I've only gotten delivery here for a plain pie and a pepperoni pie. It is not like a traditional New York slice but definitely worth trying. It is a little costly compared to other pizzerias but I feel like it is worth it. Their sauce to crust to cheese ratio is very good. It almost tastes like cafeteria school pizza in a good nostalgic way.
Elizabeth B.
Archie's is awesome! Great for delivery. I love the variety of toppings and their selection of wine and cocktails.
The Lens Of The Tiger
Order came two hours late after being told 20minutes was going to me my wait time. After calling to see if I can pick up they couldn’t find my order so I had no choice but to wait. My tip. Don’t order unless your looking to enjoy your food two hours later.
Rick L.
I love you and Miss you. Don't ever change. You'll be back soon and so will I. Pizza reigns for all, all haters char with left over garlic knots.
Asiah C.
Wow this is some of the best pizza that I have had in brooklyn. Very different from Di Faros (which some also argue is the best pizza and I also like). However, one can't really compare the two but this pizza was definitely high quality from the crust to the add ons selected. I ordered for pickup on mother's day and had my sister pick the toppings. She opted for a buffalo chicken and pineapple pie as well as an eggplant, peppers with white sauce pie. Yo that white sauce is good and reminds me of the roux my family makes to make our homemade mac n cheese. I cant wait to come back and try new combinations. They also give you fresh parmesean and pepper flakes!
Marlon Ali
This place is my first choice site. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. when I I need a good meal, this place comes right away to my mind. Great and all kinds of food and a large list of dishes.trained staff, and great mood. Not less important, the cost is affordable. I tell about this place with great pleasure.
Alexis Woody
Archie's pizza is AMAZING! I usually go for a slice of pepperoni and I enjoy their beer selection. The wait time (45 min) is worth it if you're dining in or doing delivery!
Rocco G.
Pizza is different and Great ! Can't wait to go back ! Usually don't get pepperoni . But I did 5 stars ! Keep it up . will be back
Phyllis T.
This is my first time trying Archie's Pizza, I started following them during the virus as I'm trying to support more local places! We ordered from the site instead of through an app so it was a bit cheaper. I got a 10 inch pepperoni, sausage and jalapeños pizza. One of my roommates got Hawaiian and the other got just pepperoni. We also got a beer, cider and three Jell-O shots. While I ordered the hot and honey because I wanted to try theirs unfortunately it wasn't there so keep that in mind when ordering you might not get it. Overall all the pizzas were good! They didn't cook mines more like I had asked but it's Sunday and I'm sure a ton of people are ordering. My roommate really likes the Hawaiian and said it wasn't soggy. The pepperoni was tasty as always. Jell-O shots came in the orange and cherry flavors. We got two tequila and one vodka. There was a significant amount of alcohol in them which was nice. I would definitely order again but may skip ordering the sides next time unless I'm picking up.
Farrah B.
I ordered from Archie's tonight after having a delicious pizza delivered a few weeks ago. What I received was completely different. After quite a bit of difficulty ordering, I finally got my pizza and dessert...... You can imagine my disappointment when a cold, round pie cut in odd shapes with half the amount of cheese than on my last order, a small pie. To make it worse, the top of the crust was burnt and the bottom was half-baked! First, I called the restaurant and the only thing I was offered in the neighborhood of an apology was "if the kitchen was open, we'd send you another pie.... oh, next time say you want the pie in triangles." I was sad and moved on to the Steves key lime pie. You can mess up something already prepared. Wrong. There were fork-like marks and "touch" or "drop" marks in the top, with the entire crust shattered. At this point, I am flabbergasted. So, I reach out to Seamless. And the reaction from the manager Orgeta, was since it was a quality complaint, they would not refund my money. $40 in the trash. I am furious. So I called back to the restaurant and let the manager know this was not acceptable. She apologized and offered me a credit/comp on my next visit. I let her know, I honestly do not feel comfortable ordering from them again and requested a refund. She took my number and said she would try tomorrow and and she didn't get to it, email them at their email address, saying that's the best way to handle it. I'm not sure how to even mentally process this ordeal. I'm confused, sad and hungry.
