I was expecting much more based on the online buzz. Unfortunately, the bagels are not baked fresh on site, and the lack of freshness is noticeable.The texture and flavor are nowhere near what you get from shops that boil and bake their bagels daily.There is a lot of social media attention here, but the product itself feels average at best.If quality and freshness matter to you, I would recommend going to a shop that actually bakes in house.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Patrick Murphy
Good breakfast sandwiches and very friendly service
Mark P
Wow this place has gone downhill. Used to be my favorite spot in BK. $19 for bagel + whitefish + cc + tomato….and there was barely any whitefish.
Daniel Lutsker
Delicious but crazy wait times, always out of inventory
Erick Perez
The Worst Bagels in NYC
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ted Cadieu
I had to be in neighborhood this person recommended to try there bagels. I was there at 12,:30 its just store frount place but ok. I order a dozen eat in my car as I heading back to jersey. They didn't taste fresh from the morning. But tasted like the day before very disappointing. They tasted after I tasted ok but dame. I was hoping to stumble some good treat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
wallace dos santos
Easily, one of my favorite bagels in Brooklyn, and I’m a native New Yorker ‼️ the texture, the cream cheese, the quality is just perfection.
Such a great selection of specialty bagel orders that do not miss!! As well as the regular bagel orders being a great staple!
Seriously, love this place. Have been coming here for years, and still love to come back whenever I’m nearby or order. Well worth the wait to get your bagel 🥲
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ankit Sharma
wrong order again
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jean M
Really convenient spot to order ahead on my way out and I pick up along my route. Nothing life changing and honestly I need to find a life changing bagel rn but this one is a reliable option on the journey to the life changing bagel wish there was a table or two to sit at, usually there’s just a lot of people waiting out front so I don’t hang around to eat
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
S F
the quality of the bagels does not justify the expensive price
$7.50 for a bagel with cream cheese is crazy. Not worth it.
I went months ago and I’m still annoyed at how much I paid for it.
James
Asked for a everything bagel and got a sesame seed bagel. Cashier stapled the bag so i wouldn’t see till i got home. Horrible business practice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jeremy L
Greenberg’s service is terrible. The bagels are overpriced, take too long to prepare, and aren’t particularly good
Jacob Frank-Brown
Excellent & classic NYC bagels. Ordered via GrubHub and order came to my door, hot and fresh, in less than 30 mins. Haven’t been in store, so can’t speak to complaints about in-store service during busy times, but I ordered at 10:30am Sunday morning (bagel rush hour) and couldn’t be more satisfied with the service and quality. Turkey bacon was delicious and actually crispy and my girlfriend got a healthy amount of avocado on her AEC bagel. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!!
I was expecting much more based on the online buzz. Unfortunately, the bagels are not baked fresh on site, and the lack of freshness is noticeable.The texture and flavor are nowhere near what you get from shops that boil and bake their bagels daily.There is a lot of social media attention here, but the product itself feels average at best.If quality and freshness matter to you, I would recommend going to a shop that actually bakes in house.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good breakfast sandwiches and very friendly service
Wow this place has gone downhill. Used to be my favorite spot in BK. $19 for bagel + whitefish + cc + tomato….and there was barely any whitefish.
Delicious but crazy wait times, always out of inventory
The Worst Bagels in NYC
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I had to be in neighborhood this person recommended to try there bagels. I was there at 12,:30 its just store frount place but ok. I order a dozen eat in my car as I heading back to jersey. They didn't taste fresh from the morning. But tasted like the day before very disappointing. They tasted after I tasted ok but dame. I was hoping to stumble some good treat.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Easily, one of my favorite bagels in Brooklyn, and I’m a native New Yorker ‼️ the texture, the cream cheese, the quality is just perfection.
Such a great selection of specialty bagel orders that do not miss!! As well as the regular bagel orders being a great staple!
Seriously, love this place. Have been coming here for years, and still love to come back whenever I’m nearby or order. Well worth the wait to get your bagel 🥲
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
wrong order again
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Really convenient spot to order ahead on my way out and I pick up along my route. Nothing life changing and honestly I need to find a life changing bagel rn but this one is a reliable option on the journey to the life changing bagel wish there was a table or two to sit at, usually there’s just a lot of people waiting out front so I don’t hang around to eat
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
the quality of the bagels does not justify the expensive price
Restaurantji Recommends
$7.50 for a bagel with cream cheese is crazy. Not worth it.
I went months ago and I’m still annoyed at how much I paid for it.
Asked for a everything bagel and got a sesame seed bagel. Cashier stapled the bag so i wouldn’t see till i got home. Horrible business practice.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Greenberg’s service is terrible. The bagels are overpriced, take too long to prepare, and aren’t particularly good
Excellent & classic NYC bagels. Ordered via GrubHub and order came to my door, hot and fresh, in less than 30 mins. Haven’t been in store, so can’t speak to complaints about in-store service during busy times, but I ordered at 10:30am Sunday morning (bagel rush hour) and couldn’t be more satisfied with the service and quality. Turkey bacon was delicious and actually crispy and my girlfriend got a healthy amount of avocado on her AEC bagel. Highly recommend and we will definitely be back!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
My neighborhood go-to
Loading...