Just received my delivery from them. I ordered a Spaghetti with meat sauce and penne Ala vodka. The spaghetti with meat sauce was a tiny portion with barely any sauce, just laid on top and not mixed in. The penne vodka on the other hand was a larger, normal size portion but was DROWNING in sauce, making the pasta incredibly mushy, making the whole dish inedible. Living in the bay ridge area, I will not be ordering again.
Food: 2
Joani O.
Coming from Chicago, I've been to New York several times but never had the pizza. (Always calzones!) Due to the big rivalry, I decided to try this place in the neighborhood where we're staying. The slices are large, triangular, and reminded me of some of our places at home. But that's where it stops. The slices behind the glass didn't look very appealing so I asked if they had any Italian sausage. The guy who waited on me said he could take the slices of cheese and add sausage to them and put them in the oven. So we did that and when my daughter and I saw the slices, we weren't sure what to think. The meat was big chunks, some round and some looked shredded, like gyro meat. It had a funny/different taste too, not at all like the good Italian sausage we're used to. They filled us up for the time being, but i'm glad i didn't buy a whole pizza. It just wasn't very good. See the picture for my 1/2 eaten slice. On a more positive note, they have a good variety of other dishes. Salads, pastas, misc. Italian. I would try something else next time.
Maria H.
I ordered the eggplant panini and there was only on slice of eggplant cut in half in there. Another time I ordered a hero which is double the price same issue one slice of eggplant on each side. I have been a customer for 20 years and it was never like this. I called and complained and the girl on the phone just said I will let the cook know. Like put enough food, otherwise it is just eating bread. Not happy anymore and portions suck.
Mich M.
Indeed the tastiest slice of cheese pizza in Bay Ridge! In fact, it's my favorite slice in all of NYC because of the deliciousness and the price! I haven't tried anything else here yet but the regular cheese slice is SO GOOD. The cheese were stringy and just the perfect amount of saltiness. They were generous with the amount of tomato sauce. I'm drooling as I'm writing this. It's a thin crust pizza but the crust is not as thin as those in Manhattan pizzerias. The ones in Manhattan are literally a ripe off as their pizzas are paper thin now. But here at Bay Ridge pizza, I'm reminded of the pizzas that I used to have as a kid. They kept the traditional recipe! They also use an oil on their pizza, I'm not sure the name of the oil, but it makes the pizza tastes and smells so good! I have no complaints about the service. It's a pizzeria. They're fast, honest, and clean. One time, the staff there even brought my slice to my table. I've been to several pizzerias throughout Brooklyn and Manhattan, and to me, Bay Ridge pizza lives up to their awards. They are indeed the best pizza in Brooklyn and maybe even Manhattan! They only charge $3.25 a slice!
Sameer Kabtoul
This place is great and so is the food, but they aren’t consistent. It’s kinda disappointing since the food is so good but they lack with the portions when it comes to getting slices. I sometimes get a Buffalo chicken slice and they tend to cover the whole slice with it. But last time I got it, there were only like 4 pieces of chicken on it and it wasn’t even fully covered with the sauce. Their were giant spots that had nothing on them and the chicken was all pushed to a small part of the side of the slice. I was really disappointed cuz I was looking forward to eating it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Stefany Rodríguez
Gluten free dough is
Food: 5
geoff robbins
Delivery is a hassle. Hour plus each time. Fake tough guy on phone yells that I should have ordered earlier. Promised food was fresh and driver was leaving while on phone with him while driver pulled up. Pizza was hard as a rock and cold as can be. This is not the first time this happened here on delivery. 3 strikes and your out. Hence why I haven’t ordered since October. Tried again. U failed. And here we are again. Same store. Last time was 2+ hours. “Guys on the job for 8 days. He didn’t mean 25 mins” same story this time. Hire a writer. Get new material. And your pizza sucks anyways. But the other spots were closed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
K D
This pizza would be great except for Saturday. On Saturday it sucks. Except for that one time. Too bad. I’ve deducted that pizza in Bay Ridge sorta just sucks in general. At times great, however blatantly inconsistent, and well worth giving up. My Chinese spot never fails.
Vanessa V.
Food was cold and without flavor. Chicken tasted like it was rubber. Pasta was swimming in oily water
I had really high expectations for this place but ended up extremely disappointed. The food is subpar, you can find much better options nearby so just save yourself the trip. Not only is the staff extremely rude but their delivery car even hit into my friends car and drove off as if nothing happened. I know I’ll never be coming back here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
zouhair kharbouch
????????? guys believe me after one hour off eating my stomach started hurting me and I go to the hospital ⛔️⛔️⛔️
Khadija Benchane
The most disgusting ? pizza ,AVOIDED❌❌❌ not clean at all,The service 0 the stuff and the manager are not respectful and rude.DO NOT EAT HERE
Federico Peralta
What a big piece of garbage … I bought one slice to try it … vomit on a plate …
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Evelyn Maria Gonzalez
Great mozzarella sticks! The trip to BROOKLYN from JERSEY with my son Ale was EVERYTHING! Bay Ridge Pizza’s pig in a blanket had a dough that just melts in your mouth; reminds you of a pastry but still gives you the kick of pork. And— I will NEVER have a SICILIAN SLICE in Jersey again!!!
