Our favorite Italian restaurant. The service is impeccable, the vibe very friendly, the room beautiful, and the food....well thats what keeps us coming back.
James
Excellent service and good as usual. Very accommodating and attentive staff. Go, you will love!
Larry
Went to Gargiulo's on Saturday night 06/14. Was running a little late but no problem table was ready upon arrival. The service was outstanding and the food was just as good. A very pleasant experience. Never felt rushed and a very nice atmosphere. Will be going again soon.
Barbara
We celebrated my daughter's graduation for her Masters. The food was delicious. Our server Emilio was fantastic. He was very attentive and pleasant. The restaurant was crowded but we still received excellent service and we were not rushed. I would definitely go back. I would recommend Gargiulo's Restaurant for anyone seeking delicious food, great service, and the feeling of home.
david
My wife and I always look forward to dining at Gargiulo's. The food never disappoints. My wife had Chicken Luigi and I had Chicken Tomasso.. Both dishes were outstanding. The desserts are also delicious.Our favorite is Tartufo. The wine list is reasonably priced, and the house wine is good also. I'd like to thank our server, Saad, who provided excellent service. He was very courteous and helpful with the menu. This restaurant is family owned and someone from the family is always on hand to welcome you. We have frequented this restaurant for years. It has always been one of our favorites. We highly recommend Gargiulo's.
susan
Always a great meal at Gargulios Great food Great service Always treated as a valued guest Keep coming back!
Darlene
It did take about 10 minutes for someone to help us check in and be seated. Took about 1/2 hour to get service. It was extremely busy and very noisy. Waiter was very good when he was able to give us service. There was some kind of party with band going on in big room made it hard to hear. Waiter was great when he was able to attend to myself and daughter. Food was very good.
Paul
Service could have been more hsnds on Prices went up but they took half portions away Still can't believe if you want to substitute pasta for the vegetables, you get charged Needless to say been going here for years and I'm disappointed.
Rose
We were celebrating my mother's birthday and all the holidays we missed with her because she was in and out of the hospital since October, 2024. Just walking in, mom felt like royalty, the owners and wait staff all came over to hug and kiss her. It was a lovely afternoon with mom and my brother and his family to celebrate my mom's birthday and missed holidays. Jerry was our waiter and he was very attentive to all of our needs. And even remembered to order mom's special pasta to take home to eat on another day.
JamesC
One of the best restaurants in NYC. The food is spectacular and the service is beyond compare!
Food is good but does not live up to the expectations. It's very expensive for average food. It felt like touristy prices.
Tony Zahn
My first time back since I was a kid in 1978. It’s still fabulous. My grandmother lived across the street as a teenager. So many memories celebrating there. Order the clams, you will not be disappointed. Classic, traditional Italian dishes done simply elegantly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Clams
John J Colomara
Never disappoints...Chicken Franchise, n baked clams appetizer..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Francesco Salvatore
In the semi deserts Coney Island we found this restaurant by chance. Already from afar it seemed to be one of the few decent ones in the area. It turned out to be a pleasant surprise both for the location, beautiful and very well furnished for Christmas, and for the food. Delicious bread and oil, better than many Italian restaurants in Italy, very tasty risotto and quality fish. Very kind and friendly owners, with Italian origins. I highly recommend you go there and above all end the meal with the magical Tiramisu! Great guys, nice work!!
Our favorite Italian restaurant. The service is impeccable, the vibe very friendly, the room beautiful, and the food....well thats what keeps us coming back.
Excellent service and good as usual. Very accommodating and attentive staff. Go, you will love!
Went to Gargiulo's on Saturday night 06/14. Was running a little late but no problem table was ready upon arrival. The service was outstanding and the food was just as good. A very pleasant experience. Never felt rushed and a very nice atmosphere. Will be going again soon.
We celebrated my daughter's graduation for her Masters. The food was delicious. Our server Emilio was fantastic. He was very attentive and pleasant. The restaurant was crowded but we still received excellent service and we were not rushed. I would definitely go back. I would recommend Gargiulo's Restaurant for anyone seeking delicious food, great service, and the feeling of home.
My wife and I always look forward to dining at Gargiulo's. The food never disappoints. My wife had Chicken Luigi and I had Chicken Tomasso.. Both dishes were outstanding. The desserts are also delicious.Our favorite is Tartufo. The wine list is reasonably priced, and the house wine is good also. I'd like to thank our server, Saad, who provided excellent service. He was very courteous and helpful with the menu. This restaurant is family owned and someone from the family is always on hand to welcome you. We have frequented this restaurant for years. It has always been one of our favorites. We highly recommend Gargiulo's.
Always a great meal at Gargulios Great food Great service Always treated as a valued guest Keep coming back!
It did take about 10 minutes for someone to help us check in and be seated. Took about 1/2 hour to get service. It was extremely busy and very noisy. Waiter was very good when he was able to give us service. There was some kind of party with band going on in big room made it hard to hear. Waiter was great when he was able to attend to myself and daughter. Food was very good.
Service could have been more hsnds on Prices went up but they took half portions away Still can't believe if you want to substitute pasta for the vegetables, you get charged Needless to say been going here for years and I'm disappointed.
We were celebrating my mother's birthday and all the holidays we missed with her because she was in and out of the hospital since October, 2024. Just walking in, mom felt like royalty, the owners and wait staff all came over to hug and kiss her. It was a lovely afternoon with mom and my brother and his family to celebrate my mom's birthday and missed holidays. Jerry was our waiter and he was very attentive to all of our needs. And even remembered to order mom's special pasta to take home to eat on another day.
One of the best restaurants in NYC. The food is spectacular and the service is beyond compare!
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is good but does not live up to the expectations. It's very expensive for average food. It felt like touristy prices.
My first time back since I was a kid in 1978. It’s still fabulous. My grandmother lived across the street as a teenager. So many memories celebrating there. Order the clams, you will not be disappointed. Classic, traditional Italian dishes done simply elegantly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Baked Clams
Never disappoints...Chicken Franchise, n baked clams appetizer..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
In the semi deserts Coney Island we found this restaurant by chance.
Already from afar it seemed to be one of the few decent ones in the area.
It turned out to be a pleasant surprise both for the location, beautiful and very well furnished for Christmas, and for the food. Delicious bread and oil, better than many Italian restaurants in Italy, very tasty risotto and quality fish. Very kind and friendly owners, with Italian origins. I highly recommend you go there and above all end the meal with the magical Tiramisu!
Great guys, nice work!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great old school Italian restaurant
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...