I keep finding myself coming back here, of course I try to avoid the busy days and nights. This place can get awfully packed inside and it only has a certain amount of tables and chairs, so it can be rather tight. I've had experience of other customers sitting next to me, spill their drinks and the splash hitting me, anything could happen in a close together table situation. I'll normally come here on a weekday night, I have been able to get a table here on a weekend night though without having to wait. It's all about lucky timing. I personally dislike the fact that you're only able to order at the bar, it can be messy trying to get in between other people ordering drinks and squeezing your way through to try and make yourself noticeable to order. The Plain pie is amazing and you can't go wrong, I've tried the pepperoni with sausage and it's quite the meal. These slices are thick and any type of size pie will get the job done if you're sharing or even alone. The salad is great, I forgot which one I had but it was delicious, they have numerous options. I would recommend the bread as an appetizer. I would also recommend getting the baked pasta if you don't want to order pizza. The thing about Archie's is that you're paying for quality ingredients and everything is fresh and natural it seems. The prices are a bit more average than your typical pizza joint but remember this spot isn't typical. Come check this out, the customer service has been friendly, they do Check ID here. The M train is also a close walk from the Central stop location.
Gabrielle Bienasz
I have always loved the pizza here: warm, crusty, and flavorful. But, tonight, I called after attending my grandmother's funeral virtually, and they offered me my pizza for free and sent along a tonic water and a dessert. It's such a hard time for small businesses, and I can't believe they did something like this. Hats off to the wonderful people who make this the best pizza and the best big heart in the neighborhood
M D.
I love this pizza! And as far as I know it's the only place in NYC where I can get Greek style New England pizza! I grew up in Boston so having Greek pizza in Brooklyn is great!
Anna W.
Not traditional deep dish but DAMN thank you Bushwick Archie's for providing pizza in that direction. We ordered take out during the pandemic. Called on the phone and came in for pick up - excellent service, super fast and clean. We got two large pizzas with a variety of toppings and they lasted for two nights of dinner. That definitely made the pricing worth it (not that it's super expensive). Recommend spicy red peppers, feta, sausage as toppings. My parents had white sauce and he'd rec it but really, go for the tomato Love this place, would always say go for it!!
Summer M.
I know it's a Yelp cliche to start off your review "If I could give 0 stars I would" but this is definitely a 0 star moment! I placed an order for at 11:45am in which I gave a $5 tip due to the inconvenience of the pandemic. That original pizza delivery was BURNT to the point that it was inedible. And the delivery guy was rude. We called to complain about the condition of the pizza and was lied to that the pizza was looked at before it left the store. If it was "looked" at then it wouldn't have been delivered. That upfront was blatantly disrespectful. An email was sent as proof that the pizza was burnt in which we received a response with an apology and that a new pizza would be delivered. And almost 2hrs later we receive the second pizza not only cold and toasted but the delivery guy left our pizza on the stairs of our house like we are animals. That is disgusting and deplorable and makes me feel like the quality of our service and food was given to us because customers like us aren't valid. From the pattern of service I've received from this place they are sexist and racist. I've tried to order from this place multiple times and each time it gets worse and worse. There was no prior discussion of "no contact" when I placed my order and the first delivery guy handed it to my fiancé, so why wouldn't the second guy? After an hour of waiting for the second pizza we called to see if it was even sent out for delivery. The person who picked up the phone sounded like he had an attitude and rushed us off the phone saying that the pizza left out already. An hour later we then got the second pizza. McDonald's delivery services (via ubereats) has practiced WAY BETTER delivery etiquette and service during this pandemic then this business has. I am BEYOND disappointed and disgusted by today's interactions and demanded a full refund in an email in which they still haven't responded to. So now I have to escalate measures all over some burnt pizza. I will NEVER spend money with this business again And expect them to keep my $30 cause they're unethical.
