Exceptional service, outstanding craftsmanship, delicious cake. So happy we chose Buttermilk for my daughter’s birthday cake.
S Johnson
Fantastic cake, looked incredible and was delicious! Happy child and family! Thank you again for being so easy to work with as well.
Shannon Meyer
The cake buttermilk created for us was out of this world. The flavor and presentation were equally as outstanding. They also created our wedding cake, and I find myself back in there any chance I get. I make any excuse I can find to get some cookies, cupcakes, brookie (brownie/cookie) and cake ! Do not sleep on this bakery!!
Vanessa Rosado
We LOVE this shop! We go to get treats and have started ordering cakes for everything from special occasions like birthdays to what we’ve come to call ‘happy day of the week’ celebration cakes. They are a huge hit. Delivery service was amazing, too!
Ari Kaplan
Amazing cakes!!! Will be buying for all my kids birthdays
Ryan Small
We continue to use Buttermilk Bakeshop for our Daughter’s Birthday. Not only are they super reliable, they are consistent and they never disappoint.
This year they did a Barbie theme and once you tell them what you are looking for, they never disappoint. It is also a cake that actually tastes good and always a hit at every birthday party.
It is worth every penny.
Rucha Naik
I ordered my godson’s Spider-Man themed birthday cake from here. The cake looked and tasted fantastic. The website is great for ordering custom cakes. The people I interacted with were very helpful and patient working with my budget and personalization of the cake. Overall a fantastic, hassle free experience.
Suzanne LaBarbera
I ordered a birthday cake for my son who lives in Brooklyn, I am in Florida. The staff was so easy to work with. My son said the cake tastes very good and the design was really cute. I am very happy and will definitely be ordering again in the future.
D Reid
Bought a cake there recently on valentines, very underwhelming..cake was very dense, too sweet and the frosting was hard, the inside buttercream was not bad.. but overall, I’m not happy with their cake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Hermes Arriola
Amazing as always. Buttermilk Bakery catered our cakes for our wedding and we couldn’t get enough. I wanted to surprise my spouse for Valentine’s Day with some of their cakes and cupcakes. Thank you.
I am extremely satisfied with the custom cake I ordered! The bakery was very responsive throughout the process, making sure all my requests were met. The cake was a hit at the party—everyone, especially the birthday girl, absolutely loved it. Not only was it beautiful, but it was also delicious. This isn’t my first time buying a cake here, and I can confidently say it won’t be the last. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rick Estacio
For the third year in a row, we ordered our daughter’s birthday cake from Buttermilk, and for the third year in a row it tasted and looked amazing! We usually get a rainbow cake, but this year we got a Milk & Cookies cake and it was a big hit with kids and adults alike. Not to mention the kitty cat design of the cake was just as we hoped if not better. Communication with Buttermilk was great and the cake was ready at the designated pick up time. Thank you for once again being a part of our special day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cynthia Shaw
We ordered a black velvet cake with cream cheese frosting for our birthday party. It was the best cake I’ve ever had! And all of my guests were raving about it, too. So delicious! The online ordering process was easy and the cake was ready when it was promised. I’ll definitely order from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sade Ajayi
The cakes and cupcakes are divine! I ordered the honey pistachio cake for my birthday and my friends and I couldn’t stop talking about how exquisite it tasted. It was such a beautiful balance of flavours. I’ll also recommend the Coconut Cream Pie and Strawberry Shortcake cupcakes. Definitely 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Louise Benwell
Ordered a birthday cake for my daughter’s birthday. I was able to reserve a pickup slot and it tasted great!
Exceptional service, outstanding craftsmanship, delicious cake. So happy we chose Buttermilk for my daughter’s birthday cake.
Fantastic cake, looked incredible and was delicious! Happy child and family! Thank you again for being so easy to work with as well.
The cake buttermilk created for us was out of this world. The flavor and presentation were equally as outstanding. They also created our wedding cake, and I find myself back in there any chance I get. I make any excuse I can find to get some cookies, cupcakes, brookie (brownie/cookie) and cake ! Do not sleep on this bakery!!
We LOVE this shop! We go to get treats and have started ordering cakes for everything from special occasions like birthdays to what we’ve come to call ‘happy day of the week’ celebration cakes. They are a huge hit. Delivery service was amazing, too!
Amazing cakes!!! Will be buying for all my kids birthdays
We continue to use Buttermilk Bakeshop for our Daughter’s Birthday. Not only are they super reliable, they are consistent and they never disappoint.
This year they did a Barbie theme and once you tell them what you are looking for, they never disappoint. It is also a cake that actually tastes good and always a hit at every birthday party.
It is worth every penny.
I ordered my godson’s Spider-Man themed birthday cake from here. The cake looked and tasted fantastic.
The website is great for ordering custom cakes. The people I interacted with were very helpful and patient working with my budget and personalization of the cake. Overall a fantastic, hassle free experience.
I ordered a birthday cake for my son who lives in Brooklyn, I am in Florida. The staff was so easy to work with. My son said the cake tastes very good and the design was really cute. I am very happy and will definitely be ordering again in the future.
Bought a cake there recently on valentines, very underwhelming..cake was very dense, too sweet and the frosting was hard, the inside buttercream was not bad.. but overall, I’m not happy with their cake
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Amazing as always. Buttermilk Bakery catered our cakes for our wedding and we couldn’t get enough. I wanted to surprise my spouse for Valentine’s Day with some of their cakes and cupcakes. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Birthday Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
I am extremely satisfied with the custom cake I ordered! The bakery was very responsive throughout the process, making sure all my requests were met. The cake was a hit at the party—everyone, especially the birthday girl, absolutely loved it. Not only was it beautiful, but it was also delicious. This isn’t my first time buying a cake here, and I can confidently say it won’t be the last. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
For the third year in a row, we ordered our daughter’s birthday cake from Buttermilk, and for the third year in a row it tasted and looked amazing! We usually get a rainbow cake, but this year we got a Milk & Cookies cake and it was a big hit with kids and adults alike. Not to mention the kitty cat design of the cake was just as we hoped if not better. Communication with Buttermilk was great and the cake was ready at the designated pick up time. Thank you for once again being a part of our special day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a black velvet cake with cream cheese frosting for our birthday party. It was the best cake I’ve ever had! And all of my guests were raving about it, too. So delicious! The online ordering process was easy and the cake was ready when it was promised. I’ll definitely order from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cakes and cupcakes are divine! I ordered the honey pistachio cake for my birthday and my friends and I couldn’t stop talking about how exquisite it tasted. It was such a beautiful balance of flavours. I’ll also recommend the Coconut Cream Pie and Strawberry Shortcake cupcakes. Definitely 10/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake
Ordered a birthday cake for my daughter’s birthday. I was able to reserve a pickup slot and it tasted great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...