Went there with my four kids it was TERRIBLE! Ee asked for four cones we paid almost $30 then we started to order but the workers who was making pur ice creams but they gave us in cups then when one of my girls said she wanted a cone she just added the cone on top of her cup then my other girl said that we all wanted a cone but the worker wasnt even trying to understand stand us and the ice creams were almost tasteless and it was dripping so much!!dont go!!
Neysa Dejesus
Came in for an ice cream cone on a gorgeous night with my niece. Ordered a vanilla cone. The girl served it in a cup and put the cone on top. I made her change it to an actual cone I ordered. All employees rolling eyes and being rude and it's their own stupidity. Do better.
Daniel Martinez
The Gelato was good but the employees were so rude, they got mad because we asked for Nutella crunch and they didn’t have it
Diyanat Choudhury
I got the regular size cup with Coney Island custard and Cookie Monster. The custard was amazing, it had a nice taste of condensed milk that wasn’t too heavy. The gelato was also very silky. Cookie Monster was delicious too, it had a cotton candy taste and the cookies inside made for a good sort of chocolatey taste too go along with it. The only problem I really have is that the cups are too small for the portions given. The second we went outside the icecream started melting very very rapidly. It felt like a race against time to shovel each scoop into our mouth because it was dripping outside the cup onto the ground, our clothes, and making our hands sticky. I feel like the portion size was perfect, any less icecream and it was wouldn’t feel worth the eight dollars, it’s just the cup sizes.
Lediya W
I was at Coney Island for vacation, I stopped by to get ice cream, it’s one of the best cream I’ve ever had. They give you so much amount. The employees were very friendly too. I would move there for the ice creams
JC Testud
Underappreciated ice cream spot. I had the pistachio, hazelnut, and Coney Island Custard, each one was excellent. Light and airy, with a milky texture like true gelato. Felt very natural to me. None of the artificial coloring or overpowering aroma that plagues most pistachio ice cream out there.
shirley d
One of the best gelatos i had.
Tony Anczer
Neat place. A bit pricey. You don’t really have time to see what flavors are available before you have to place your order, which felt rushed. My son got a vanilla shake and it was pretty bland. I would have preferred Dairy Queen.
Coney’s Cones - Absolutely Divine Gelato - A Boardwalk Must-Visit! CONEY'S CONES is an absolute gem on the boardwalk, and I can't recommend it highly enough! From the moment you walk up, you're greeted with a vibrant display of what truly is fresh and delicious gelato. The sheer variety of flavors is impressive, offering something for every palate, and each one I tried was bursting with authentic taste. What really sets CONEY'S CONES apart, beyond the incredible quality, is the service. The staff genuinely know how to serve gelato – a skill that's surprisingly rare! They create beautiful cones and, crucially, they give you a truly great portion for your money. It's clear they take pride in their product and customer experience. Honestly, this gelato stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the best we've had in European countries. If you're on the boardwalk and craving an unforgettable frozen treat, do yourself a favor and stop by CONEY'S CONES. You won't be disappointed!
Helene Williams
Bit disappointing, not very tasty. Big enough portion!
Hossam Eshmawy
I love stopping by this beautiful little ice cream shop during summer! Don’t worry about the lines—they move fast. Great variety of flavors at reasonable prices. The mango/raspberry combo is a must-try! So refreshing. A perfect treat when visiting Coney Island! 🍦
William Laast
Delicious coconut and pistachio gelato. Good milkshakes as well
Krammer Avillan
This is a very good location for those sunny days on the boardwalk. We stopped in to give it a try and weren’t disappointed, we got pistachio and Nutella crunch and were very pleased. Next time I come I’m going to try the Milano cookie vanilla since they were out that day.
Strawberry was my favorite!
One of the best in the town gelato.
Went there with my four kids it was TERRIBLE! Ee asked for four cones we paid almost $30 then we started to order but the workers who was making pur ice creams but they gave us in cups then when one of my girls said she wanted a cone she just added the cone on top of her cup then my other girl said that we all wanted a cone but the worker wasnt even trying to understand stand us and the ice creams were almost tasteless and it was dripping so much!!dont go!!
Came in for an ice cream cone on a gorgeous night with my niece. Ordered a vanilla cone. The girl served it in a cup and put the cone on top. I made her change it to an actual cone I ordered. All employees rolling eyes and being rude and it's their own stupidity. Do better.
The Gelato was good but the employees were so rude, they got mad because we asked for Nutella crunch and they didn’t have it
I got the regular size cup with Coney Island custard and Cookie Monster. The custard was amazing, it had a nice taste of condensed milk that wasn’t too heavy. The gelato was also very silky. Cookie Monster was delicious too, it had a cotton candy taste and the cookies inside made for a good sort of chocolatey taste too go along with it. The only problem I really have is that the cups are too small for the portions given. The second we went outside the icecream started melting very very rapidly. It felt like a race against time to shovel each scoop into our mouth because it was dripping outside the cup onto the ground, our clothes, and making our hands sticky. I feel like the portion size was perfect, any less icecream and it was wouldn’t feel worth the eight dollars, it’s just the cup sizes.
I was at Coney Island for vacation, I stopped by to get ice cream, it’s one of the best cream I’ve ever had. They give you so much amount. The employees were very friendly too. I would move there for the ice creams
Underappreciated ice cream spot. I had the pistachio, hazelnut, and Coney Island Custard, each one was excellent. Light and airy, with a milky texture like true gelato. Felt very natural to me. None of the artificial coloring or overpowering aroma that plagues most pistachio ice cream out there.
One of the best gelatos i had.
Neat place. A bit pricey. You don’t really have time to see what flavors are available before you have to place your order, which felt rushed. My son got a vanilla shake and it was pretty bland. I would have preferred Dairy Queen.
Restaurantji Recommends
Coney’s Cones - Absolutely Divine Gelato - A Boardwalk Must-Visit!
CONEY'S CONES is an absolute gem on the boardwalk, and I can't recommend it highly enough! From the moment you walk up, you're greeted with a vibrant display of what truly is fresh and delicious gelato. The sheer variety of flavors is impressive, offering something for every palate, and each one I tried was bursting with authentic taste.
What really sets CONEY'S CONES apart, beyond the incredible quality, is the service. The staff genuinely know how to serve gelato – a skill that's surprisingly rare! They create beautiful cones and, crucially, they give you a truly great portion for your money. It's clear they take pride in their product and customer experience.
Honestly, this gelato stands shoulder-to-shoulder with the best we've had in European countries. If you're on the boardwalk and craving an unforgettable frozen treat, do yourself a favor and stop by CONEY'S CONES. You won't be disappointed!
Bit disappointing, not very tasty.
Big enough portion!
I love stopping by this beautiful little ice cream shop during summer! Don’t worry about the lines—they move fast. Great variety of flavors at reasonable prices. The mango/raspberry combo is a must-try! So refreshing. A perfect treat when visiting Coney Island! 🍦
Delicious coconut and pistachio gelato. Good milkshakes as well
This is a very good location for those sunny days on the boardwalk. We stopped in to give it a try and weren’t disappointed, we got pistachio and Nutella crunch and were very pleased. Next time I come I’m going to try the Milano cookie vanilla since they were out that day.
Loading...