Emmy Squared Pizza: Williamsburg, Brooklyn

The gluten free pizza was just dough, tasted uncooked. Maybe the recipe changed or I got a bad batch?

Food: 1

Service: 5

Please train your staff to treat people with respect regardless of who they are. Some of the staff members are very disrespectful to delivery drivers for no reason. We are all just trying to do our jobs. Thanks

It might have been an off night but the service was pretty slow. Food was good but nothing to make me want to come back. Just seemed like an average sports bar atmosphere with TVs on the wall. I was expecting more

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

In what world is this a salad that serves 2-3 people? The dressing is fishy to the point of being inedible. I ordered delivery so I can’t speak to the service / atmosphere but I’m beyond disappointed in what I received.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Service was great though the food is really bad. The kale salad was very bad and the pizza was greasy and disgusting.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

We get the gluten-free pizza from Emmy Squared for takeaway, and it’s absolutely delicious! The crust is perfectly crispy, and the flavors are spot on every time. Definitely a go-to for a tasty, reliable gluten-free option.

Food: 4

Had a lovely brunch with a friend and the staff was so kind! I noted our dietary restrictions (celiac) in advance and they were so prepared to let us know immediately the gluten free pizza crust and salads on the menu were save for us! They were so hospitable and the food at Emmy Squared is always great so overall a fab visit!

We loved the sweet man who was running the entire front of house while we were there. I didn't catch his name but he made me feel super special on my birthday!

I really love Emmy and order here all the time but the quality control on delivery has gone down a lot lately. I always get the Colony but lately there’s been little to no honey, the jalapeños are often burnt, and I’ve gotten several pies in a row where there’s basically no cheese on top at all, just sauce. I don’t mind paying high prices for delicious pizza but I’m annoyed at how regular this is getting now. Please work on quality control!!!

We ordered well over $2,000 of food from here for 2yrs and when we ordered one night they sent us random ice cold pizza and didn’t send any of the sides we ordered, instead they literally sent 3 boxes of raw broccoli which made absolutely no sense. I tried to contact them and complain and they ignored. I have not ordered from them since but am shocked at the fact that they would do that and not take responsibility. I was never even compensated for that but I want everyone to know that this business did this to people who were long time customers. Horrible.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Love the pizza here, but service here was really poor. They messed up the order (we didn’t get the sesame crust, even tho we ordered it), and the person running the place got really defensive, basically denied they made a mistake, and when she realized she was wrong said, “there’s nothing we can do.” Usually when places make a mistake, they offer some kind of discount, or some form apology, but instead we got a bunch of attitude for pointing out they messed up. Ruined the experience for us.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 1

Burger was delicious as per usual, we also really liked the Brussel sprouts.

The Hawaiian pizza and the gourda pizza (limited seasonal) were good but the middle felt a little under cooked. We’ve never noticed this at other locations. Wouldn’t recommend pizzas with huge chunks of cheese though because that makes the dough soggy.

Recommended dishes: Le Big Matt Burger

We had a lovely visit to Emmy Squared's Williamsburg location. The food and drinks were wonderful, as always, but the service stood out on this particular visit! Many thanks!

No good

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

The hype is very overrated. Small portions of food, basic and nothing special. Would never order again

Food: 2

Service: 2