Jimmy's Pizza

561 Wilson Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 455-3237

Recent Reviews

Katherine P.

The food and prices here are amazing, Recommend 100%. This pizzeria been here for years.

Alessandro Motta

Grandma slice is incredible. Must try. Tasty, perfectly seasoned, very crunchy. Not doughy or greasy at all. 10/10

Kevin D.

This has been in my rotation for pizza in my neighborhood in Bushwick near Irving Square Park. In a world of gourmet pizza, sometimes you want to go back to basics and have normal NY style pizza. This place nails it.

Lance Goodwin

Been a neighborhood staple since I was a teen. Food has always been great and the prices are very good for a long standing establishment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Andrew W.

Food arrived very late even though they are only a few blocks away. The driver called and refused to deliver to our door despite there being an elevator. He cursed at me multiple times and said he couldn't come up because he had "mad orders bro". The regular pizza is pretty good but the grandma pie is barely more than crust, cheese, and some tomatoes on top.

Kelsie M.

Great local pizza shop that delivers and never fails to please! I love jimmy's and have been going there since 2018. Their pizza is affordable. They deliver with no delivery fees. Their service is great. And the ambience inside is what you would expect from a local pizza spot. Worth a go.

Shihan Darrell McKinney

Fast and easy delivery service and I didn't have to wait long for my pizza to get to my home. Food is excellent in all manner!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shanice G.

Disappointing customer service. I ordered my food, patiently waiting 10 minutes for a fresh pie to come out . The pie comes out and in comes a new customer for them. They truly served her food before serving me. The ambiance of this place was a total shock to me. Lesson learned.

Bryan Mentore

I got the chicken Alfredo pasta, a pepperoni pizza slice, garlic knots and pepperoni pinwheels with a 2ltr soda. I think my favorite was the pepperoni pinwheels but everything was really flavorful and tasty. I definitely highly recommend their garlic knots too. I will be ordering from here again!

Food: 4

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks

star dionne (badgurlbeauty)

I came here Tuesday night right before closing. I ordered a slice . The guy at the counter was trying to get everyone’s payment for their food. I didn’t like the atmosphere. Anyhow the slice was mediocre and it made me throw up. I got sick in the middle of the night. I don’t trust that place. The cashier was taking orders and holding money dirty hands pizza place who knows if they wash their hands when cooking. Blah never again

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

donavan denny

Good food.especialy the nice hot pizza ?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

ajibola elizabeth

I love the grape nut ice

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole

Delicious. Chewy crust the way I like

Gary Wilson

Medium-thick crust slice for $3.Soft chewy crust.Undercooked overall.Sauce has good taste, but slice is killed by the undercooked cheese.Skimps on overall coverage.Would be much better well cooked with a crisp crust.I'll give this one an 80.

Prettyboy Mikey

What type of poor excuse is this even Domino’s Pizza Hut? Get this correct? Why is it red sauce on my barbecue chicken pie? Why is it red sauce on my buffalo chicken pie? It’s just a cheese pie with barbecue sauce on it and chicken buffalo sauce on it. What I order wht I got the sad thing is when my wife put it, describe how a buffalo pizza is built. He said to her that she didn’t ask him to do that to the pizza. But it’s only one way to make a buffalo pizza or a barbecue pizza dough sauce, cheese, and chicken not red sauce

Load More