The food is excellent it's like my grandmother is in the kitchen cooking the grandma pies awesome they're courteous friendly and the restaurant has a nice atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ann Garcia
Highly recommend their Sicilians! đ
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bes Sogojeva
Bad boys pizza is probably the best pizza Bensonhurts . My kids love their pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jeannine Campos
I ordered food last night we order all the time last night the shrimp was freezer burn the bread you could bounce off the wall. The chicken is sliced so so thin it comes to less the 1 cutlet so sad they charge so much and that's what they give we will be using someone else sorry give your steady customers what they pay for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Howard Weiss
Favorite pizza in the neighborhood - still one of my favorite pizza places they moved and I moved as well and today I found out where they moved to, and Iâm in heaven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Arsenii Moroz
they were soo nice and made some of the best pizza in town I would highly recommend, having always tipped well.
I donât usually ever leave bad reviews for restaurants even when I donât enjoy the experience, but I hope this business can take this feedback and seriously improve.
I ordered a large pizza with half mushroom for delivery. When I open the pizza box, half of the pizza has no cheese, sauce, or toppings on it as they have all slid into one corner of the pizza box, and itâs become a goopy nonspreadable ball of mess. I donât know if the delivery man accidentally tipped over the box, but even if that was the case, a normal pizza should not have all of its cheese and sauce slide completely off the pizza if it was made properly.
The slices that are still intact have a way too thick and hard crust that feels like Iâm eating cardboard. The pizza tastes overpoweringly yeasty, like the dough is over fermented. There is barely any sauce on them, and not just because the sauce slid off the other half of the pizza. All I taste is yeast.
The pizza also has mushrooms on the entire pie, not half like I had requested. People make mistakes, but it was hard to overlook this one given how terribly everything else was.
I sincerely hope this business takes this feedback to improve, given how many other pizza slice shops are in the area. This was my first time ordering from here and I was far from impressed.
Food: 1
Ronnie Jenzen
After 20 years of this being my goto pizzeria at work and ordering 1 to 2 times a week, I call today, don't know what happened, got disconnected. I call again, it just rings, one more call and I get a recording saying there's a call restriction on my number. Call from a coworkers phone, it went thru and I asked what happened, the guy starts screaming and yelling. AAAA/OOOO this and that. Never again, there's Casa Bella a block away and Pizza D'Amore in Ceaser's Bay. In a time when businesses ain't doing so good, especially in a neighborhood most Italians left, not the best idea to insult a long time customer that does the ordering in a shop of 14 guys. There's better, friendlier, more respectful options that'll appreciate my money and not put my number on block. from "the tire store"
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Scorpio
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeriađ´.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Mariela TP
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeria?.
Its just okay? I liked their food better at their old location. Ordered their chicken roll and it was long and thin, barely enough room for the sauce or chicken. My first two bites were bread. Pretty disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
YURR MOMM
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeria?.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Clarymar
Fav spot in Brooklyn.Mario is great
Ignazio Bongiorno
Terrible food. Rude service, Mario is an idiotI walked in, see no food on the counter. I asked him if he had any food coming out. He told me to take it easy and to shut the F.â˘â˘â˘ upThe food is terrible regardless, he do me a favor Went to a different pizzeria it was so much better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
John Go
I love this place , beautiful inside and outside enclosed seating . Atmosphere is a very comforting old school Brooklyn Italian pizzeria . No place like home and the food is fresh and delicious . If you have never been you need to give it a try .
Vegetarian options: Almost all the pizza is vegetarian friendly , salads , garlic knots
The food is excellent it's like my grandmother is in the kitchen cooking the grandma pies awesome they're courteous friendly and the restaurant has a nice atmosphere
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend their Sicilians! đ
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bad boys pizza is probably the best pizza Bensonhurts . My kids love their pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
I ordered food last night we order all the time last night the shrimp was freezer burn the bread you could bounce off the wall. The chicken is sliced so so thin it comes to less the 1 cutlet so sad they charge so much and that's what they give we will be using someone else sorry give your steady customers what they pay for.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Favorite pizza in the neighborhood - still one of my favorite pizza places they moved and I moved as well and today I found out where they moved to, and Iâm in heaven
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
they were soo nice and made some of the best pizza in town I would highly recommend, having always tipped well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Parmigiana, Sausage Parmigiana, Stuffed Rolls
I donât usually ever leave bad reviews for restaurants even when I donât enjoy the experience, but I hope this business can take this feedback and seriously improve.
I ordered a large pizza with half mushroom for delivery. When I open the pizza box, half of the pizza has no cheese, sauce, or toppings on it as they have all slid into one corner of the pizza box, and itâs become a goopy nonspreadable ball of mess. I donât know if the delivery man accidentally tipped over the box, but even if that was the case, a normal pizza should not have all of its cheese and sauce slide completely off the pizza if it was made properly.
The slices that are still intact have a way too thick and hard crust that feels like Iâm eating cardboard. The pizza tastes overpoweringly yeasty, like the dough is over fermented. There is barely any sauce on them, and not just because the sauce slid off the other half of the pizza. All I taste is yeast.
The pizza also has mushrooms on the entire pie, not half like I had requested. People make mistakes, but it was hard to overlook this one given how terribly everything else was.
I sincerely hope this business takes this feedback to improve, given how many other pizza slice shops are in the area. This was my first time ordering from here and I was far from impressed.
Food: 1
After 20 years of this being my goto pizzeria at work and ordering 1 to 2 times a week, I call today, don't know what happened, got disconnected. I call again, it just rings, one more call and I get a recording saying there's a call restriction on my number. Call from a coworkers phone, it went thru and I asked what happened, the guy starts screaming and yelling. AAAA/OOOO this and that. Never again, there's Casa Bella a block away and Pizza D'Amore in Ceaser's Bay. In a time when businesses ain't doing so good, especially in a neighborhood most Italians left, not the best idea to insult a long time customer that does the ordering in a shop of 14 guys. There's better, friendlier, more respectful options that'll appreciate my money and not put my number on block. from "the tire store"
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeriađ´.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeria?.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Its just okay? I liked their food better at their old location. Ordered their chicken roll and it was long and thin, barely enough room for the sauce or chicken. My first two bites were bread. Pretty disappointing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Ordered delivery on Monday for a pie. Half pepperoni and half plain,** WELL DONE***. Why did this man send me a BURNED PIZZA??? You looked at this and said âyeah this is good !â??? This is unacceptable and u canât sit here and try to tell me this pizza is âwell doneâ. Plus the delivery guy was outside my house yelling at the top of his lungs saying âWHO ORDERED PIZZAâ. $21 for a burned pizza. Next time just order from Federicoâs Pizzeria?.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 2
Fav spot in Brooklyn.Mario is great
Terrible food. Rude service, Mario is an idiotI walked in, see no food on the counter. I asked him if he had any food coming out. He told me to take it easy and to shut the F.â˘â˘â˘ upThe food is terrible regardless, he do me a favor Went to a different pizzeria it was so much better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I love this place , beautiful inside and outside enclosed seating . Atmosphere is a very comforting old school Brooklyn Italian pizzeria . No place like home and the food is fresh and delicious . If you have never been you need to give it a try .
Vegetarian options: Almost all the pizza is vegetarian friendly , salads , garlic knots
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto, Chicken Parmigiana, Meatball Parmigiana, Regular Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Slice of Pizza, Tomato Soup, Garlic Knots, Rice Ball, Stuffed Rolls, Chicken Pizza, Baked Ziti, Rice Ball Special, Shrimp Marinara, Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana, Veal & Peppers
Loading...