I've only gotten delivery here for a plain pie and a pepperoni pie. It is not like a traditional New York slice but definitely worth trying. It is a little costly compared to other pizzerias but I feel like it is worth it. Their sauce to crust to cheese ratio is very good. It almost tastes like cafeteria school pizza in a good nostalgic way.
Archie's is awesome! Great for delivery. I love the variety of toppings and their selection of wine and cocktails.
Order came two hours late after being told 20minutes was going to me my wait time. After calling to see if I can pick up they couldn’t find my order so I had no choice but to wait. My tip. Don’t order unless your looking to enjoy your food two hours later.
I love you and Miss you. Don't ever change. You'll be back soon and so will I. Pizza reigns for all, all haters char with left over garlic knots.
Wow this is some of the best pizza that I have had in brooklyn. Very different from Di Faros (which some also argue is the best pizza and I also like). However, one can't really compare the two but this pizza was definitely high quality from the crust to the add ons selected. I ordered for pickup on mother's day and had my sister pick the toppings. She opted for a buffalo chicken and pineapple pie as well as an eggplant, peppers with white sauce pie. Yo that white sauce is good and reminds me of the roux my family makes to make our homemade mac n cheese. I cant wait to come back and try new combinations. They also give you fresh parmesean and pepper flakes!
This place is my first choice site. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. when I I need a good meal, this place comes right away to my mind. Great and all kinds of food and a large list of dishes.trained staff, and great mood. Not less important, the cost is affordable. I tell about this place with great pleasure.
Archie's pizza is AMAZING! I usually go for a slice of pepperoni and I enjoy their beer selection. The wait time (45 min) is worth it if you're dining in or doing delivery!
Pizza is different and Great ! Can't wait to go back ! Usually don't get pepperoni . But I did 5 stars ! Keep it up . will be back
This is my first time trying Archie's Pizza, I started following them during the virus as I'm trying to support more local places! We ordered from the site instead of through an app so it was a bit cheaper. I got a 10 inch pepperoni, sausage and jalapeños pizza. One of my roommates got Hawaiian and the other got just pepperoni. We also got a beer, cider and three Jell-O shots. While I ordered the hot and honey because I wanted to try theirs unfortunately it wasn't there so keep that in mind when ordering you might not get it. Overall all the pizzas were good! They didn't cook mines more like I had asked but it's Sunday and I'm sure a ton of people are ordering. My roommate really likes the Hawaiian and said it wasn't soggy. The pepperoni was tasty as always. Jell-O shots came in the orange and cherry flavors. We got two tequila and one vodka. There was a significant amount of alcohol in them which was nice. I would definitely order again but may skip ordering the sides next time unless I'm picking up.
I ordered from Archie's tonight after having a delicious pizza delivered a few weeks ago. What I received was completely different. After quite a bit of difficulty ordering, I finally got my pizza and dessert...... You can imagine my disappointment when a cold, round pie cut in odd shapes with half the amount of cheese than on my last order, a small pie. To make it worse, the top of the crust was burnt and the bottom was half-baked! First, I called the restaurant and the only thing I was offered in the neighborhood of an apology was "if the kitchen was open, we'd send you another pie.... oh, next time say you want the pie in triangles." I was sad and moved on to the Steves key lime pie. You can mess up something already prepared. Wrong. There were fork-like marks and "touch" or "drop" marks in the top, with the entire crust shattered. At this point, I am flabbergasted. So, I reach out to Seamless. And the reaction from the manager Orgeta, was since it was a quality complaint, they would not refund my money. $40 in the trash. I am furious. So I called back to the restaurant and let the manager know this was not acceptable. She apologized and offered me a credit/comp on my next visit. I let her know, I honestly do not feel comfortable ordering from them again and requested a refund. She took my number and said she would try tomorrow and and she didn't get to it, email them at their email address, saying that's the best way to handle it. I'm not sure how to even mentally process this ordeal. I'm confused, sad and hungry.
