Pizza is good, local pizza joint which is great. But please stop putting so much spinach on your spinach pizza, shit tasted like I was at Trader Joe’s. But overall pizza is good, real good pizza crust and sauce.
Zen Yui
used to be lit, new management and it’s bad
Food: 1
J Bwell
Pizza making is for Italians. Order ck cutlet parm. Wow no cheese Lil sauce @ the cheese i ask for wasn't on it. Don't pay up fron̈t ck your order first 15 dollars.wasred.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Oscár OA
Whoever took over this place, i hate you. This place used to be good. Now is trash. The only spot close to my place ruined by new ownership.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Kaniz Ferdous
I ordered a pizza pie the other day and it was ok but if you like lot of dough, that is I mean. I also ordered an eggplant rollatini which was not what I expected at all. It was so disappointing and the pasta w vodka sauce was a side that it came with, was also so off and bland. I use to love there pizza few years back, they really fell off sadly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
Kristin Liu-Carway
A very decent slice of Margherita pizza; although basil flavor was not strong enough, the plentiful sauce was balanced. They made it extra crispy crust for me.
The atmosphere is what you’d expect a grab-and-go joint post-dinnertime to be but I opted to dine in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jenna Nessa
Update Dec, 2025: I ended up going back several times and still order pizza from this place and didn’t make sense to leave it at one star if I kept going back. It’s the best pizza in the vicinity and I haven’t had any other issues. They have lunch specials now and deals online as well. I tried the Kosciusko pizza shop that’s popular and their crust is always too soft for the margarita. It doesn’t get crispy. ———— Previous review: Ordered online their macadamia cookies and a pizza pie and when I got there was told that they don’t the macadamia cookies and that they couldn’t refund my money. I’ve never heard of such a thing.
Food: 5
Sumon Kumar Saha
great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tony Orlando
Had this pizza Saturday, food poisoning, never eating at this place again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Pangaea
this place used to be so good. the pizza has gone downhill since the new owners/management or whatever took over. It used to be a solid 4-5 star slice now it’s definitely a 1. way too much cheese it just slides off like some molten rock on the earth. makes the crust soggy, this thing is flopping around and burning ya face. also there was no oregano. simple fix, put less cheese on it 💯lmk and then i’ll come back to try it again.
I ordered a regular Margherita pie. Grew up and lived in NYC for 26 years. Maybe the worst pizza I’ve ever had. I never thought it was possible to say this, but the put wayyyyy toooo much garlic as well. My whole house smells like garlic now too.
Food: 1
Mizanur Rahman
To be honest Brookly pizza store one of best pizza store in New York City there pie and slice test amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
C R
This spot a couple years back was legitimately the best pizza I’ve ever had check some of the other reviews and you’ll see what I’m talking about. It was absolutely legendary and made with love went here for yearsssss. Now it’s just trash not gonna lie. Most of it is incredibly mediocre. The pasta pizza is really good however but ordered Mac & cheese bites and jalapeño and it was frozen refried trash. Regular cheese slice is also like a 5/10. BRING BACK THE OLD PIZZA!!! I had never no issues regarding service though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Tanina Agosto
This usesld to be one of my favorite spots but since the new owners took over, the quality of the pizza and service has gotten terrible
Pizza is good, local pizza joint which is great. But please stop putting so much spinach on your spinach pizza, shit tasted like I was at Trader Joe’s. But overall pizza is good, real good pizza crust and sauce.
used to be lit, new management and it’s bad
Food: 1
Pizza making is for Italians. Order ck cutlet parm.
Wow no cheese Lil sauce @ the cheese i ask for wasn't on it.
Don't pay up fron̈t ck your order first 15 dollars.wasred.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Whoever took over this place, i hate you. This place used to be good. Now is trash. The only spot close to my place ruined by new ownership.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I ordered a pizza pie the other day and it was ok but if you like lot of dough, that is I mean. I also ordered an eggplant rollatini which was not what I expected at all. It was so disappointing and the pasta w vodka sauce was a side that it came with, was also so off and bland. I use to love there pizza few years back, they really fell off sadly.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 2
A very decent slice of Margherita pizza; although basil flavor was not strong enough, the plentiful sauce was balanced. They made it extra crispy crust for me.
The atmosphere is what you’d expect a grab-and-go joint post-dinnertime to be but I opted to dine in.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Update Dec, 2025: I ended up going back several times and still order pizza from this place and didn’t make sense to leave it at one star if I kept going back. It’s the best pizza in the vicinity and I haven’t had any other issues. They have lunch specials now and deals online as well. I tried the Kosciusko pizza shop that’s popular and their crust is always too soft for the margarita. It doesn’t get crispy.
————
Previous review: Ordered online their macadamia cookies and a pizza pie and when I got there was told that they don’t the macadamia cookies and that they couldn’t refund my money. I’ve never heard of such a thing.
Food: 5
great food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had this pizza Saturday, food poisoning, never eating at this place again!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
this place used to be so good. the pizza has gone downhill since the new owners/management or whatever took over. It used to be a solid 4-5 star slice now it’s definitely a 1. way too much cheese it just slides off like some molten rock on the earth. makes the crust soggy, this thing is flopping around and burning ya face. also there was no oregano. simple fix, put less cheese on it 💯lmk and then i’ll come back to try it again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a regular Margherita pie. Grew up and lived in NYC for 26 years. Maybe the worst pizza I’ve ever had. I never thought it was possible to say this, but the put wayyyyy toooo much garlic as well. My whole house smells like garlic now too.
Food: 1
To be honest Brookly pizza store one of best pizza store in New York City there pie and slice test amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This spot a couple years back was legitimately the best pizza I’ve ever had check some of the other reviews and you’ll see what I’m talking about. It was absolutely legendary and made with love went here for yearsssss. Now it’s just trash not gonna lie. Most of it is incredibly mediocre. The pasta pizza is really good however but ordered Mac & cheese bites and jalapeño and it was frozen refried trash. Regular cheese slice is also like a 5/10. BRING BACK THE OLD PIZZA!!! I had never no issues regarding service though.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
This usesld to be one of my favorite spots but since the new owners took over, the quality of the pizza and service has gotten terrible
very good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...