Brooklyn’s Best Eats

23 Hillel Pl, Brooklyn
(718) 252-1234

Recent Reviews

Randall M.

If you find yourself in the Brooklyn College vicinity, then you must try Brooklyn's Best Eats. It is a small shop with limited seating, and it can get very busy. I stopped in at the height of the lunch crowd and waited. My efforts were not in vain. I ordered an Aaron Judge sandwich, and I dined indoors. The sandwich was delicious. I did not award five stars because the bread was subpar. My bill with a bottle of Poland Spring water was $14.37. I'll be back!

Kenya W.

So glad I finally made it to this spot! Woke up craving an egg & cheese sandwich recently. Brooklyn's Best Eats DID NOT disappoint. First of all, the establishment is clean, customer service was on point, and the options are unlimited! I had scrambled egg (well done) with cheddar cheese on an everything bagel. The bagel was so good! It wasn't rock hard like most delis and tasted freshly baked. They made the eggs just how I like them (fluffy yet browned nicely) and they didn't overdo it with the cheese, which I was most grateful for! The menu options all looked so good so I know I'll be back very soon! I may try their shrimp quesadilla next! Can't wait to return!

Jaylina Leeza

The reviews are true their prices are very expensive and they charge you extra. They charged me an extra $3 “tax” for a $13 meal. They do this all time they’re taking advantage of people.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

FARRA SAINT-FLAVIN

This is my favorite place to grab a bite when i go to work. The staff is as amazing as the food is!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Fajita Wrap, Chicken Chipotle, Salads, Chicken Quesadilla

Dawn L.

The only complaint I have is all the fees however, I would pay them over and over again and I have,the Food is everything I love love love this spot, the corn muffins toasted with butter and jelly or plain OMG this is definitely a must try spot. such a great variety of different items.

Kachi Ibe

Sometimes they get your order wrong and give you an attitude about it, for the outrageous prices you think they’d always get your order right. Food is good

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Ray K.

Food is always incredibly fresh. Large variety. Quick service, clean place, nice workers.

Random Stuff

Good sandwich at an outrageous price. $11 for roast beef on a ROLL… this is unheard of at other Delis. You can find better price for the same sandwich at an other Deli.

nivia gomez

I gave two stars because they write your order down and they get it wrong. I asked to create my own salad, when I got home I realized they gave me what they wanted not what I asked for. I did not walk back to return it but I was annoyed. Also, I have ordered whole wheat sandwiches and I’ve gotten rolls instead. I don’t know if they are rushing to make food and don’t listen. Idk that I would order food from them again because they might get it wrong.

Jackie B.

Food is good, service was quick, and ambiance reminds me of when I went to Midwood. They're under new management from when I was in school but it's still worth coming back to have sandwiches from here.

Kimberly Benevento

friendly staffgreat food selectio

Fiona Chen

Despite the hefty price tag, the salads are the healthiest thing in Flatbush, wish Brooklyn College had more healthy options.

Charles Pulliam

Great hamburger ? and sweet potato fries.

Dominique G.

Recommend when you need a delicious breakfast, I've had bagels with cream cheese, omelets, and oatmeal options - or lunch (the Derek Jeter for the win!). The service is quick and efficient. It is a great place to grab and go!

AllowPeopleTheirSpaceToFlourish

I should have read the reviews first. But I was just in the area and the posters wetted my appetite. First of all the food came out cold. I was literally the only person in there, and you couldn’t make my food hot?Disappoint

Load More