Restaurantji Recommends
I keep finding myself coming back here, of course I try to avoid the busy days and nights. This place can get awfully packed inside and it only has a certain amount of tables and chairs, so it can be rather tight. I've had experience of other customers sitting next to me, spill their drinks and the splash hitting me, anything could happen in a close together table situation. I'll normally come here on a weekday night, I have been able to get a table here on a weekend night though without having to wait. It's all about lucky timing. I personally dislike the fact that you're only able to order at the bar, it can be messy trying to get in between other people ordering drinks and squeezing your way through to try and make yourself noticeable to order. The Plain pie is amazing and you can't go wrong, I've tried the pepperoni with sausage and it's quite the meal. These slices are thick and any type of size pie will get the job done if you're sharing or even alone. The salad is great, I forgot which one I had but it was delicious, they have numerous options. I would recommend the bread as an appetizer. I would also recommend getting the baked pasta if you don't want to order pizza. The thing about Archie's is that you're paying for quality ingredients and everything is fresh and natural it seems. The prices are a bit more average than your typical pizza joint but remember this spot isn't typical. Come check this out, the customer service has been friendly, they do Check ID here. The M train is also a close walk from the Central stop location.
I have always loved the pizza here: warm, crusty, and flavorful. But, tonight, I called after attending my grandmother's funeral virtually, and they offered me my pizza for free and sent along a tonic water and a dessert. It's such a hard time for small businesses, and I can't believe they did something like this. Hats off to the wonderful people who make this the best pizza and the best big heart in the neighborhood
I love this pizza! And as far as I know it's the only place in NYC where I can get Greek style New England pizza! I grew up in Boston so having Greek pizza in Brooklyn is great!
Not traditional deep dish but DAMN thank you Bushwick Archie's for providing pizza in that direction. We ordered take out during the pandemic. Called on the phone and came in for pick up - excellent service, super fast and clean. We got two large pizzas with a variety of toppings and they lasted for two nights of dinner. That definitely made the pricing worth it (not that it's super expensive). Recommend spicy red peppers, feta, sausage as toppings. My parents had white sauce and he'd rec it but really, go for the tomato Love this place, would always say go for it!!
I know it's a Yelp cliche to start off your review "If I could give 0 stars I would" but this is definitely a 0 star moment! I placed an order for at 11:45am in which I gave a $5 tip due to the inconvenience of the pandemic. That original pizza delivery was BURNT to the point that it was inedible. And the delivery guy was rude. We called to complain about the condition of the pizza and was lied to that the pizza was looked at before it left the store. If it was "looked" at then it wouldn't have been delivered. That upfront was blatantly disrespectful. An email was sent as proof that the pizza was burnt in which we received a response with an apology and that a new pizza would be delivered. And almost 2hrs later we receive the second pizza not only cold and toasted but the delivery guy left our pizza on the stairs of our house like we are animals. That is disgusting and deplorable and makes me feel like the quality of our service and food was given to us because customers like us aren't valid. From the pattern of service I've received from this place they are sexist and racist. I've tried to order from this place multiple times and each time it gets worse and worse. There was no prior discussion of "no contact" when I placed my order and the first delivery guy handed it to my fiancé, so why wouldn't the second guy? After an hour of waiting for the second pizza we called to see if it was even sent out for delivery. The person who picked up the phone sounded like he had an attitude and rushed us off the phone saying that the pizza left out already. An hour later we then got the second pizza. McDonald's delivery services (via ubereats) has practiced WAY BETTER delivery etiquette and service during this pandemic then this business has. I am BEYOND disappointed and disgusted by today's interactions and demanded a full refund in an email in which they still haven't responded to. So now I have to escalate measures all over some burnt pizza. I will NEVER spend money with this business again And expect them to keep my $30 cause they're unethical.