Supreme NY Pizza

297 Broadway A, Brooklyn
(347) 725-4005

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ryder Nelson

Inaccurate hours listed

Michael Mallinder-MacLeod

Very average. Probably the worst slice pizza I’ve had in NYC. But it’s not awful.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 4

Chase Rainey

“I have no change.” 10PM on a Saturday night? Have change for a $20.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

B M

The BEST pizza in the neighborhood!

Steven Todd Thaxton

This is the worst Pizza I think I've ever had. And I've had a lot. A total disservice to NY pizza. Not cooked. The worst crust I've EVER had. Ingredients were suspect. I ordered a Supreme and they sent me something like a Supreme with fried chicken. Asked for peppers and they sent none. The absolute worst.I think I'm switching to Indian after this

Dietary restrictions: I asked for a Supreme (no chicken) and they delivered a fried chicken pizza with half baked crust. Don't know about you but I'm not into ecoli

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tania Kabir

Vegetable slice tasted

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bd Pizza

Best pizza in Williamsburg

Vegetarian options: Vegetables Lover pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza

TLHyland

My husband and I went to the location just up from Times Square on Broadway. The worst pizza I've ever had. Oh and the $.99 per piece - it's only for a slice of cheese pizza. They added a dollar for each small piece of pepperoni on my slice - $3.99. That picture you see in Trip Advisor that looks like a luscious supreme pizza is to lure you in. Don't fall for it! Spend a little more $$ and get a decent slice from somewhere else!

Glendolffe Smith II

I liked their pizza!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Im ZeFyr

Pour le prix cest genial cest bon

scassidy50

We spent $160 on an average meal the night before. For $14 we had a huge pizza was fed all 4 of us and 4 sodas. Such good value!!

Emmie Schlessinger

The main guy who works here is a scam artist. He selectively speaks English when absolutely necessary (to declare there is no cheese pizza available and you must get a slice with toppings), and otherwise refuses to answer questions or otherwise engage with customers.Cheese pizza is $1 but a slice with any toppings is $2.50 - which admittedly is on their sign (in tiny writing in the bottom left corner of the menu).Once I realized this, I ordered a full cheese pizza (8 slices), and for some reason was charged $9 + tax. When I asked why this was, he suddenly didn’t speak English anymore.I have watched him take advantage of drunk customers who want cheese pizza, exclaiming “no regular!” and forcing them to select a $2.50 slice.If you go here, I suggest ordering only cheese and paying with exact change (he will keep any extra that you give him and then refuse to answer why).And the pizza is only ok. Better dollar slices available elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Tion

my go to pizza spot for every time of the day when i was in new york. always had opened, even on christmas eve i came in and he was a bit baffled i ordered 2 whole pizzas but we were vibing ykwim
sadly he didn’t let me pay card instead i had to take the atm and pay fees lol but vibes were good, pizza was always great and done in a minute, even when ordering 2 pies and he had to still make one of them it was done very quickly, 10/10 i like

Chelsea Thomas

Please correct opening hours

Michael Stevens

Good varity pizza at discount.$2.50 will get you topings of sorts. $1 slces. Average service in a rush definitely a good place to stop and get a quick slice. All in all i only saw i fly so you know it is outside

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Loading...