Gold Star Beer Counter

176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 955-5031

Recent Reviews

Albert Le

Beer good vibe good

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Craft Beer

Ina Li

Cozy beer parlor on a quiet street corner with rotating taps of beer, sours, and ciders, delicious snacks and sandwiches, and friendly service. Summertime here is magical with cold beer and outdoor seatings. Great ambiance and perfect for chill hangouts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carolyn Gearig

I love this place so much ?? great pours, really friendly bartenders, perfect ambience & they play the best vinyl

Olivia N

Overall rating: 4.8Super cute spot near the Brooklyn museum. I already knew it was going to be a great place just by the other reviews, but I wasn’t sure if it was going to be snooty or anything. Super chill, but very popular! My friend and I got lucky and got seats at the bar, but I could totally come here solo which is why I like it a lot!Beer is crafted and good. It’s a tad bit bright but looks like people come to work, read a book or hang. The staff was really nice and I like how simple the menu is. I don’t think I’d eat any snacks here, but I can try it out when I come back.Such a good find & highly reco!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Olivia N.

Overall rating: 4.8 Super cute spot near the Brooklyn museum. I already knew it was going to be a great place just by the other reviews, but I wasn't sure if it was going to be snooty or anything. Super chill, but very popular! My friend and I got lucky and got seats at the bar, but I could totally come here solo which is why I like it a lot! Beer is crafted and good. It's a tad bit bright but looks like people come to work, read a book or hang. The staff was really nice and I like how simple the menu is. I don't think I'd eat any snacks here, but I can try it out when I come back. Such a good find & highly reco!

Iso Kate

A short macho-presenting bartender just yelled in my face when I went to the window to enquire what cider he recommend me last time. “How should I know what you ordered last time!?” came off super rude and made me want to just walk off. I gave 3 stars since the first time I went there with a friend was all right, mostly because my buddy was there, the cider was crisp, and inside there was comfortable lighting. I will avoid even passing by this dive in the future.If he had allowed me to describe the label/flavor and that it came in a wine bottle before speaking to me harshly & rushing off to go back to the other bar guests, maybe we could have come to an answer. I’ll go try to find it at a wine shop and invite friends to my place where I can create a better atmosphere.As if I didn’t need another reason to move out of this pitiful neighborhood, now I have another one. Most people in Prospect Heights/Park Slope are the sort of miserable upper-middle-class that’ll leave you drained of enthusiasm for life if you stay too long. I see why a bartenders here would be snobby as well, considering the surrounding Zeitgeist.

Atmosphere: 3

Service: 2

Alice Q. Hoang

Family friendly (thanks Brooklyn bar culture). Surprisingly nom foods (even the vegan options, and I am mostly carnivore). The best staff. I generally go weekly bc they are on my way home from work and it's been consistently exceptional.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Oliver C.

One of my favorites. Terrific local ambiance with cozy outdoor seating and a warm, cheerful indoor section. Bar tenders are really friendly. Beer is terrific, as are the meat & cheese plates. Love it here

Rebecca Parker

Incredible beer list. Crowlers to go. Simple food but super tasty, I have loved the olives beer cheese and sandwiches I’ve tried. I love during nice weather brining my dog here and enjoying a beer outside. They give him a treat at the window and now he’s obsessed with coming here. My husband is a beer snob and they always have something that excites him. They spin vinyl inside. The staff is super nice & not snooty but approachable.I learned they do coffee and pastry’s in the morning and now I’ve been going for coffee on my morning dog walk which I is so nice bc now I have a destination.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Saul Kaiserman

Insanely good beers at bar or pickup window, draft or in cans, indoor and outdoor seating. This is what Brooklyn is all about.

Sanjay Ginde

Great, rotating selection beers with excellent bartenders.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Tim Fish

This is the exact type of vibe I look for in a beer bar! Bartender was super chill & knew his stuff. Draft selection isnt huge but still really good but their can and bottle selection is pretty stellar. Will definitely be going back anytime im in the area!

Abu Taher

Best neighborhood spot in all of Prospect Heights. Staff is personable, efficient, and have great music taste as they put on perfect to the mood records. Foods solid to go with the beer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rust Man

Great craft beer spot. On tap and Togo.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Russell Bateman-Buckley

Great rotation of beer selection from $8-12 for a pour. Cans for here or to go. Lovely shaded outdoor seating which gets packed during happy hour. Baby/stroller central at times, which can be a pro or a con depending on your life stage. Food available if you have too many and don't want to leave.Kid-friendliness: Stroller parking outside. Very tolerant of kids at the outdoor seating.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Load More