Catskill Bagel Co.

1416 Cortelyou Rd, Brooklyn
(718) 282-5049

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emily Adkisson

First time eating a salt bagel. Was great and very delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

B. Saszare

Too sweet!!! Tastes like cake to me.
$2.00 a plain bagel?!!!! C’mon!!!
I’ve seen these prices charged on Madison Avenue.

They raised their bagel prices
35 percent in the 6 months since I’ve been here. That’s shameful, considering that inflation and food costs haven’t gone up 35 percent in 6 months. I know what food business operating costs are since I used to be in the business, and these prices are not a place I would recommend to anyone, considering the inconsistency of the bagels. And no, these are not the classic New York bagels that I am use to eating.

The decor is ok, but not a single member of that staff or manager/owner said hello or welcomed me, and I was one of only 2 customers in the store. It felt cold.
I sincerely would have appreciated someone saying hi to me, or even a thank you after my purchase (nope- that didn’t happen).

$2.00 for a plain bagel (May 2023)
$1.50 for the plain bagel (Aug 2022)

Melanie Cortez

They just ignored me and two people skip ahead me in the line. It’s a really bad first impression to be so rude. I went to connecticut muffin down the street and got much better treatment.

Ece Era

I specifically asked for the bread to be toasted, multiple times even, and it was extremely soft. Not even toasted a tiny bit. I had to go home and toast it myself.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

yvette donis

I ordered a muffin , she asked me if I wanted to warm it up because it was cold. I asked her why would it be cold? . She put it in a toaster to warm it and gave it to me after. however, when I bit into it was as cold as ice and a bit stale. If you’re charging $4.50 for a muffin it should at least be warm and fresh.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 3

D L

Love this place! The bagels and food are excellent and the staff is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dev Ranjan

Don’t understand the low ratings because this place actually has great bagels.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ian Ellison

We visited this place for breakfast, and it exceeded our expectations. The portion sizes were generous considering the price. We got two BLTs with cheese and added turkey. I can’t lie, I was ready for bed after we ate. We got one BLT on a wrap and the other on a plain bagel. The bagels here are freshly baked daily and have a warm, soft interior with a delightful crisp exterior. Every bite was packed.

As for the food, I’ve dined here a few times and never had any disappointing experiences. They have a well-rounded menu and a variety of drinks to choose from. Additionally, they offer some delectable baked goods and fresh juices at the counter.

If you’re in the area, I highly recommend stopping by for a bite.

Food: 4 | Service: 4 | Atmosphere: 3

Seating type:The offer indoor and outdoor seating. It can get packed here during the morning rush, but I go late in the morning so there always seating available.

Vegetarian options: there are plenty of vegetarian options

Dietary restrictions: the staff is very accommodating. They will do their best

Parking space: there is no designated parking for this establishment

Parking options: plenty of street parking

Kid-friendliness: all the kids I see in there love it

Wheelchair accessibility: they are wheelchair accessible

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ayinde Samuel

Inconsistent quality of food, and they get your order wrong even after vigorously attempting to articulate what you want clearly.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Shel M

Got the grapefruit juice and the yoghurt with oats. Oats were very bad, maybe the juice too. Ended up getting food poisoning :(

Crane Tecce

Seriously, these guys are awesome. Been there in person and the service was incredible.. ordered delivery and the food is always on point. Soup of the day never disappoints and the Lox bagels are some of the best in BK. Can’t take a photo because I ate too fast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brianna Melissa

Love getting my salads from here. Nice and fresh food

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Salad

Phillip Kautz

Great morning option for the area. Very good bagels with many great choices on top.
Very popular so it can be crowded including stroller issues.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Ambreen Khan

I bought 2 plain bagels first time buy from here unfortunately I don’t recommend the bagel to buy from here it waste of money bagel is hard to chew is like gum i was living around will never buy from here

Food: 1

Megan Lang

I wish I'd read some reviews. The bagels are good but prices are too high and not clear, and the vibes are weird. Good spread of tofu cream cheese options though.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 2

Loading...