I wanted something sweet but never been so I asked the guy at the counter whats his favorite and he didnt hesitate and said carrot cake. I got it and boy was AJ right! Carrot cake is banging man! Great recommendation it hit the spot for sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Xani Hargreaves
I LOVE the pies here - make me feel like I’m back home in Australia. And AJ is so sweet!! Would give 6 stars if I could!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elena S.
AJ was the best! Super helpful and knowledgeable about different tastes of pies. Gave great recommendations! The chai was perfectly made and AJ’s recommendation was on point! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Asia Bickley
While visiting New York with a friend, we stopped at Betty Bakery. Prior to ordering, I reviewed the posted menu sign, which did not indicate any additional charge for oat milk. I ordered three hot chocolates with oat milk.
When I was charged, the cashier attempted to add an additional $1 per drink for the oat milk, bringing the total to approximately $22. This surcharge was not communicated at the time of ordering and was not reflected on the posted pricing. Upon noticing the discrepancy, I politely requested that the displayed price be honored.
In response, the cashier became unprofessional, making remarks about recent price changes, the cost of chocolate, and stating that I had “messed it up” for other customers. This interaction was unnecessary and inappropriate, as my request was simply to be charged the advertised price.
Although the owner ultimately issued a refund, the resistance and commentary from both the cashier and the owner were unwarranted and detracted from the experience. I believe this situation could have been handled more professionally and with clearer communication regarding pricing.
Service: 1
Stan Laroche
The place is incredible. AJ from the counter told me about how hard the owner worked to perfect his recipe. It’s my go to spot after a long day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sharon Chen
Cumin lamb pies and spinach egg pies are so good! Crust is buttery and flaky, and the lamb was perfectly seasoned.
Abi Sundaram
We placed a custom vegan cupcake order from Betty Bakery for a special event, specifically noting a few allergens. Unfortunately, those allergen requests were not honored, and our guests with sensitivities became sick. While their reactions were thankfully mild and not life-threatening, it did derail the rest of our evening and was deeply disappointing. We will not be ordering from here again!
Ariel S
Wow! On a random solo adventure, I stumbled across this bakery and I love chocolate cake so I was hoping that I can get a slice before i went home. A little after being home I completely forgot I bought a sweet treat! I was pleasantly surprised with how rich and moist this Valrhona chocolate cake was. It was so good currently wishing I could’ve bought an entire Cake. 🤣🤣🤣🩵🩵🩵 definitely the kind of cake that makes you want a glass of milk🤭😆
The Hood came thru!! I was on my way to Dunner and remembered I needed a birthday cake for my Dad..... Betty staff could not have made it easier.
Food: 5
Service: 5
brian
Great savory pie selections
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MA ponce
AJ was very helpful lived it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emilie Loring
I love their savory pies! We get a dozen at a time and stock the freezer, easy lunch or kids meal always on hand. The Argentine Beef and the Cumin Lamb are the adults favorites, the kids love the Bacon Egg and Cheese and the Steak and Cheese.
June Glass
The guy on the phone said it’s the best and it is.
Easily the best Carrot Cake in NYC, and yes, I’ve had Lloyd’s, Hani’s, Billy’s, Carrot Top, Mia’s, Little Cupcake (which is actually not good at all), and many many others.
It has very similar cake layers to Lloyd’s and is truthfully not quite as warming, dense, or rich of a mouthful, but the icing is perfectly balanced. Velvety mouthfeel, not gritty or mealy like Lloyd’s, and not nearly as sweet. It’s a very dreamy nostalgic bite, and from someone who has tried hundreds of carrot cakes recipes at home and out at bakeries, this is as good as it gets.
I wanted something sweet but never been so I asked the guy at the counter whats his favorite and he didnt hesitate and said carrot cake. I got it and boy was AJ right! Carrot cake is banging man! Great recommendation it hit the spot for sure
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I LOVE the pies here - make me feel like I’m back home in Australia. And AJ is so sweet!! Would give 6 stars if I could!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AJ was the best! Super helpful and knowledgeable about different tastes of pies. Gave great recommendations! The chai was perfectly made and AJ’s recommendation was on point! Will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
While visiting New York with a friend, we stopped at Betty Bakery. Prior to ordering, I reviewed the posted menu sign, which did not indicate any additional charge for oat milk. I ordered three hot chocolates with oat milk.
When I was charged, the cashier attempted to add an additional $1 per drink for the oat milk, bringing the total to approximately $22. This surcharge was not communicated at the time of ordering and was not reflected on the posted pricing. Upon noticing the discrepancy, I politely requested that the displayed price be honored.
In response, the cashier became unprofessional, making remarks about recent price changes, the cost of chocolate, and stating that I had “messed it up” for other customers. This interaction was unnecessary and inappropriate, as my request was simply to be charged the advertised price.
Although the owner ultimately issued a refund, the resistance and commentary from both the cashier and the owner were unwarranted and detracted from the experience. I believe this situation could have been handled more professionally and with clearer communication regarding pricing.
Service: 1
The place is incredible. AJ from the counter told me about how hard the owner worked to perfect his recipe. It’s my go to spot after a long day
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cumin lamb pies and spinach egg pies are so good! Crust is buttery and flaky, and the lamb was perfectly seasoned.
We placed a custom vegan cupcake order from Betty Bakery for a special event, specifically noting a few allergens. Unfortunately, those allergen requests were not honored, and our guests with sensitivities became sick. While their reactions were thankfully mild and not life-threatening, it did derail the rest of our evening and was deeply disappointing. We will not be ordering from here again!
Wow! On a random solo adventure, I stumbled across this bakery and I love chocolate cake so I was hoping that I can get a slice before i went home. A little after being home I completely forgot I bought a sweet treat! I was pleasantly surprised with how rich and moist this Valrhona chocolate cake was. It was so good currently wishing I could’ve bought an entire Cake. 🤣🤣🤣🩵🩵🩵 definitely the kind of cake that makes you want a glass of milk🤭😆
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Bad experience
amazing steak and cheese pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The Hood came thru!! I was on my way to Dunner and remembered I needed a birthday cake for my Dad..... Betty staff could not have made it easier.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great savory pie selections
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
AJ was very helpful lived it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love their savory pies! We get a dozen at a time and stock the freezer, easy lunch or kids meal always on hand. The Argentine Beef and the Cumin Lamb are the adults favorites, the kids love the Bacon Egg and Cheese and the Steak and Cheese.
The guy on the phone said it’s the best and it is.
Easily the best Carrot Cake in NYC, and yes, I’ve had Lloyd’s, Hani’s, Billy’s, Carrot Top, Mia’s, Little Cupcake (which is actually not good at all), and many many others.
It has very similar cake layers to Lloyd’s and is truthfully not quite as warming, dense, or rich of a mouthful, but the icing is perfectly balanced. Velvety mouthfeel, not gritty or mealy like Lloyd’s, and not nearly as sweet. It’s a very dreamy nostalgic bite, and from someone who has tried hundreds of carrot cakes recipes at home and out at bakeries, this is as good as it gets.
Food: 5
Loading...