield Rd where the pizza is not only good, but the staff are friendly too. The pizza at Full Moon might be good, but because of my experience, I didn’t feel welcome enough to give it a try.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Came here for lunch I ordered 2 slices of pizza peppers and sausage it really want good restaurant was clean but the staff looked mad
“Not a Fan “ one slice of pizza is so Salty you need three bottles of water with it that’s probably what they want . They are living off the legacy of previous owners.
Dietary restrictions: Be careful eating from this pizza place too much salt is in there food.
Parking: Great location
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 3
Friday date night. We both love pizza and had been meaning to try this spot for a while. The place was not too busy and tables were available. Menu is more or less typical pizza shop menu. We ordered a few things to get a good feel for the food. Everything was very good. The service was great - there were a couple of people that were welcoming and personable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food was delicious and the staff were friendly and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
We got some takeout today but the only thing that was good was the pizza pie. I will admit, very good. The rest though was not. The potato croquette barely had potato (almost all cheese which was odd), the penne vodka was inedible, the minestrone and pasta fagiole were bland. Really really disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
I do not like to leave unflattering reviews, but I simply have to comment on my order. I ordered a regular 16 inch pizza and a meat calzone. The pizza arrive, looking like it was jammed into the box. It had more folds than a used one dollar bill. The flavor was blasé. The calzone was burnt on the outside. I will never order from here again.
Food: 1
I love this place - it’s become my go-to for pizza since I moved to the area. The chicken parm slice, bbq slice and classic pepperoni are my favorites. Garlic knots are awesome, too! Everyone who works there is so nice and friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s my second time here and I really love their wings and pizza ima just go there from now on the pizza and wings ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One of the worst tasting pizzas I’ve ever tasted, they must be cutting back on the cheese and sauce. It left an awful after taste, big disappointment nothing like the one in the Bronx. The place was empty, now I understand why.
Restaurantji Recommends
I must say that I was truly disappointed in the slice of plain cheese pizza that I purchased from this place. Not only was the slice over $4, but it was overheated, barely any cheese on it and lacked any flavor…big disappointment! I hadn’t eaten all day after visiting a sick friend in the hospital and decided to go across the street just for a simple slice of pizza…Highly disappointed. Nice place, good staff..just do better with the plain slices of pizza.
I don’t know where to begin. This place stinks. I went there for the first time today after visiting an ill family member over at the hospital across the street. When I got in, it was around 8:45 PM. We asked for 3 slices of pizza which they had and they just heated it up. They got us our food around 8:53 and we were happy, we asked the owner if we could eat inside because he said they were closing at 9. He told us yes if it was quick, we agreed that we wouldn’t be there for more than 10 minutes as we were just eating one slice each. As soon as we paid, he said “I’m sorry guys you gotta go because we close at 9 and we still have to sweep”. First of all, he basically tricked us into thinking we can eat inside until after we paid and then he revealed his true colors. Second of all, if he is the owner, he should make the decision to let us stay for 5-10 minutes to eat one single slice of pizza and then leave. We were forced to eat pizza outside with no table and the owner and the crew left at 9:00 on the dot. He could’ve swept up while we ate our pizza and we would have been out of his hair by the max 9:05. This is not the right way to run a business, I have been to many many places before who lock the doors to not let customers in, but allow the customers who got in before closing to finish their business before leaving. I don’t understand why he had to kick us out and couldn’t wait an extra 5 minutes.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
I'm a 66 year old native born from the Bronx. Though not having lived there in the city for many many years? Back in 2005 my late Grandmother on my late father's side past away then in 2005 at the hospital there in Bronxville . One night while I was in the city then? My late father ? A cousin also now gone my brother's and myself sat one night in this wonderful restaurant. What a great experience for me it was that evening sitting and enjoying some great great food that was Mama Mia. The place was clean ? The decor fantastic... Service superb ? And did I mention how great the food was. Madone I honestly hope one day before I pass? To get back there once again to sit and enjoy a plate of delicious food that's literally a slice of heaven to this old guy capish? Anyway though it's been a few years since I was there? The memory of that experience is still engraved in my mind. Grazie mille huh? I live in Albuquerque N.M and though there are a few fellow New Yorkers here and some pizzarias and the places here are good such as Saggios? They aren't quite the same. I really enjoyed my evening in your establishment.
First of all, this is some of the most "authentic" tasting Italian food that I've ever had. I only wish I was in the neighborhood more often. I'm a black man from OLD Brooklyn, and I know good pizza. But that's not even it my step-dad got pizza and I got a calzone. But... how do I... man, I'll just say it.
The people of Bronxville aren't the most BLACK-tolerant folk on the planet. Sorry, it's not my fault y'all are unfriendly. But THIS restaurant made me forget I was IN a town like this.
My mom was here for a complicated back surgery. My step-dad and I were look-out for something fast to eat while we waited. I found the place by accident while I was smoking a cigarette.
And when we got in, I felt like family. Normally, if it's something fast and small like a slice and calzone, you pay immediately. But our server/cashier wouldn't even accept our money until we finished eating. Brought the food to a table for us and the whole nine. Made us feel welcomed. That was big.
And the food? Phenomenal! Fresh, great portions, and while I know that all restaurants, regardless of theme or menu, some hardworking Hispanic people are usually cooking... unless it's a Chinese food restaurant.. but the food still made you feel like you were on Capri. They're using SOME Italian grandmother's recipe(s), and it SHOWS.
THANK you to the gentleman that served us. I appreciate(d) not being stared at and whispered about for a little while in this town.
Lunch, dinner, SOUP... come here. I PROMISE you it's worth it. Get the chicken parm (it looked amazing) or pizza, or zeppoles, soups, sandwiches.
Come. Here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm, Baked Ziti, New England Clam Chowder, Meatball Parm Hero, Regular Pizza, Caesar Salad, Tiramisu, Chicken Scarpariello, Spaghetti Garlic & Oil, Cannoli, Mozzarella Sticks
Great food and great, friendly people! You should definitely have a visit and enjoy some good NY style pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...