I ran in here looking for a quick slice, not expecting to find a gem! To my surprise this is a pizzeria, bakery, and cafe all in one. The staff is very friendly and attentive. There is a wide variety of food, baked goods and coffee. The pizzeria opens up into their restaurant, which looks really nice (but I’ll get into that when I visit the restaurant). I had a wood fired margarita slice and the lasagna slice. Both were tasty and done really well. The marinara on the margarita was vibrant and flavorful while the lasagna tasted like home made lasagna my mom used to make. There was plenty of seating there. I can’t wait to stop in an again and try something else. Maybe the garlic knot chicken parm pizza. Don’t forget to grab a cannoli or maybe some gelato on the way out to enjoy at home. I was really impressed. If you’re in the area, stop in
Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Atmosphere: 5
Seating type: in a addition to tables there is countertop seating here at the care area
Vegetarian options: plenty of vegetarian options
Dietary restrictions: the staff seemed very accommodating
Parking space: no designated parking area
Parking options: street parking can be tricky here
Wheelchair accessibility: this restaurant is wheelchair accessible
Ronald Houston
I was online waiting to be served and I had been skipped and the white man behind me was served in fact I was the last of 6 people on line to get my food and I only was waiting for a slice victor was my server very racist I would never eat their again very prejudice atmosphere great food but if ur black enter with caution ⚠️ very sad to say this but this is not the only incident it happened to me before at this same establishment
Michel Nee
Every bite delivers pure enjoyment. This restaurant maintains highest quality always. The workers showed skill while maintaining warmth. Carmine's repeatedly delivers on promises. Our family has added this to our favorites.
Anthony Witkowski
Best pizza
Robyn Palmeri
I cannot give this restaurant enough stars! Carmine is AMAZING amd so is his food, staff, and atmosphere! I would choose this place over and over again to eat and celebrate whether im by myself orhaving a party of 25 people with me. Impeccable food, wine, pizza, pasta, service....all of it! Thank you for making our 10 year wedding anniversary party a night to never forget!!!!!
Diana Vita Leavy
This is definitely a neighborhood gem. The best Chicken Francese I have ever tasted - and I have tasted quite a few in NYC. Prices are incredibly reasonable. The presence of the owner adds to the dining experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Otero
I came to this place because it was recommended by my patient. I ordered two slices, bake clams, and steam muscles in garlic sauce. The Pizza was burnt. The muscles had no salt or garlic. The baked clams was toss. The customer service when you’re working in that area, they should be bubbly and they looked all miserable. The drinks was sugared down and watery when I asked to make it a little stronger. I gave a tip, but I was unsatisfied with the Services. Waiters and waitress should always be happy and attentive to people. I was very polite. I was scared to say anything wrong because of the bad looks. This is why I go to Howard Beach and get the real food from Lenny’s on Howard Beach and the service there is phenomenal from teenagers. sometimes maybe if you pay your employees better they work better, but the staff wasn’t happy and the food wasn’t good. Waiting for my patient to come back to tell him he doesn’t know real food. I spend 85 dollars with tip and went down on it. I’m all about svc. Btw just because you have a stone oven doesn’t mean you know how to make a pizza pie.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Matt Roberge
Excellent every time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
R. Rodriguez
Some of the best square slices, so many different options, typically spend $21-$25 for three people when it comes to slices and pin wheels there's two entrances one is for simple pizza orders next door is the restaurant very busy atmosphere sometimes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Truffle Mushroom Pizza by the Slice, White Pizza, Garlic Knots, Regular NY Slice, Grandma Slice, Plain Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Grandma Pie, Sausage Pepperoni Pie, Baby Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza, Slice of Pizza
We sat at the bar, food was amazing, great service from the bartender and the atmosphere was perfect for any live sport event you want to watch! We are definitely coming back for next baseball game
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pepperoni Pie, Slice of Pizza
Joe Hicks
Always impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zero Gravity Moving
I would say easily the best pizza in NY??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenni Aleja
(I’ve never seen in my life a bartender kissing her customer in the mouth in front of the other people). It’s the worst service I’ve ever had. My boyfriend asked for 2 simple beers at the bar and when I arrived, I asked for a whiskey sour, I waited 10 minutes to get my whiskey sour and I then got a simple whiskey soda up!! Incredible, I got something that I never asked for! When I told the manager because of the female bartender was ignoring us and she knew about my upset because of my face (I can’t hide it), she said: I know where you’re coming from and I understand but I don’t have any eggs for the whiskey sour. Sooooo, if you know that and you’re working on service, you should be more patient with no Americans and you should tell about “I don’t have any eggs for the whiskey sour”, (which business doesn’t have any eggs when they have a kitchen?) you got it? It’s logical at least ask one time in the day an one person that looks like NOT American and that person can be a tourist or not the industry, but I work in the industry and I need to ask if the person is ok without one ingredient in the drink, I need to CHECK, and the whiskey sour is NOT a fine drink (like she expressed to me), it’s a classic cocktail in the city instead! By the way, the manager never supported us too, he allowed that she treated me in a bad way and finally, she said: “don’t come back”. Beautiful! I’m pretty sure I won’t come back. Thank you! You know? You are in New York City, you have to deal with it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Arianna Campbell
Amazing pizza!!! Perfect crunch, cheese pull, cooked to perfection.
