Neat place. A bit pricey. You don’t really have time to see what flavors are available before you have to place your order, which felt rushed. My son got a vanilla shake and it was pretty bland. I would have preferred Dairy Queen.
Eli Brown
Coney’s Cones - Absolutely Divine Gelato - A Boardwalk Must-Visit! CONEY'S CONES is an absolute gem on the boardwalk, and I can't recommend it highly enough! From the moment you walk up, you're greeted with a vibrant display of what truly is fresh and delicious gelato. The sheer variety of flavors is impressive, offering something for every palate, and each one I tried was bursting with authentic taste. What really sets CONEY'S CONES apart, beyond the incredible quality, is the service. The staff genuinely know how to serve gelato – a skill that's surprisingly rare! They create beautiful cones and, crucially, they give you a truly great portion for your money. It's clear they take pride in their product and customer experience. Honestly, this gelato stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the best we've had in European countries. If you're on the boardwalk and craving an unforgettable frozen treat, do yourself a favor and stop by CONEY'S CONES. You won't be disappointed!
Helene Williams
Bit disappointing, not very tasty. Big enough portion!
Hossam Eshmawy
I love stopping by this beautiful little ice cream shop during summer! Don’t worry about the lines—they move fast. Great variety of flavors at reasonable prices. The mango/raspberry combo is a must-try! So refreshing. A perfect treat when visiting Coney Island! 🍦
William Laast
Delicious coconut and pistachio gelato. Good milkshakes as well
Krammer Avillan
This is a very good location for those sunny days on the boardwalk. We stopped in to give it a try and weren’t disappointed, we got pistachio and Nutella crunch and were very pleased. Next time I come I’m going to try the Milano cookie vanilla since they were out that day.
Went there to get an ice cream with my friend before enjoying the luna park. Unfortunately, the mango flavoured one tasted like salted fish. Thought I had a stroke. My friend tried it and came to the same conclusion. Had to toss the ice cream all together. My friend's coconut ice cream was great though. We googled reviews afterward and saw another one about the fishy flavour of the supposed mango. How and - most importantly - why they make it this way?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Jin Ho Choe
Commercially made, artificially flavored ice cream in the form of gelato. Even more disappointing is that it's worse than Baskin-Robbins...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone
Jimmy cacco (The-Graphist-JAYC STUDIO)
The place to enjoy an ice cream!!! top
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Daniel Sant
Excellent ice cream on the splendid seafront of Coney's Island. It's not Italian ice cream but it's still very good and big.
Neat place. A bit pricey. You don’t really have time to see what flavors are available before you have to place your order, which felt rushed. My son got a vanilla shake and it was pretty bland. I would have preferred Dairy Queen.
Coney’s Cones - Absolutely Divine Gelato - A Boardwalk Must-Visit!
CONEY'S CONES is an absolute gem on the boardwalk, and I can't recommend it highly enough! From the moment you walk up, you're greeted with a vibrant display of what truly is fresh and delicious gelato. The sheer variety of flavors is impressive, offering something for every palate, and each one I tried was bursting with authentic taste.
What really sets CONEY'S CONES apart, beyond the incredible quality, is the service. The staff genuinely know how to serve gelato – a skill that's surprisingly rare! They create beautiful cones and, crucially, they give you a truly great portion for your money. It's clear they take pride in their product and customer experience.
Honestly, this gelato stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the best we've had in European countries. If you're on the boardwalk and craving an unforgettable frozen treat, do yourself a favor and stop by CONEY'S CONES. You won't be disappointed!
Bit disappointing, not very tasty.
Big enough portion!
I love stopping by this beautiful little ice cream shop during summer! Don’t worry about the lines—they move fast. Great variety of flavors at reasonable prices. The mango/raspberry combo is a must-try! So refreshing. A perfect treat when visiting Coney Island! 🍦
Delicious coconut and pistachio gelato. Good milkshakes as well
This is a very good location for those sunny days on the boardwalk. We stopped in to give it a try and weren’t disappointed, we got pistachio and Nutella crunch and were very pleased. Next time I come I’m going to try the Milano cookie vanilla since they were out that day.
Crowded place but great granitas.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone, Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream, Gelato, Chocolate Ice Cream
Not much choice of perfume and industrial taste
Food: 3
Service: 5
The ice cream ? was amazing, I will come for a visit again someday.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Donut, Coney's Cones, Waffle Cone, Coney Island Custard, Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream, Chocolate Ice Cream
My husband said the cappuccino gelato was really delicious and had the perfect amount of crunch. The staff was friendly and the place was packed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Still best gelato & espresso I tried in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went there to get an ice cream with my friend before enjoying the luna park. Unfortunately, the mango flavoured one tasted like salted fish. Thought I had a stroke. My friend tried it and came to the same conclusion. Had to toss the ice cream all together. My friend's coconut ice cream was great though. We googled reviews afterward and saw another one about the fishy flavour of the supposed mango. How and - most importantly - why they make it this way?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Commercially made, artificially flavored ice cream in the form of gelato. Even more disappointing is that it's worse than Baskin-Robbins...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Waffle Cone
The place to enjoy an ice cream!!! top
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent ice cream on the splendid seafront of Coney's Island. It's not Italian ice cream but it's still very good and big.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...