Dickey's Barbecue Pit

196A Flatbush Ave Ste A, Brooklyn
(347) 889-5400

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian Yount

That's a 100 dollar family meal, guys. Three cups of (I swear) bushes baked beans, two slices of yesterday's toast (complete with a mustard splotches on one) and 6 meager slices of what I can only describe as DOGFOOD. On behalf of me and my FAMILY, YOU GUYS ABSOLUTELY SUCK.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

D C

I ordered takeout, so I don't know if it's better if you eat in the restaurant, but this is the most mediocre BBQ I've ever had. The macaroni had hard noodles in it like it was old and the bread roll they gave me was a disgrace. I literally laughed it was so hard. It was inedible. Also, the three meat platter comes with one rib. That's right, ONE SINGULAR RIB. It tasted fine but a single rib is laughable. Brisket was okay and I didn't really like the jalapeno sausage, but that may just be personal taste. Definitely not worth a visit. There is WAY better BBQ in Brooklyn.

Food: 2

Paloma Cui

This 3 meat meal costed $20.99 before tax. Brisket is literally 2 small slices, 4 pieces of sausages and ONE pork rib. This feels like a rip-off. Brisket is loose which somehow feels old. Flavor is ok but portion is no no.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Jessica Tigner

Their phone doesn't work so I can't call them and advise that someone has hacked my account and placed a fraudulent order via the website.

Da Dodge Diva79

My video shows the brisket. I was given a chance to taste the brisket, macaroni, potato salad and BBQ chicken. Everything was excellent service was outstanding and the food is beautiful. Thank you for everything Louis. Outstanding

Nun Yuh

Ordered from Grubhub, and delivery was great but the food itself was not. The brisket was mostly fat and the pulled pork was dry as heck, the bread roll was hard and dry as well. The loaded baked potatoes were just straight disgusting. Plus it was small portions but not small price. Will never order from or visit this establishment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joseph Hernandez

The food and service are good. The place looks rundown and needs to be made over.

Parking: There's street parking. Also, there are several parking garages nearby.

Wheelchair accessibility: It's a street level entrance.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Beef Brisket Sandwich Platter, Pulled Pork Sandwich

Lori Yang

This barbecue tastes so bad. It's dry and the only seasoning they use is this watery barbecue sauce. The portions are so small and the prices are so expensive. It's terrible. Don't come here.

Karina Alamo

Right off the bat service and the atmosphere was incredible everyone was so sweet and patient and in great spirits! The food was soo flavorful and very good portions my favorites were the sliced brisket and the sweet potato casserole. There’s so many food options and FREEE ICECREAM ❤️? highly Recommend trying this place I’ll definitely be back

Brandon Sanchez

I would recommend not ever ordering from here. Maybe its better if you eat at the location, but the images online are not true to what is given. My image shows a two meat plate and a pulled pork sandwich which came out to nearly 40$ before any fees and tip. There is no value here. the portions were honestly shocking for the quality. For the same price please take your money to a better bbq place like Fette sau or pig beach. Even dallas bbq was better for less. This was my first and last time ordering.

Mike Cee

I feel robbed. We spent $70+, including delivery fees, and all we got was a small portion. The 2 meat plate starts at $22.75, however if you add ribs, one of the most common bbq foods, they add an additional $3.00 to your meal. The burnt ends also add an additional charge. In total a 2 meat plate with ribs and burnt ends comes to $28.25 pre-tax. And all you get are 2 ribs and a few pieces of burnt ends! At least in places like Dino BBQ a 2 piece meat combo comes with a half rack of ribs (6) and more pieces of meat for $25.00 pre-tax! The taste wasn't even that good. The green beans had a weird taste, the creamed spinach was bland. I feel completely robbed of money paying $60.00 before delivery fees and tax for small, bland portions, and not even a drink. I understand that times are tough but this is highway robbery. I would suggest everyone stay away from this place for delivery. I can't speak for dine-in portions but delivery portions are a scam.

Food: 1

Michael Bednark

Ordered Uber eats. Spent $90.Portions and quality equivalent to spending $30 at KFC. Stay far far away from this scam.Bowl of chili $12

Harlem Beloved

Let me just say I was introduced to Dickies just 2 weeks ago while in South Carolina.. I fell in love with this food and was super excited to find out they have a Brooklyn location even though I live in The Bronx.. My wife and I went there last night and it was a total disappointment......... The taste was good however the portions are RIDICULOUSLY SMALL in terms of the meat... It's not even half of what they gave down south let alone the tray was bigger than the French fry container they gave in Brooklyn..... To sit in traffic, pay a toll and to be charged those prices for such a small portion and to still be hungry afterwards is deplorable....To make matters worse I was told that the 2 meat meal did NOT include ribs... No sign posted, just word from the employee that stated this was as per the manager... I didn't have this problem in SC so I expect a better answer rather than "That's what the manager said".....After waiting for this disappointment order I had the displeasure if using a rest room that was absolutely disgusting....Next time I will just wait until I get back to South Carolina.. I knew it was too good to be true.... DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY......OH and I almost forgot, $18 for a half rack of ribs is insane.. There isn't that much inflation in the world........

Davian Corbin

I will Never order from here again. I wish I had read the online reviews before ordering on Uber eats. Unfortunately Uber eats doesn’t allow you to see reviews. The portion sizes are TINY. To be exact 40$ and change gets you 3 ribs sized between 3-4.5 inches. 1 2.5 inch slice of brisket. And 1/4 cup if chopped fat brisket( if you round up) 1/3 cup of the 2 sides. This is for the 3 meat meal. I was upset at even accepting the food from the delivery person. This is ridiculous, I have been robbed and will be posting on other avenues because everyone needs to know not to order from here. There’s no reason to be spending so much money on doll sized portions. Especially since the original store gives much better portions. They need to go ahead an close this branch instead of robbing people of their money to feed them crumbs. 40$!!! Are you kidding me? I’m so upset this is egregious. And on top of that there was no pickles and onions

Haley Brisben

Disgusting, cold, chewy, arrived 2 hours late, bland, McDonald’s level bbq. I recommend any other place but Dickey’s. Some 1 million% better options in Brooklyn are:-Mabel’s BBQ-Fette Sau-Dino BBQAnd Anywhere else possible

Loading...