Bagel supreme

9401 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 745-1108

Recent Reviews

Sort by
jason delprete

Food is prepared by an awesome staff. It's just a simple bagel shop but the bagels are great. Coffee is good as well.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese, Bagels

Ray Campbell

Stopped in early morning about a quarter after seven in the morning on a Thursday, walked in and it was very clean but nothing spectacular inside. It’s a small place with two tables, for seating of four at each. You can sit down and wait for your order or you can have a seat and eat. Wait time was under five minutes for them to take my order and another five minutes or so for it to be completed. I was going to order a plain bagel but I noticed they had a tray of croissants off to the side, so I ordered one lighty toasted and lighty buttered. I was a tad disappointed because they appeared freshly baked but when I tried it, I didn’t get that freshness feeling. To me it tasted just like a regular croissant that you can buy that already came prepackaged. Overall the service was decent, so I’d give it a try with something different

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 5

Vincent “Mulch Man” Calabrese

I was eating alone at a table, guy sits down at my table, I said excuse me, I didn't ask you to sit down with me, while I'm eating, his girlfriend starts going nuts on me, we can sit wherever we want... workers did absolutely nothing!! Terrible the way they let someone harass a customer without doing anything. I'll never be back, and I don't recommend anyone go there. You can do a whole lot better than this place!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 2

Adam Rosatti

Ordered a Veggie Omelette via Uber eats, received a Lunch Veggie Wrap. Called to get the order right, non-English speaker answers phone, never delivers correct item.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jermaine G

Bagels are on point

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak, Bagels

Jennifer S.

Hands down best bagels in Bay Ridge. Hardest working staff around. Place gets busy during breakfast but I promise you, it's worth the wait.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Christian Schou

We all have our favorite bagel spot and this it for me in Bay Ridge. Amazing taste and cooked just the way I like them. The staff is always friendly and helpful. Highly recommend.

Jennifer Sadel

Hands down best bagels in Bay Ridge. Hardest working staff around. Place gets busy during breakfast but I promise you, it's worth the wait.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Bagels

Steven T

THE GODFATHER!!!

This sandwich is Russian dresssing, grilled onions and mushrooms, roast beef , toasted

Sandwich was a little greasy but really freaking fantastic, nice sweetness from the Russian dressing and onions

Great sandwich would recommend

Daniel Pino

Layout/atmosphere*Four tables; self serve coffee station/counter; electronic display boards for the menu; one TVFood/drink*Bacon, egg & cheese on sesame bagel - good; bigger bagel/doughy

Donald Nestler

Breaks my heart. Going there for years but like a lot of other places service just keeps getting worse. The woman in the front is the worst and she keeps getting worse. It's a shame. They need to fire her and get some competent people. Smh. Also double check the bacon or meat on your sandwich I've had 2 instances where they served raw bacon thank God double checked. Again going there 3x a week for years always tipped and was nice but not no more. They just don't get it.

Casey Rohrig

Best egg sandwich in bay ridge so

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese

Annette Gerage

The bagels are fluffy & always fresh. I had a bagel w/white fish. They fill the bagel & it's great. Always get it there.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ashley

Food is great!But the owner is rude! He got mad when I told him I don’t want him touching my food. His touching the money and then the food! Going out side smoking not washing his hands and coming back in and making food. His response to me why are you watching me? (I watching my food be made) and told me to stop talking.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Frugal Cyclist

Got here 5:50 am to attend the pre bike ride before NYC Marathon start. Shop opened early and line had already formed with many New York’s Finest in blue. The wait was only 5 minutes, line moved quickly.I ordered the 3 egg whites on a bagel and was charged $5. I pointed out to the cashier that the menu overhead states $4.25. She said it’s the tax. Looking at the receipt, there was a discrepancy.Not wanting to hold up the line and fuss over 75 cents, I moved aside. Either she is incorrect or the system hasn’t been updated to reflect the new higher price.Coffee was a good deal for a medium size at $2. Also able to sit inside away from the cold autumn air. Place does look quite busy, not sure if the marathon played a role in this or food is just good. I do hope they rectify the price issue so other customers don’t make a fuss…

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Loading...