One of my favorite cookie places! The cookies are large and soft and gooey in the middle with a nice crisp to the edges. The banana pudding is good as well, though the cookies are the best!
New fave cookies in NYC! (and I've done a lot)10/10 for both chocolate chip and peanut butter. Perfectly crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside and not overly sweet.Missed their banana pudding which I definitely will be back for!
marina diforte
Absolutely delicious! We got 4 cookies. All fresh and so yummy. We spoke with the owner for a few minutes and he was so kind. We will be back! Heard great things about the banana pudding but it sells out quick so we’ll have to try again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie H.
A year ago, my husband bought me a cookie from this bakery to cheer me up after a long day, and I thought it was probably the most delicious chocolate chip cookie I had ever had. It was rich, crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, and full of buttery flavor. It tasted like someone had taken a cookie from Levain and made it so much better. I finally came back a year later to buy another cookie there and see if it lived up to the memory. Unfortunately, it tasted like a run-of-the-mill chocolate chip cookie this time, and I can't say whether it's better or worse than Levain. I'm not sure if they changed their recipe or I just came on an off day, but it was merely a good chocolate chip cookie this time. I think I'll come back again to see if it's a pattern and I'll average out my experience with 4 stars.
Jihye Han
Must go this place. Good cookies and good vibe. Recommend especially macha flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maggie B.
Loved these cookies! The cinnamon roll was delicious with a generous dollop of cream cheese frosting in the center. Also enjoyed the chocolate chip, which was crunchy on the outside and gooey on the inside. They do run out of certain flavors in the evening so come early if you are looking for something in particular.
Kim X.
It was a spontaneous decision to get some cookies for our ride out of NYC to upstate. This place came up on my search. Cookies are not as messy as other baked goods, which make for convenient road-trip snacks. I decided to get the 7 cookies for the cost of 6 deal, which ended up being around 18 dollars. Way cheaper than Levain. The cookies were large. I got the walnut, the peanut butter, the oatmeal, the double chocolate and 3 classics. I didn't see any matcha cookies when I went. The service was friendly and efficient. The cookies were put in a very sturdy cute box that said "I got baked cookies. Love at first sight." They were soft and chewy and definitely hit the spot! I think they use brown butter. I prefer mine with a bit more crunch. But I would def be coming by again.
David C.
The cookie was warm and fresh ! And affordable!! I would definitely recommend coming here. They have so many other flavors to try and I have no doubt that they'll be amazing.
Leah
I LOVE this place. Please open one in Manhattan, I would go alllll the time!!
I've tried their walnut chocolate chip, peanut butter chocolate, and matcha cookies. All are delicious but I think the classic chocolate chip walnut reins supreme. Really great mix of crunchy outer shell and soft inside without feeling too underbaked
Joy Whalen
Fantastic little shop -- adore their massive cookies and decadent banana pudding! ?
Annie M.
I've bought these cookies to so many housewarmings, dinner parties, office events, etc and people always LOVE them. The chocolate chip is my go-to but I've had their peanut butter, matcha, and walnut and they were all good. I'm also so glad they extended their M-Th hours to 9 & weekend hours to 10! Food: 10/10 recommend the classic chocolate chip. all their cookies are thick & gooey in the inside Service: everyone I've interacted with here is friendly, cookies are always warm & there are usually more cookies in the back if you're worried their out of a flavor Insider tips: buy 6 get one free, they're also on Too Good to Go! Good for: any event you need to bring a dish to!
Annie Schmaeling
LOVE these gooey cookies!! I’ve tried the chocolate chip, double chocolate and peanut butter flavors, and they’re all delicious. Excited to try the rest of the menu!
Supriya K.
Came here a half hour before closing and snagged their matcha cookie, banana pudding, and unsweetened iced tea. Unsweetened iced tea - Pretty standard but in a way that hits the spot! Matcha cookie - I wish the matcha flavor was stronger but the white chocolate bits were heavenly. I love that their cookies are softer in the middle. They remind me of Levain's but they're not as decadent or crisp on the outside. I thoroughly enjoyed it for the texture. Banana pudding - fresh! Quite a strong banana flavor but still made for a delicious pudding. Very indulgent. There's maybe two seats in the establishment and the interiors are quite bare boned.
