Got an assortment of cookies from them through Too Good To Go, and oh my goodness!!! They were all SO beyond delicious! Literally enjoyed every flavor that came home with me. Hands down would recommend Aunt Butchie's to others.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, White Macadamia Cookie, Funfetti Cookie, Red Velvet Cookie, Sugar Cookie
Stanley Abraham
This is the tastiest place in Bay Ridge by far. The food is delicious and fresh. The place is clean. The staff is friendly and helpful. Did I mention that the food is great. Treats galore.
The NY cheesecake is pretty good and authentic, could be less frozen and use more of that graham cracker crust kick. The Italian cheesecake isn’t good, it has too much citrus/zest taste that is way too overpowering.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lilandra Rivera
Was really looking forward to a smooth experience but unfortunately it wasn't the case. I had pre-ordered a cake for my sister's birthday, payed and received a confirmation that it was going to be processed etc. The day that i have to pick up the cake, travel all the way to the bakery to only see chairs put up and the doors locked. On the website it showed open, called multiple times and no one has answered. Now I have no cake for my sister's birthday and having to travel back home. Very unfortunate and very unprofessional. I received no notification that my order was cancelled not until 8min before pick up time. I hate to have to scramble for last minute items.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Brownie Cheesecake
Lila
Was really looking forward to a smooth experience but unfortunately it wasn't the case. I had pre-ordered a cake for my sister's birthday, payed and received a confirmation that it was going to be processed etc. The day that i have to pick up the cake, travel all the way to the bakery to only see chairs put up and the doors locked. On the website it showed open, called multiple times and no one has answered. Now I have no cake for my sister's birthday and having to travel back home. Very unfortunate and very unprofessional. I received no notification that my order was cancelled not until 8min before pick up time. I hate to have to scramble for last minute items.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Brownie Cheesecake
Evan Myer
One of the best dessert spots in Brooklyn. Some of the best cheesecake and mousse cake I have had, and the cookies were also delicious. Their specialty “cheesecake cones” are great as well, really unique dessert item. Workers are super nice, too, you can tell it’s a family-owned business.
I started patronizing Aunt Butchie’s since 2003-2015 and that’s because I moved to Florida. Miss their cheesecake samplers. I’m happy to know they are still around because I will be returning for their delicious desserts. Thank you Aunt Butchie
Cool kid 24
I just came by here with one of my friends last week. I picked up some cookies and some cake and I can’t stop thinking about going back and getting more of them I will be back very soon
The desserts here are delicious and to die for.. My little Nicky loves his Brookies and can’t stop eating them…. He even gained 5 pounds eating them even though he was a little on the underweight size to begin with… the Cheescake cones are delicious too and always puts a smile on Nicky’s face….
Such an amazing spot! Everyone is so nice here and the food is so fresh! 10/10 would recommend
Alexander Koutras
Incredible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NYC Style Cookie
Charmaine Diaz
It was my first time visiting this bakery just this past weekend as I was going to a restaurant in the area. I bought a couple of cookies, one being the salted caramel cookie. As I got down to the last bite, I was chewing and tasted something weird. What I pulled out of my mouth was a piece of lint. Very weird to say but it seems like maybe the cookie dough was dropped on the floor before baking and they picked it back up anyway instead of discarding it and the lint baked inside of the cookie. Or maybe the cookie itself was dropped and the lint/dust from the floor was stuck on the back of it. I have no idea. I threw out all of the cookies afterwards and unfortunately I will not be returning to this establishment. That is completely unacceptable.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Jonathan J
The reason I’m giving only two stars is because while the desserts are excellent, the service and general atmosphere of the place left much to be desired. On the door, they claim to open at 8:00A.M., and I was in a rush this morning to get something for my friend. However, they opened an hour late. While I don’t mind this on its own, I do wish that they would change the time on the door so that they can live up to it. Secondly, the woman serving me had a very stone-cold face, as though she was not pleased to be there, and answered in rather rude tones when I asked questions. Good food, poor service quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Jenny
Their chocolate mousse cake is so amazing, it's addicting. It's been my go-to cake for birthdays and celebrations. I also grab slices every now and then to satisfy my craving in between celebrations. This time, I tried their cookies. A lot of cookies tend to be too sweet for me, but these were great. I just had a slice of chocolate mousse cake two days ago, and writing this review is making me want to grab some more slices as soon as possible.
