Cakes by Madelin Bakery

748 Liberty Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 627-6525

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Foxy 8489

My review is based on service since I never got my cake. Spend your money else where!! I am big on respecting people’s time and money, something this business woman claims she does. From Sept 6th I requested to use my credit for Oct 19th. Madelin didn’t care to order what I needed to get the cake I wanted. Even with ample time, she kept forcing gold on me last minute, when I wanted silver and black. She claimed I changed the date several times! Where?? when?? Look at the messages. She also changed the pickup time from 5pm to 6pm day of. I was extremely understanding and accommodating. Madelin never got back to me till 6:25pm when the version of the cake she wanted to give me was ready. Very inconsiderate of my time and plans for this day. Why not just be professional and give a refund if you couldn’t deliver on the cake that was requested!! She clearly doesn’t understand English or Spanish, she made false statements and won’t give me my money back. I gave her $160 just because I guess, so you’re in the business of stealing people money too!! She claims my message was confusing? So as a professional, why wait till the day of to try and understand what I wanted? and even if you didn’t care too, why not deliver on the rest of what I asked for at minimum?. She’s very rude and dismissive!! SAVE YOUR MONEY AND GO SOMEWHERE ELSE where you’ll get better service and quality.

Service: 1

Rosa Rodriguez

Her Cakes are very good and her designs are beautiful but she never has your cake ready on time. She makes up her own time. Also she is over priced.

Maria Cruz

It is a great pleasure to work with cakesbymadelin who are punctual and always up to date with their organized work.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Madelin Tineo

She is the best at making cake, I recommend her.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Arelis Sosa

$160+ wasted because the cake is nasty. Literally no one ate it at the event. Owner was not helpful when it came to design input and she delivered the cake at the last minute, 30 mins before event and wouldn’t allow me the opportunity to go pick it up myself. I wouldn’t come here if you are actually looking to fed people cake but the cakes are good looking.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Margarita Rivera

Her cakes are so delicious and fresh one of a kind , for all my events she’s my cake lady

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake

Wilma Gomez

She’s excellent. She makes sure you get an outstanding cake. Her vision goes beyond and surpasses your expectations. Don’t look no further, she’s the perfect Baker!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carl Estera

The cake I order and what I got was exactly the same. It surpassed my expectations and it tasted so good. 5 out 5 all around from the process, communication, and final product.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Celise Broadhead

When I say this cake was sooooo good!!!!! My family could NOT stop raving. Madelin was so sweet to accommodate my schedule by dropping my cake off at the event a few hours before it started. 10/10 recommend!!! Also, can’t deny the pure talent the bakery has.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Niraby Arias

The best cake in town!!!

Danyela Almanzar

I loved everything about this place ♥️ their desserts and cakes are the best ? something you want to eat and eat again ♥️ I recommend it for its customer service and the delicacies they sell ☺️ the place is very cozy for a coffee and a delicious dessert ♥️

Kid-friendliness: excellent place for children for a delicious dessert and not only for children but for the family, I loved the place♥️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shakira Felix

Best bakery ever cakes and treats are delicious I’ve been getting cakes from her for the past 6 years and she never failed us !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Teshanna Caesar

Ordered a 3 tier cake with 3 different flavors for my sister’s Sweet 16 OMG my self and the guest can’t get over how gorgeous and scrumptious the cake was, it right the right of my moisture, not and not overly sweet . Sent Madelin an idea of the cake I wanted and she took that idea and crafted this masterpiece. I loved everything about it. Madelin is very nice and professional she ensured to communicate with me to ensure that the finish product was what I wanted upon delivery ( being that I wasn’t at the venue) &YES SHE OFFERS DELIVERY which was a plus ??because who knows how to handle a cake in route to the location better than the baker? lol10/10 HIGHLY RECOMMEND ?PS. I already ordered another cake and on my way to placing yet another order ????

Food: 5

Service: 5

Claudine McLeod

Madelin has been making all my cakes and treats since 2018. I have never had any issues with her or her business. I enjoyed doing business with her she’s very sweet and personal. Everything was delicious and beautifully decorated she’s the best at what she does and will continue to have her make all my cake’s and treats for me and my family and friends. Thank you Madelin ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen Columna

Amazing cake service! Had a tres leches cake which I had never had before ! Great price !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...