Gold Star Beer Counter

176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 955-5031

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Beth

i’ve never purchased anything here but they let me pee once so i love them forever. nice clean bathroom.

Ciara Colon

Came by about a week ago and it was such a nice experience. The bartender was really friendly offered great beer suggestions. Will definitely come back

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Vishal Vaidya

Best mood best beers best bites, bit of a strollertown sometimes but what can you do

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lauren M

I hate to one star a business but I have to say this was the worst cold brew I have ever had

Nathan Yengel

Gold Star Beer Counter nails what most places miss. The music is local and right — unexpectedly amazing — like someone actually thought about it instead of hitting play on some corporate streaming service. You can feel it’s picked by the same personalities you see at the bar, not a marketing team in another time zone. The vibe is warm, unforced, and human. No branding exercise, no playlist ‘strategy,’ just a room that knows exactly who it is and lets you enjoy it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Garza

The bar keep was friendly and knowledgeable. The atmosphere is chill with good music. The beer is always great there.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Andres Lopez-Ovejero

I'm very picky about beer and I love this place. They have a rotating list of taps, the friendly staff will let you taste a draft before you buy. The printed beer list has descriptions. I love that they have foreign as well as domestic beers, especially Belgian and German beers. The list is mostly American Craft but there are always 2 or more imports. They take chances too with smoked beers and barrel aged. While other places may serve only IPAs and sours, you can get those at Gold Star but also a Fantome! The outdoor beer window that sells 32 and 64 oz growlers is great too, you can.pick up a growler while walking your dog.

There are a couple of sandwiches on the menu, both delicious. They are always nice.

I have never purchased cans or bottles here either to stay or go. I would be careful about buying cans and bottles here. I see them displayed warm and that's not good for most beer. Maybe check and see if hey also have cold beer for sale. Perhaps the ones left out are only for display. That would make sense since  this is an excellent beer bar.

The interior is pretty as well, it would be a good place to impress someone who likes decor. There is a lot of wood but it's still light and airy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 4

Charles Veilleux

This was such a great bar, beautiful inside with a great selection of beers. Highly recommend even for visitors.

Christian Lawson

Great spot, best decaf IPA I've ever had while I was working. The meat and cheese are also spot on!

Alex Serebrov

This is a very cool beer joint with large and interesting selection of beers. The place not your average beer bar, but rather a Starbucks that serves beer instead of coffee. This cool place to socialize and even to work. I gave 3 stars just because they serve good sandwiches, but not omg, but again it is just an option to have with an excellent beer.
The place is next to the local celebrity- Radio bakery, so if not in the mood to stay in a long line, or they run of their goodies, this place is a great substitution

John Lightfoot

This place is so great. I didn't get the full vibe from their website, but it's like a super gastro-pub/winebar-ish beer bar (#beeristhenewwine?) with a spectacular selection on tap. They even have that crazy side pull Czech tap for their Pilsners. I know, opinions and a-holes and all, but maybe a hand-pumped cask ale?

Charlotte K

Great selection of beers and fun vibes

pranav jain

Great place to grab a beer, amazing service

Rachel T

Such a great spot in Prospect Heights! Really friendly service with a consistently great beer selection. I also love that you can get cheese and charcuterie plates

Lucia Ryan

one of the best bars in the neighborhood. comfortable, well-designed, and warm, with a great beer selection!

Loading...