Got an assortment of cookies from them through Too Good To Go, and oh my goodness!!! They were all SO beyond delicious! Literally enjoyed every flavor that came home with me. Hands down would recommend Aunt Butchie's to others.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, White Macadamia Cookie, Funfetti Cookie, Red Velvet Cookie, Sugar Cookie
This is the tastiest place in Bay Ridge by far. The food is delicious and fresh. The place is clean. The staff is friendly and helpful. Did I mention that the food is great. Treats galore.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mousse Cake, NYC Style Cookie, Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
The NY cheesecake is pretty good and authentic, could be less frozen and use more of that graham cracker crust kick. The Italian cheesecake isn’t good, it has too much citrus/zest taste that is way too overpowering.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Was really looking forward to a smooth experience but unfortunately it wasn't the case. I had pre-ordered a cake for my sister's birthday, payed and received a confirmation that it was going to be processed etc. The day that i have to pick up the cake, travel all the way to the bakery to only see chairs put up and the doors locked. On the website it showed open, called multiple times and no one has answered. Now I have no cake for my sister's birthday and having to travel back home. Very unfortunate and very unprofessional. I received no notification that my order was cancelled not until 8min before pick up time. I hate to have to scramble for last minute items.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Brownie Cheesecake
Was really looking forward to a smooth experience but unfortunately it wasn't the case. I had pre-ordered a cake for my sister's birthday, payed and received a confirmation that it was going to be processed etc. The day that i have to pick up the cake, travel all the way to the bakery to only see chairs put up and the doors locked. On the website it showed open, called multiple times and no one has answered. Now I have no cake for my sister's birthday and having to travel back home. Very unfortunate and very unprofessional. I received no notification that my order was cancelled not until 8min before pick up time. I hate to have to scramble for last minute items.
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Brownie Cheesecake
One of the best dessert spots in Brooklyn. Some of the best cheesecake and mousse cake I have had, and the cookies were also delicious. Their specialty “cheesecake cones” are great as well, really unique dessert item. Workers are super nice, too, you can tell it’s a family-owned business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cheesecake Cone, Sampler Cake, Mousse Cake, NYC Style Cookie, Chocolate Mousse Cake
I started patronizing Aunt Butchie’s since 2003-2015 and that’s because I moved to Florida. Miss their cheesecake samplers. I’m happy to know they are still around because I will be returning for their delicious desserts. Thank you Aunt Butchie
I just came by here with one of my friends last week. I picked up some cookies and some cake and I can’t stop thinking about going back and getting more of them I will be back very soon
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Cheesecake Cone, Carrot Cake, Sampler Cake, NYC Style Cookie, Individual Tartufo, Sugar Cookie, Oreo Cheesecake
Best Cake ever and Alex is a 10/10 employee
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The desserts here are delicious and to die for.. My little Nicky loves his Brookies and can’t stop eating them…. He even gained 5 pounds eating them even though he was a little on the underweight size to begin with… the Cheescake cones are delicious too and always puts a smile on Nicky’s face….
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Such an amazing spot! Everyone is so nice here and the food is so fresh! 10/10 would recommend
Incredible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: NYC Style Cookie
It was my first time visiting this bakery just this past weekend as I was going to a restaurant in the area. I bought a couple of cookies, one being the salted caramel cookie. As I got down to the last bite, I was chewing and tasted something weird. What I pulled out of my mouth was a piece of lint. Very weird to say but it seems like maybe the cookie dough was dropped on the floor before baking and they picked it back up anyway instead of discarding it and the lint baked inside of the cookie. Or maybe the cookie itself was dropped and the lint/dust from the floor was stuck on the back of it. I have no idea. I threw out all of the cookies afterwards and unfortunately I will not be returning to this establishment. That is completely unacceptable.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
The reason I’m giving only two stars is because while the desserts are excellent, the service and general atmosphere of the place left much to be desired. On the door, they claim to open at 8:00A.M., and I was in a rush this morning to get something for my friend. However, they opened an hour late. While I don’t mind this on its own, I do wish that they would change the time on the door so that they can live up to it. Secondly, the woman serving me had a very stone-cold face, as though she was not pleased to be there, and answered in rather rude tones when I asked questions. Good food, poor service quality.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Their chocolate mousse cake is so amazing, it's addicting. It's been my go-to cake for birthdays and celebrations. I also grab slices every now and then to satisfy my craving in between celebrations. This time, I tried their cookies. A lot of cookies tend to be too sweet for me, but these were great. I just had a slice of chocolate mousse cake two days ago, and writing this review is making me want to grab some more slices as soon as possible.
Loading...