Nice place. Good prices.
I ran in here looking for a quick slice, not expecting to find a gem! To my surprise this is a pizzeria, bakery, and cafe all in one. The staff is very friendly and attentive. There is a wide variety of food, baked goods and coffee. The pizzeria opens up into their restaurant, which looks really nice (but I’ll get into that when I visit the restaurant). I had a wood fired margarita slice and the lasagna slice. Both were tasty and done really well. The marinara on the margarita was vibrant and flavorful while the lasagna tasted like home made lasagna my mom used to make. There was plenty of seating there. I can’t wait to stop in an again and try something else. Maybe the garlic knot chicken parm pizza. Don’t forget to grab a cannoli or maybe some gelato on the way out to enjoy at home. I was really impressed. If you’re in the area, stop in
Food: 5 | Service: 5 | Atmosphere: 5
Seating type: in a addition to tables there is countertop seating here at the care area
Vegetarian options: plenty of vegetarian options
Dietary restrictions: the staff seemed very accommodating
Parking space: no designated parking area
Parking options: street parking can be tricky here
Wheelchair accessibility: this restaurant is wheelchair accessible
I was online waiting to be served and I had been skipped and the white man behind me was served in fact I was the last of 6 people on line to get my food and I only was waiting for a slice victor was my server very racist I would never eat their again very prejudice atmosphere great food but if ur black enter with caution ⚠️ very sad to say this but this is not the only incident it happened to me before at this same establishment
Every bite delivers pure enjoyment. This restaurant maintains highest quality always. The workers showed skill while maintaining warmth. Carmine's repeatedly delivers on promises. Our family has added this to our favorites.
Best pizza
I cannot give this restaurant enough stars! Carmine is AMAZING amd so is his food, staff, and atmosphere! I would choose this place over and over again to eat and celebrate whether im by myself orhaving a party of 25 people with me. Impeccable food, wine, pizza, pasta, service....all of it! Thank you for making our 10 year wedding anniversary party a night to never forget!!!!!
This is definitely a neighborhood gem. The best Chicken Francese I have ever tasted - and I have tasted quite a few in NYC. Prices are incredibly reasonable. The presence of the owner adds to the dining experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came to this place because it was recommended by my patient. I ordered two slices, bake clams, and steam muscles in garlic sauce. The Pizza was burnt. The muscles had no salt or garlic. The baked clams was toss. The customer service when you’re working in that area, they should be bubbly and they looked all miserable. The drinks was sugared down and watery when I asked to make it a little stronger. I gave a tip, but I was unsatisfied with the Services. Waiters and waitress should always be happy and attentive to people. I was very polite. I was scared to say anything wrong because of the bad looks. This is why I go to Howard Beach and get the real food from Lenny’s on Howard Beach and the service there is phenomenal from teenagers. sometimes maybe if you pay your employees better they work better, but the staff wasn’t happy and the food wasn’t good. Waiting for my patient to come back to tell him he doesn’t know real food. I spend 85 dollars with tip and went down on it. I’m all about svc. Btw just because you have a stone oven doesn’t mean you know how to make a pizza pie.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent every time
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Some of the best square slices, so many different options, typically spend $21-$25 for three people when it comes to slices and pin wheels there's two entrances one is for simple pizza orders next door is the restaurant very busy atmosphere sometimes
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Truffle Mushroom Pizza by the Slice, White Pizza, Garlic Knots, Regular NY Slice, Grandma Slice, Plain Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Grandma Pie, Sausage Pepperoni Pie, Baby Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza, Slice of Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
We sat at the bar, food was amazing, great service from the bartender and the atmosphere was perfect for any live sport event you want to watch! We are definitely coming back for next baseball game
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Pepperoni Pie, Slice of Pizza
Always impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I would say easily the best pizza in NY??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
(I’ve never seen in my life a bartender kissing her customer in the mouth in front of the other people). It’s the worst service I’ve ever had. My boyfriend asked for 2 simple beers at the bar and when I arrived, I asked for a whiskey sour, I waited 10 minutes to get my whiskey sour and I then got a simple whiskey soda up!! Incredible, I got something that I never asked for! When I told the manager because of the female bartender was ignoring us and she knew about my upset because of my face (I can’t hide it), she said: I know where you’re coming from and I understand but I don’t have any eggs for the whiskey sour. Sooooo, if you know that and you’re working on service, you should be more patient with no Americans and you should tell about “I don’t have any eggs for the whiskey sour”, (which business doesn’t have any eggs when they have a kitchen?) you got it? It’s logical at least ask one time in the day an one person that looks like NOT American and that person can be a tourist or not the industry, but I work in the industry and I need to ask if the person is ok without one ingredient in the drink, I need to CHECK, and the whiskey sour is NOT a fine drink (like she expressed to me), it’s a classic cocktail in the city instead! By the way, the manager never supported us too, he allowed that she treated me in a bad way and finally, she said: “don’t come back”. Beautiful! I’m pretty sure I won’t come back. Thank you! You know? You are in New York City, you have to deal with it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amazing pizza!!! Perfect crunch, cheese pull, cooked to perfection.
Loading...