Hidden behind a bodega's freezer door, La Milagrosa in Williamsburg is a small-scale miracle for mezcal lovers. This speakeasy isn't about glitz, it’s about good taste and great ambiance. The space is wonderfully intimate, decked out in warm wood and the soft glow of a disco ball and Virgin of Guadalupe candles, creating a vibe that is simultaneously cool, cozy, and transcendent. While the ambiente is top-tier, the Guayaba Mezcal Margarita is the true star. It’s easily a top-five cocktail in the neighborhood, perfectly balancing the smoky complexity of high-quality mezcal with the lush, tropical sweetness of guava. It’s an innovative drink that never sacrifices the spirit’s integrity. Paired with the curated vinyl soundtrack—a mix of old-school funk and global grooves—it’s the perfect elixir for a night of low-key revelry. La Milagrosa is a must-visit for anyone seeking small, good vibes and a truly exceptional agave cocktail.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Asha Pereira
super rude male bartender - as we were counting cash for tip ~1 min after we paid, he said “the tip is not included in the price. 20% is acceptable”. Also menu linked here on Google is incorrect FYI drinks are much more expensive + drinks were not strong at all + it was absolutely empty at 10pm on a Saturday. avoid!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
H. Jules
Great sound system. Proper drinks, if Mescal and tequila are your jam- that is way to go. I always went next store for food, as well as Superio, and decided to pop in. Turns out its cool lol. No real surprise. Just know it will be packed and there will be people from other parts of the world at times, which I think is a plus. If younare a person who doesn't like mingling and getting to know others, go somewhere without good music and pretty people. A dive bar- this is NOT
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chineme Valerie Schneider
The mezcals. Wow. The music. Wow
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander Blyakher
Best Brooklyn has to offer, hidden gem with amazing music and friendly crowd.
Atmosphere: 5
Nick Meehan
Woman at the door is aggressively rude and sits around waiting to start fights with customers for no damn reason (see other reviews below).
A Ponce
Tacos on point, service on point.
Enchiladas were lackluster - boiled chicken (unseasoned) rolled in corn tortillas thrown in an oven with some sauce.... Meh. had to smother it in salsas to give it some life.
I'd go back for drinks and tacos though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Allison Johnson
Cool little cash only speakeasy. The DJ was great. Would recommend coming here for the DJs. It was vibey for sure with the fog machine.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Jordan Preston
Under the radar speakeasylike mezcalaria hidden behind a bodega like storefront has some of the best music and mezcal in Williamsburg. The space is very small and intimate with an incredible Macintosh tube powered sound system and often features some of the best musicians in NYC. Check out Wednesday evenings for live jazz music that is on the next level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amandip Kaur
Cool electro music but space is super small. Anyways, the bartender was friendly and mezcal negroni was great.
Amazing on a Wednesday night. Live jazz electronic band and dj are 🔥
Lizzie Mears
This is my favorite place to go dancing in New York
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Selena
Horrible drinks, horrible customer service. Didn’t even drink our cocktails.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Lucas Ekstrom
Cool enough spot but the woman working the front was INCREDIBLY rude, and for no clear reason. I empathize with her for the pent up anger she clearly carries, but she shouldn’t be taking it out on the customers. She wouldn’t give it up either and took her sweet time ranting at me about how “the neighborhood has changed and it’s because people are on their phones.” I literally only asked her how much cover was for 3 people and she blew up because I “didn’t ask her how her night was going first.” She also asked me if I was from NYC or not and proceeded to chastise me for not being born here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Daniela Maria Amador
A hidden gem. The best bar in Williamsburg for a drink, fun, and dancing.
Hidden behind a bodega's freezer door, La Milagrosa in Williamsburg is a small-scale miracle for mezcal lovers. This speakeasy isn't about glitz, it’s about good taste and great ambiance. The space is wonderfully intimate, decked out in warm wood and the soft glow of a disco ball and Virgin of Guadalupe candles, creating a vibe that is simultaneously cool, cozy, and transcendent.
While the ambiente is top-tier, the Guayaba Mezcal Margarita is the true star. It’s easily a top-five cocktail in the neighborhood, perfectly balancing the smoky complexity of high-quality mezcal with the lush, tropical sweetness of guava. It’s an innovative drink that never sacrifices the spirit’s integrity. Paired with the curated vinyl soundtrack—a mix of old-school funk and global grooves—it’s the perfect elixir for a night of low-key revelry. La Milagrosa is a must-visit for anyone seeking small, good vibes and a truly exceptional agave cocktail.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
super rude male bartender - as we were counting cash for tip ~1 min after we paid, he said “the tip is not included in the price. 20% is acceptable”. Also menu linked here on Google is incorrect FYI drinks are much more expensive + drinks were not strong at all + it was absolutely empty at 10pm on a Saturday. avoid!!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great sound system. Proper drinks, if Mescal and tequila are your jam- that is way to go.
I always went next store for food, as well as Superio, and decided to pop in. Turns out its cool lol. No real surprise.
Just know it will be packed and there will be people from other parts of the world at times, which I think is a plus. If younare a person who doesn't like mingling and getting to know others, go somewhere without good music and pretty people. A dive bar- this is NOT
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The mezcals. Wow. The music. Wow
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Brooklyn has to offer, hidden gem with amazing music and friendly crowd.
Atmosphere: 5
Woman at the door is aggressively rude and sits around waiting to start fights with customers for no damn reason (see other reviews below).
Tacos on point, service on point.
Enchiladas were lackluster - boiled chicken (unseasoned) rolled in corn tortillas thrown in an oven with some sauce.... Meh. had to smother it in salsas to give it some life.
I'd go back for drinks and tacos though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Cool little cash only speakeasy. The DJ was great. Would recommend coming here for the DJs. It was vibey for sure with the fog machine.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 4
Under the radar speakeasylike mezcalaria hidden behind a bodega like storefront has some of the best music and mezcal in Williamsburg. The space is very small and intimate with an incredible Macintosh tube powered sound system and often features some of the best musicians in NYC. Check out Wednesday evenings for live jazz music that is on the next level.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cool electro music but space is super small. Anyways, the bartender was friendly and mezcal negroni was great.
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing on a Wednesday night. Live jazz electronic band and dj are 🔥
This is my favorite place to go dancing in New York
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Horrible drinks, horrible customer service. Didn’t even drink our cocktails.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Cool enough spot but the woman working the front was INCREDIBLY rude, and for no clear reason. I empathize with her for the pent up anger she clearly carries, but she shouldn’t be taking it out on the customers. She wouldn’t give it up either and took her sweet time ranting at me about how “the neighborhood has changed and it’s because people are on their phones.” I literally only asked her how much cover was for 3 people and she blew up because I “didn’t ask her how her night was going first.” She also asked me if I was from NYC or not and proceeded to chastise me for not being born here.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
A hidden gem. The best bar in Williamsburg for a drink, fun, and dancing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...