Just received my delivery from them. I ordered a Spaghetti with meat sauce and penne Ala vodka. The spaghetti with meat sauce was a tiny portion with barely any sauce, just laid on top and not mixed in. The penne vodka on the other hand was a larger, normal size portion but was DROWNING in sauce, making the pasta incredibly mushy, making the whole dish inedible. Living in the bay ridge area, I will not be ordering again.
Food: 2
Coming from Chicago, I've been to New York several times but never had the pizza. (Always calzones!) Due to the big rivalry, I decided to try this place in the neighborhood where we're staying. The slices are large, triangular, and reminded me of some of our places at home. But that's where it stops. The slices behind the glass didn't look very appealing so I asked if they had any Italian sausage. The guy who waited on me said he could take the slices of cheese and add sausage to them and put them in the oven. So we did that and when my daughter and I saw the slices, we weren't sure what to think. The meat was big chunks, some round and some looked shredded, like gyro meat. It had a funny/different taste too, not at all like the good Italian sausage we're used to. They filled us up for the time being, but i'm glad i didn't buy a whole pizza. It just wasn't very good. See the picture for my 1/2 eaten slice. On a more positive note, they have a good variety of other dishes. Salads, pastas, misc. Italian. I would try something else next time.
I ordered the eggplant panini and there was only on slice of eggplant cut in half in there. Another time I ordered a hero which is double the price same issue one slice of eggplant on each side. I have been a customer for 20 years and it was never like this. I called and complained and the girl on the phone just said I will let the cook know. Like put enough food, otherwise it is just eating bread. Not happy anymore and portions suck.
Indeed the tastiest slice of cheese pizza in Bay Ridge! In fact, it's my favorite slice in all of NYC because of the deliciousness and the price! I haven't tried anything else here yet but the regular cheese slice is SO GOOD. The cheese were stringy and just the perfect amount of saltiness. They were generous with the amount of tomato sauce. I'm drooling as I'm writing this. It's a thin crust pizza but the crust is not as thin as those in Manhattan pizzerias. The ones in Manhattan are literally a ripe off as their pizzas are paper thin now. But here at Bay Ridge pizza, I'm reminded of the pizzas that I used to have as a kid. They kept the traditional recipe! They also use an oil on their pizza, I'm not sure the name of the oil, but it makes the pizza tastes and smells so good! I have no complaints about the service. It's a pizzeria. They're fast, honest, and clean. One time, the staff there even brought my slice to my table. I've been to several pizzerias throughout Brooklyn and Manhattan, and to me, Bay Ridge pizza lives up to their awards. They are indeed the best pizza in Brooklyn and maybe even Manhattan! They only charge $3.25 a slice!
This place is great and so is the food, but they aren’t consistent. It’s kinda disappointing since the food is so good but they lack with the portions when it comes to getting slices. I sometimes get a Buffalo chicken slice and they tend to cover the whole slice with it. But last time I got it, there were only like 4 pieces of chicken on it and it wasn’t even fully covered with the sauce. Their were giant spots that had nothing on them and the chicken was all pushed to a small part of the side of the slice. I was really disappointed cuz I was looking forward to eating it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Gluten free dough is
Food: 5
Delivery is a hassle. Hour plus each time. Fake tough guy on phone yells that I should have ordered earlier. Promised food was fresh and driver was leaving while on phone with him while driver pulled up. Pizza was hard as a rock and cold as can be. This is not the first time this happened here on delivery. 3 strikes and your out. Hence why I haven’t ordered since October. Tried again. U failed. And here we are again. Same store. Last time was 2+ hours. “Guys on the job for 8 days. He didn’t mean 25 mins” same story this time. Hire a writer. Get new material. And your pizza sucks anyways. But the other spots were closed
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This pizza would be great except for Saturday. On Saturday it sucks. Except for that one time. Too bad. I’ve deducted that pizza in Bay Ridge sorta just sucks in general. At times great, however blatantly inconsistent, and well worth giving up. My Chinese spot never fails.
Food was cold and without flavor. Chicken tasted like it was rubber. Pasta was swimming in oily water
Nasty nasty nasty service is terrible mad
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I had really high expectations for this place but ended up extremely disappointed. The food is subpar, you can find much better options nearby so just save yourself the trip. Not only is the staff extremely rude but their delivery car even hit into my friends car and drove off as if nothing happened. I know I’ll never be coming back here.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
????????? guys believe me after one hour off eating my stomach started hurting me and I go to the hospital ⛔️⛔️⛔️
The most disgusting ? pizza ,AVOIDED❌❌❌ not clean at all,The service 0 the stuff and the manager are not respectful and rude.DO NOT EAT HERE
What a big piece of garbage … I bought one slice to try it … vomit on a plate …
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Great mozzarella sticks! The trip to BROOKLYN from JERSEY with my son Ale was EVERYTHING! Bay Ridge Pizza’s pig in a blanket had a dough that just melts in your mouth; reminds you of a pastry but still gives you the kick of pork. And— I will NEVER have a SICILIAN SLICE in Jersey again!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5