Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizza

Asked them to remake a pie when mine got messed up. Manager showed up at my place and demanded the old one back and complained I ate off the old one. Never told me not to touch it or nothing - just showed up mad

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 1

Their buffalo chicken is one of my top favorite slices now. I've tried their regular and other slices, and they were great too. I love that the crust is flavorful, fluffy, and crispy.

I have ordered here a few times and have loved the Caesar salads. Ordered a 4 Caesar salads to go, none of them came with Parmesan cheese like in the past and now the side portions of dressing have gotten smaller. Very disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Did a Togoodtogo had nothing left over and didn’t cancel the order

Service: 1

Literally the perfect slice of pizza just when it was needed the most.

I’ve gotten pizza and wings from here multiple times as well as Caesar salads. My family and I enjoy the food every time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

One of my favorite spots in town for🍕

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Disrespectful and Insensitive Experience at Homeslice on 4th Avenue
My family and I visited this Homeslice location because we’re regular customers at the Vanderbilt spot, which we’ve always loved. Unfortunately, our experience here was very disappointing.
The employee at the register, Ross, was polite at first, but as soon as the manager left, his attitude completely changed. My 4-year-old son — who has sensory and special needs — was simply excited about his pizza. I had already reminded him to use a quiet voice, but Ross suddenly “shh’d” him harshly. At first, I honestly thought Ross was being playful, but then he started yelling, saying, “This is not a galley!” — directly at my child.
I calmly reminded him that my son is only four and just excited, but Ross didn’t apologize or show any understanding. It wasn’t until I asked for his name and requested to speak to a manager that he quickly said, “sorry,” then immediately repeated, “Yes, this is not a galley,” as if to justify his behavior. I stayed respectful throughout, but he was defensive, and another employee — who had already been rude to other customers — tried to excuse his actions by saying my son’s excitement was “disrupting them from hearing orders.” Meanwhile, groups of high school students were talking and laughing nearby without issue.
This experience showed a complete lack of empathy and professionalism, especially toward a young child with special needs. As loyal customers, we expected kindness and understanding — not hostility. I hope management at this location takes this seriously and provides better training on how to treat all families with patience, respect, and compassion.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Great ingredients. Served hot.

So, when a white worker walks out from the back… Sees two Black men (one ordering and one eating), and has two Latino men making pizzas behind the counter… And proceeds to say “call the police!”… And follows it up with “call ICE!”… AND THEN, when challenged about his racist jokes, says “well that’s the relationship I have with my workers” AS IF THEY HAVE A CHOICE BUT TO JUST TAKE IT…

IT IS TIME TO STOP GOING TO THIS PIZZERIA. I’ll take my pizza plain, WITHOUT a side of racism.

All jokes aside.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Friendly staff, all are welcome, great Brooklyn slices, but the big winner is the Broccoli Rabe grandma slice, just wow! So much delicious broccoli Rabe, fresh crushed tomatoes on a delicious pizza dough! Get it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Please dont go here 😢

Trash rather gonto 1 pizza 🍕 😒

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Go-to neighborhood spot. The eggplant and Sicilian slices are my favorite and the staff is lovely. Only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is because it’s not L&Bs IYKYK

Food: 4

Service: 5

Good pizza, haven't really tried that much pizza in NYC. Can't go wrong here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5