Edith’s Sandwich Counter

495 Lorimer St, Brooklyn
(929) 387-8280

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

2 Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies
Scottsdale Breakfast Wrap
Fatoush Chicken Schnitzel
The NY Classic Sandwich
Bacon Egg Cheese & Latke
Sephardi Breakfast Wrap
Chicken Schnitzel Club
Pastrami Chopped Cheese
Hand Cut Crispy Fries
Edith's Square Latkes

Menu

Signatures
Iced Cafe Slushie
Our famous drink! Cold brew, tahini, oat milk, and simple syrup combine to make the signature Iced Cafe Slushie.
BEC&L
Our most popular bagel sandwich. Featuring our classic hand-twisted, sourdough bagel loaded up with a freshly shredded and fried latke, Japanese-style egg omelette, Cooper American sharp cheese, and thick, just-crispy bacon. Served with a side of Edith's Special Sauce for dipping.
Pastrami Chopped Cheese
House smoked Pastrami, caramelized onions, Cooper sharp cheese sauce, lettuce and tomato on a garlicky toasted long roll.
Totkes
Our famous square latkes cut down into little bite size tots! (Totkes) they're the perfect crispy fried potato! Contains: flour, onion, and egg.

Bagel Sandwiches
BEC&L
Our most popular bagel sandwich. Featuring our classic hand-twisted, sourdough bagel loaded up with a freshly shredded and fried latke, Japanese-style egg omelette, Cooper American sharp cheese, and thick, just-crispy bacon. Served with a side of Edith's Special Sauce for dipping.
Middle Eastern
Your choice of bagel with omelet style egg, stuffed with farmer's cheese, parsley, zaatar, and shakshuka sauce with scallion aioli spread on the bagel.
NY Classic
Bagel flavor of your choice topped with cream cheese, Sliced Tomato, local hand-sliced salmon, and Amba pickled shallots.
SEC&L
House-made Chicken Sausage, Egg and Cooper Sharp American Cheese with a Latke on your choice of bagel.
PEC&L
House-smoked pastrami, omelet style egg, Cooper Sharp® Cheese, and a latke on a bagel of your choice.
LEO (Lox, Egg & Onion)
LEO (Lox, Egg & Onion) - Omelette Style Egg filled with Edith's House Smoked Salmon, Caramelized Onions and Chives. Served on your choice of bagel with a schmear of cream cheese.
The Californian
Gardinera Tuna Salad, Amba Pickled Shallots, Avocado, & Lettuce. On a Bagel of Your Choice.

Sandwiches
PBB&J
Griddled Challah toast slathered with natural peanut butter, strawberry jam and filled with peanut butter Bamba. Next level PB&J
French Onion Grilled Cheese
Caramelized Onion, Cooper Sharp AND Swiss pressed between two slices of buttery crispy Challah Pullman.
Sephardi Breakfast Wrap
Dairy-Free Malawach stuffed with Alheira chicken sausage, cheesy scrambled eggs, pickled Fresno peppers, herbs, harissa mayo. May be made vegetarian by substituting Avocado in place of the Alheira (patty).
Chicken Schnitzel Club
Chicken Schnitzel, Bacon, shredded lettuce and tomato with Zataar Ranch on griddled Challah bread
The Edith
Our flagship sandwich! House-smoked, hand-sliced pastrami piled high and grilled to order with kraut, Swiss cheese, and Edith's special sauce. Served on grilled rye bread.
A Simple Tuna Melt
Giardiniera tuna salad, swiss cheese and cooper sharp pressed between griddled challah bread.
Smoked Turkey Hoagie
House-smoked turkey rubbed with a shawarma spice blend, topped with harissa mayo, brussel slaw, spicy sweet sandwich pickles, and pickled onions. On a sourdough hoagie roll.
The Mushreuben
Smoked Mushroom version of our signature Edith sandwich. Wild mushrooms rubbed with our pastrami seasoning and smoked until flavorful and tender, served between two slices of griddled rye with kraut, swiss cheese and special sauce.
The Babe
House-smoked turkey, topped with Swiss cheese and Edith's special sauce. Served on freshly grilled rye bread.
Hot Pastrami on Rye
12oz of House smoked Pastrami with Scahller & Weber's® Horseradish Mustard on Thick Cut Rye. Pastrami. Mustard. Rye. That's it. That's the sandwich.
Scottsdale Breakfast Wrap
Cheesy Scrambled Eggs, Avocado, Salsa Verde and a Crispy Latke all inside a Flaky Malawach wrap.