Awesome cookies!?
One of my favorite cookie places! The cookies are large and soft and gooey in the middle with a nice crisp to the edges. The banana pudding is good as well, though the cookies are the best!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Matcha Double Nuts, Classic Chocolate Chips Red Velvet, Chocolate Walnut, Classic Chocolate Chips, Banana Pudding
New fave cookies in NYC! (and I've done a lot)10/10 for both chocolate chip and peanut butter. Perfectly crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside and not overly sweet.Missed their banana pudding which I definitely will be back for!
Absolutely delicious! We got 4 cookies. All fresh and so yummy. We spoke with the owner for a few minutes and he was so kind. We will be back! Heard great things about the banana pudding but it sells out quick so we’ll have to try again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A year ago, my husband bought me a cookie from this bakery to cheer me up after a long day, and I thought it was probably the most delicious chocolate chip cookie I had ever had. It was rich, crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, and full of buttery flavor. It tasted like someone had taken a cookie from Levain and made it so much better. I finally came back a year later to buy another cookie there and see if it lived up to the memory. Unfortunately, it tasted like a run-of-the-mill chocolate chip cookie this time, and I can't say whether it's better or worse than Levain. I'm not sure if they changed their recipe or I just came on an off day, but it was merely a good chocolate chip cookie this time. I think I'll come back again to see if it's a pattern and I'll average out my experience with 4 stars.
Must go this place. Good cookies and good vibe. Recommend especially macha flavor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved these cookies! The cinnamon roll was delicious with a generous dollop of cream cheese frosting in the center. Also enjoyed the chocolate chip, which was crunchy on the outside and gooey on the inside. They do run out of certain flavors in the evening so come early if you are looking for something in particular.
It was a spontaneous decision to get some cookies for our ride out of NYC to upstate. This place came up on my search. Cookies are not as messy as other baked goods, which make for convenient road-trip snacks. I decided to get the 7 cookies for the cost of 6 deal, which ended up being around 18 dollars. Way cheaper than Levain. The cookies were large. I got the walnut, the peanut butter, the oatmeal, the double chocolate and 3 classics. I didn't see any matcha cookies when I went. The service was friendly and efficient. The cookies were put in a very sturdy cute box that said "I got baked cookies. Love at first sight." They were soft and chewy and definitely hit the spot! I think they use brown butter. I prefer mine with a bit more crunch. But I would def be coming by again.
The cookie was warm and fresh ! And affordable!! I would definitely recommend coming here. They have so many other flavors to try and I have no doubt that they'll be amazing.
I LOVE this place. Please open one in Manhattan, I would go alllll the time!!
Restaurantji Recommends
I've tried their walnut chocolate chip, peanut butter chocolate, and matcha cookies. All are delicious but I think the classic chocolate chip walnut reins supreme. Really great mix of crunchy outer shell and soft inside without feeling too underbaked
Fantastic little shop -- adore their massive cookies and decadent banana pudding! ?
I've bought these cookies to so many housewarmings, dinner parties, office events, etc and people always LOVE them. The chocolate chip is my go-to but I've had their peanut butter, matcha, and walnut and they were all good. I'm also so glad they extended their M-Th hours to 9 & weekend hours to 10! Food: 10/10 recommend the classic chocolate chip. all their cookies are thick & gooey in the inside Service: everyone I've interacted with here is friendly, cookies are always warm & there are usually more cookies in the back if you're worried their out of a flavor Insider tips: buy 6 get one free, they're also on Too Good to Go! Good for: any event you need to bring a dish to!
LOVE these gooey cookies!! I’ve tried the chocolate chip, double chocolate and peanut butter flavors, and they’re all delicious. Excited to try the rest of the menu!
Came here a half hour before closing and snagged their matcha cookie, banana pudding, and unsweetened iced tea. Unsweetened iced tea - Pretty standard but in a way that hits the spot! Matcha cookie - I wish the matcha flavor was stronger but the white chocolate bits were heavenly. I love that their cookies are softer in the middle. They remind me of Levain's but they're not as decadent or crisp on the outside. I thoroughly enjoyed it for the texture. Banana pudding - fresh! Quite a strong banana flavor but still made for a delicious pudding. Very indulgent. There's maybe two seats in the establishment and the interiors are quite bare boned.