This restaurant is a magical place. The food the staff, the ambiance and the food (yeup repeating that) is incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emil
Private party. The staff were limited and did not fulfill the drink orders. Had to ask multiple times. Food was ok, under seasoned. Its Xmas time, yet NO decorations in the private room, NOT ONE!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
D G
Gargiulos is not the same. Meals are below average and price is very expensive. Started with calamari which came out cold and definetly not fresh with no taste at all. Main xourse was stuffed shrimp for $44 which consited of only 4 small shrimps which were overbreaded and tasted horrible served with absolutely nothing was horrible. Finished with tiramusu dessert which had to taste and preaentation was zero. This meal alone with two glasses of wine was over $180.I dont mind paying high prices for a good meal but this meal was below average and not worth the price. You will get a better meal elsewhere. Will definetly not be coming back. Save your money.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Danny Rivera
Fantastic food, great service and a really Italian restaurant with home cooked meals.
Sheila Boone
First I like would like to thank This fine establishment for giving a wonderful Thanksgiving free dinner to the community Inside was beautiful and spacious Kindness was being served 🫶🏿 to top it all off the food was delicious I love Italian and when I do come back I want to be dressed up and try their food ; With rising costs with everything rent etc This establishment did a kind and generous service all with kindness and a smile Just wanted to give a generous Thank you !!
Ronnie Levine
Chicken Scarpariello, Veal chop, Pork chop, baked clams and mussels in red sauce were all delicious. Tiramisu for dessert was yummy. All three of us enjoyed our meal as well as the cocktails and wine. Service was attentive and impeccable. It's a great old place; very classy. I recommend it highly. There is a dress code so if you go to Coney Island beach make sure you have change of clothes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee
My experience at this restaurant has been neutral I can't say that it's great and rave about it like these other five-star reviews because that was not my experience to me the food was mediocre and nothing special. I would not go back for a second time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Douglas Considine
It's been way too long since my last visit to Gargiulo's. It was even better than I had remembered. We'll worth the trip, you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carlos
Loved the staff food and drinks the place was so fancy and beautiful 10/10 will come back again
Delicious food here. The food quality is top notch and service is great. The staff were so friendly. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jo Ann
My family has been coming here for years. There's nothing else like it. Never disappoints.
Kathy Barzal Real Estate
Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richie Giordano
This was my first visit, for a fraternal function. I've had better food, but it was enjoyable. The drinks were strong, but I wasn't driving so I'm not worried. The venue was beautiful, and the staff are friendly and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Maria
I've just returned to Brooklyn after 22 years in Queens. Finding places that feel like home has been a challenge. Gargiulos is that place I've been looking for almost a year to find. We arrived early on Friday night to celebrate a belated birthday and it couldn't have been more perfect. Blue cheese stuffed olives for my dirty martini, white bean and escarole soup with linguini in garlic and oil. It was perfection. My love ordered the pasta e fagiole and osso buco and was beyond happy. Both of us are cooks and it's hard to find a place where they make linguini in garlic and oil better or just as good as we can. Gargiulos nailed it! Light and just the right amount of garlic. I'm so happy to write a positive review but more so to have found a little bit of home in Brooklyn. Thank you for making my special birthday dinner so much more!
Company xmas dinner, food was exquisite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This restaurant is a magical place. The food the staff, the ambiance and the food (yeup repeating that) is incredible.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Private party. The staff were limited and did not fulfill the drink orders. Had to ask multiple times. Food was ok, under seasoned. Its Xmas time, yet NO decorations in the private room, NOT ONE!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Gargiulos is not the same. Meals are below average and price is very expensive. Started with calamari which came out cold and definetly not fresh with no taste at all. Main xourse was stuffed shrimp for $44 which consited of only 4 small shrimps which were overbreaded and tasted horrible served with absolutely nothing was horrible. Finished with tiramusu dessert which had to taste and preaentation was zero. This meal alone with two glasses of wine was over $180.I dont mind paying high prices for a good meal but this meal was below average and not worth the price. You will get a better meal elsewhere. Will definetly not be coming back. Save your money.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Fantastic food, great service and a really Italian restaurant with home cooked meals.
First I like would like to thank This fine establishment for giving a wonderful Thanksgiving free dinner to the community Inside was beautiful and spacious Kindness was being served 🫶🏿 to top it all off the food was delicious I love Italian and when I do come back I want to be dressed up and try their food ; With rising costs with everything rent etc This establishment did a kind and generous service all with kindness and a smile Just wanted to give a generous Thank you !!
Chicken Scarpariello, Veal chop,
Pork chop, baked clams and mussels in red sauce were all delicious. Tiramisu for dessert was yummy.
All three of us enjoyed our meal as well as the cocktails and wine. Service was attentive and impeccable. It's a great old place; very classy. I recommend it highly.
There is a dress code so if you go to Coney Island beach make sure you have change of clothes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My experience at this restaurant has been neutral I can't say that it's great and rave about it like these other five-star reviews because that was not my experience to me the food was mediocre and nothing special. I would not go back for a second time.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
It's been way too long since my last visit to Gargiulo's. It was even better than I had remembered. We'll worth the trip, you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loved the staff food and drinks the place was so fancy and beautiful 10/10 will come back again
Restaurantji Recommends
Delicious food here. The food quality is top notch and service is great. The staff were so friendly. Highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family has been coming here for years. There's nothing else like it. Never disappoints.
Delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my first visit, for a fraternal function. I've had better food, but it was enjoyable. The drinks were strong, but I wasn't driving so I'm not worried. The venue was beautiful, and the staff are friendly and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I've just returned to Brooklyn after 22 years in Queens. Finding places that feel like home has been a challenge. Gargiulos is that place I've been looking for almost a year to find. We arrived early on Friday night to celebrate a belated birthday and it couldn't have been more perfect. Blue cheese stuffed olives for my dirty martini, white bean and escarole soup with linguini in garlic and oil. It was perfection. My love ordered the pasta e fagiole and osso buco and was beyond happy. Both of us are cooks and it's hard to find a place where they make linguini in garlic and oil better or just as good as we can. Gargiulos nailed it! Light and just the right amount of garlic. I'm so happy to write a positive review but more so to have found a little bit of home in Brooklyn. Thank you for making my special birthday dinner so much more!
Loading...