Bagels and Spreads
Choose Your Bagel

Sides
Totkes
Our famous square latkes cut down into little bite size tots! (Totkes) they're the perfect crispy fried potato! Contains: flour, onion, and egg.
Edith's Square Latkes
Latke made fresh daily, house shredded potatoes and lots of love.
Special Sauce, 1oz
Tart, snappy, Edith's special sauce. Good for anything and everything!
Cheesy Totkes
Our famous square latkes cut down into little bite size tots! Covered in our house made Cooper Sharp Aleppo cheese sauce. They're the perfect cheesy, crispy fried potato! Contains: flour, onion, and egg.
Pickle Side - Garlic Spears, 3pc
Smaller side version of our pickle spears.

Chips
Doritos, Hot Battle (gold)
Bamba
Dorito, Spicy Sour (green)
Dorito, BBQ (purple)
Doritos, Hot Battle (silver)
Baby Bamba, (blue)
Cheetos, flamin hot

Sweet Treats & Desserts
Salted Chocolate Chip Cookies
Thin. Crispy. Chewy. Buttery. Salty, sweet and chocolatey. What else does a cookie need to be?
Tahini Blondies
Tahini, White Chocolate, brown butter, black sesame seeds. Ooey-gooey goodness.

Coffee
Iced Cafe Slushie
Our famous drink! Cold brew, tahini, oat milk, and simple syrup combine to make the signature Iced Cafe Slushie.
Cold Brew - 16oz
House cold brew. Strong, rich in chicory and chocolate flavors.
Parlor Drip Coffee - 12oz
Wallabout coffee blend by Parlor. Their flagship blend elevates timeless toffee and chocolate flavors. Current blend is sourced from Colombia and Mexico.

Drinks
Iced Cafe Slushie
Our famous drink! Cold brew, tahini, oat milk, and simple syrup combine to make the signature Iced Cafe Slushie.
Diet Coke Can
Orange Juice 8oz
Coca-Cola Can
Dr. Brown's Black Cherry Soda
Mountain Valley Sparkling Water, 11.3oz
Mango Juice 8oz
Pear Juice 8oz
Coconut Water, 8.75oz
Harmless Harvest Coconut Water
Dr. Brown's Cel-Ray
Dr. Brown's Cream Soda
Saratoga Bottled Water 16oz

Stock Up
Pickle Side - Garlic Spears, 3pc
Smaller side version of our pickle spears.
Garlic Pickle Spears Jar
12oz our house fermented pickled spears. Our take on the classic, a little spicier and briney.
Ketchup.
Pickles - Sweet & Spicy Sandwich, 8oz
Sweet and Spicy pickles for a snack or add-in to your sandwich!
Charred Scallion Cream Cheese, 8oz
8oz container of Charred Scallion cream cheese. Scallions blistered and charred in a broiler and then sliced thin and whipped with local cream cheese.
Cream Cheese Plain, 8oz

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+47 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I liked the filling of the sandwich I got here but it was definitely overpriced for what it was. I ordered a GF bagel because I can't eat wheat and I didn't like the texture of their GF bagels
January 2026
I have not had the chance to try the food yet but I just wanted to say R.I.P Lady Octopus they used to be located their their food is missed very much . But I'm glad Edith's took over the spot the food looks delicious looking forward to try the pastrami chopped cheese ☺️
January 2026
(This review is only about their cookies.)
🍪✨It was two really really thin slices of caramel chocolate chip cookies with a chewy texture. Thinking like a caramel you have to pull but still kinda crumbly a little bit. Super unique and I do recommend cookie lovers to give it a try!
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Campbell and Co - Williamsburg - 502 Lorimer St
Cheese Shops, Grocery, Coffee & Tea, Sandwich Shop
Ren 稔 - 623 Grand St
Chinese, Szechuan
La Taqueria - 572 Grand St
Mexican, Tacos

Edith’s Sandwich Counter

495 Lorimer St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
(929) 387-8280