Benny's Pizza Ave J
1418 Avenue J, Brooklyn
(718) 253-1894
Customers' Favorites
Eggplant Rollatini
Baked Penne Pasta
Ala Vodka Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Regular Pizza
Pizza Slices
Salad Bar
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
???Wow, my new favorite pizza place! We tried the Margarita Pizza. This place figured out a way to make the crust also crazy delicious! No one compares to this place. Seriously, the crust, it’s sooo good!
Ordered delivery and pizza was ok part of the dough was white and undercooked a bit and parts of the pie were more brown how I like my pizza. Doesn’t taste the same as other location.
Pene vodka pasta was amazing definitely a 5/5!!!. However we also ordered a small pie, and when we got home and opened the box we saw the whole pie was 90% tomato sauce and 10% cheese right in the middle of the pie. Was kinda dissapointed, suggest you make sure you see your pie before leaving the store
You May Also Like
ISTANBLUE KEBAB HOUSE - 1416 Avenue J
![]()
Turkish, Mediterranean, Seafood, Salad
Di Fara Pizza - 1424 Avenue J
![]()
Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian
1012 Kitchen - 1012 E 15th St
![]()
Italian