$1.25 Slice

534 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 240-3603

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stacey Gibbs

It was very good just no place to sit. Gotta take it to

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Khaled ElTokhy

The bad: the place is sketchy at night. The pizza is sometimes served “cold” unless you specifically ask for it to be left in the oven for longer or to be crispyThe good: pretty decent - really good dollar pizza. The prices can’t be beat. It’s open 24 hours. Service is extremely fast. The staff is friendly if you’re friendly to them.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Slice of Pizza

AllFather

If you're coming here after 11pm understand that the whole area is sketchy. Bums and addicts lurk inside and out. Panhandle are usually inside asking for money for food or just food...or just money.As to the food: what do you expect, Cipriani? The Park Regency for that power breakfast? Flemings? Listen, you are lucky they're even open after midnight for you to grab some unhealthy carbs & sugar. ? Take what they give you. The pizza crusts are a tad burnt, the beef patties taste a bit weird and I honestly miss when they sold hot dogs/hot sausages like they do in the Village which was the only draw they had for me years ago. The staff are nice guys, thus I gave them four stars.

Vegetarian options: Another silly question for such an establishment. Have you seen their menu? It's a pizza shop.

Dietary restrictions: What a silly question to ask of this establishment.

Kid-friendliness: Terrible place to BRING children. Their pizza pies are decent; just bring one home.

Wheelchair accessibility: Wide open double doors, so yes.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza, Pizza Toppings

keithinatlanta

don’t go late nite or you could get sprayed with acid in the face by homeless trying to extort you for $$ as 3 of us were last nite. when asked owner to call police he just shrugs shoulders,,, business as usual. New York is not safe place to visit.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Acerbic

It's very hot inside. Hasn't the owner of this place heard of air conditioning?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza

Megan Price

Such good slice of pie! Cheap, always warm - seriously one of the best simple authentic nyc pizza joints

Arner ermit

Not a 1.25, they will price hike you depending on the bill you present.

Jimminy Cricket

No complaints here, this place is always open and the pizza is decent enough. Try to pay with cash, otherwise you may get overcharged on card (they add tax via card, and the amount they charge depends on the cashier's mood that day)

Jeffrey Jones

1.25 B BEST AND CHEAPEST PIZZA ??? IN THE WHOLE WIDE WORLD!

Phil Smithback

One of the worst slices I've ever had the misfortune to try.

Lisa Strachan

My kids love the cheese pizza ?.

Eddie Q

STAY AWAY FROM THIS PIZZA PLACE I JUST BOUGHT 2 SLICES OF PIZZA TODAY A FEW MINUTES AGO THE PIZZA THEY SELL HERE IS HORRIBLE PIZZA IT HAS NO TASTE THEY SELL YOU OLD OLD PIZZA DONT COME HERE NOT WORTH IT FOR $1.25

The Subway Show

Provide Godzilla With Pizza.World Domination Is Imminent.Don't Buy Hot Dogs From Smelly People In Front Of A Jiffy Lube. Or The Jiffy Lube. Which You Later Find Out That Smelly Person Owns.

Gabriela Busmar

Very good slice for only $1! They are fast and people don’t stay here for long so it’s never that crowded.An observation is that when people eat on the counter they leave a mess and the staff don’t clean it either. So, I cleaned after myself and a man before me cleaned after himself too.

Jenny Kessler

Everyone is right, IT'S SO GOOD. I've lived in Brooklyn for 15 years and my boyfriend is a fancy chef and I swear this is some of the best pizza in town. I mean, it's dollar pizza, but it's freakin delicious! I lived around the corner and it was extremely extremely difficult to resist eating this every single day. I was vegan for 3 months and this is seriously one of the things I missed most. Now we moved to Vermont and I'm literally drooling thinking about this spot. Can't wait to go back.

Loading...