Wildly inconsistent. Some nights it’s a solid local spot, others it’s some of the worst garbage I cannot believe they sent out the door. The pizza tonight was a disgusting mess. Not the first time it’s happened. The prices are also skyrocketing while the average quality of an order is dropping hard.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Anum Khan
Booked a catering order with Anthony and he made the process very smooth, and easy! Food was delicious, warm, and on time and quantity was exactly perfect for the crowd. Quantity, portions, bread, sauce everything worked out perfectly. Highly recommend for any corporate, birthday, or celebration needs!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph A
I go to Park Slope often as my favorite pizzeria and Italian restaurant are there, but I’ve never been to Da Nonna Rosa. I’ve ordered pizza about 5 times now in the past year and a half and it deserves a good review.
The pizza has never let me down. It’s a nice thin, tender crust. I usually like crispy but this works; maybe because of the delivery time it loses the crisp not sure. The sauce is tangy and very flavorful. You don’t feel bad after eating a few slices lol. They are light and delicious. The prices are also reasonable.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Theo Azak
Delicious pizza and pasta
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rich Episcopo
Do not go there for pizza. Grandma style was underdone, very floppy, and greasy the last two times. The picture was pizza few minutes after it came out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Gianna Aquilina
Got an order of their fettuccine Alfredo it was a whopping $31 and had impressively absolutely no flavor to it. Would not recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Emma Verner
love this place!!! food is consistently excellent and staff is so kind — called about an issue with an uber eats order and they generously and quickly resolved it.
Susan JD
Disappointed with the food here - I will say that Dine-in is much better. The take out has been not very good. eggplant was undercooked, pasta was overcooked and tasteless.
Food: 2
Russell Lane
My favorite fancy pizza in Brooklyn
Harold Gonzalez
A pizza shop that wants to be an Italian restaurant. From their website I was extremely misled on thinking it would be a more upscale experience. When I got there, there were kids running around and the place had outdated decor. the food is meh, the calamari is mostly bland but not the worst I’ve had and the stuffed mushrooms were the most bland I’ve ever had in my life. I also ordered a shrimp scampi which is around 30 something dollars and when I got it, it had no pasta. what kind of place makes a shrimp scampi with no pasta I basically paid that much for 5 shrimps, then I was told that you need to order the pasta as a side the shrimp tasted like they pulled it out of a super market shrimp cocktail pack and then they grilled it. I wouldn’t come here expecting a true restaurant experience. It’s just a pizza spot and nothing more. Staff was still very amazing. But I’ll never come back ever again.
Terrible food , I ordered food from them and it arrived burned and inedible.
kl ry
Family style, large dishes, good American Italian food. Nothing fancy and nothing needs to be fancy, just good tasty food.
Barry Katz
Delicious!!! Outstanding family and friends place to enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ishtiaque Zaman
Ordered a pie from there 2xs and had 2 slices of Buffalo chicken, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots about 3 years ago circa 2022. This place is the no 1 best Italian restaurant without a big huge doubt. I just wanna try their pastas someday because heard good things about it. Really want to and have to try their pastas someday for sure no doubt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nate
Horrible service. Leaving slices on the display that have already been ordered.
Wildly inconsistent. Some nights it’s a solid local spot, others it’s some of the worst garbage I cannot believe they sent out the door. The pizza tonight was a disgusting mess. Not the first time it’s happened. The prices are also skyrocketing while the average quality of an order is dropping hard.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Booked a catering order with Anthony and he made the process very smooth, and easy! Food was delicious, warm, and on time and quantity was exactly perfect for the crowd. Quantity, portions, bread, sauce everything worked out perfectly. Highly recommend for any corporate, birthday, or celebration needs!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I go to Park Slope often as my favorite pizzeria and Italian restaurant are there, but I’ve never been to Da Nonna Rosa. I’ve ordered pizza about 5 times now in the past year and a half and it deserves a good review.
The pizza has never let me down. It’s a nice thin, tender crust. I usually like crispy but this works; maybe because of the delivery time it loses the crisp not sure. The sauce is tangy and very flavorful. You don’t feel bad after eating a few slices lol. They are light and delicious. The prices are also reasonable.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza and pasta
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Do not go there for pizza. Grandma style was underdone, very floppy, and greasy the last two times. The picture was pizza few minutes after it came out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Got an order of their fettuccine Alfredo it was a whopping $31 and had impressively absolutely no flavor to it. Would not recommend.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
love this place!!! food is consistently excellent and staff is so kind — called about an issue with an uber eats order and they generously and quickly resolved it.
Disappointed with the food here - I will say that Dine-in is much better. The take out has been not very good. eggplant was undercooked, pasta was overcooked and tasteless.
Food: 2
My favorite fancy pizza in Brooklyn
A pizza shop that wants to be an Italian restaurant. From their website I was extremely misled on thinking it would be a more upscale experience. When I got there, there were kids running around and the place had outdated decor. the food is meh, the calamari is mostly bland but not the worst I’ve had and the stuffed mushrooms were the most bland I’ve ever had in my life. I also ordered a shrimp scampi which is around 30 something dollars and when I got it, it had no pasta. what kind of place makes a shrimp scampi with no pasta I basically paid that much for 5 shrimps, then I was told that you need to order the pasta as a side the shrimp tasted like they pulled it out of a super market shrimp cocktail pack and then they grilled it. I wouldn’t come here expecting a true restaurant experience. It’s just a pizza spot and nothing more. Staff was still very amazing. But I’ll never come back ever again.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Terrible food , I ordered food from them and it arrived burned and inedible.
Family style, large dishes, good American Italian food. Nothing fancy and nothing needs to be fancy, just good tasty food.
Delicious!!! Outstanding family and friends place to enjoy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a pie from there 2xs and had 2 slices of Buffalo chicken, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots about 3 years ago circa 2022. This place is the no 1 best Italian restaurant without a big huge doubt. I just wanna try their pastas someday because heard good things about it. Really want to and have to try their pastas someday for sure no doubt.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible service. Leaving slices on the display that have already been ordered.
Service: 1
Loading...