Good evening. I ordered a gyro and a meatball Parmigiana, unfortunately the gyro was not lamb. It was DRY chicken. I was very disappointed. If you didn't have lamb when the order was placed, that information should have been shared with the customer. Bye bye Lenny's. our ties have been severed
Service: 1
Red Craddock
They serve old food. Garlic knots were all burnt, mozzarella sticks were hard and dry, zeppolies were inedibly hard and were also just garlic knot bread covered in sugar, so it was obviously everything was recooked/ stale. Ordered cake and they didn't include it. Pizza crust was pale and unrisen meaning it was improperly proofed and cooked. It wasn't undercooked tho and the flavor was good. Maybe if you want the cheap slice this place could be worth it but I don't think it's worth coming here for anything
Alani A
I’ve been going there for almost a decade now and the pizza is soooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mikheil Ghvinianidze
They show as open and they are closed Aug/04/25 5:20pm
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Saqr Kaid
I keep asking them for deliveries they said yes and then they keep hanging up on my face. I’ll call them again. They said they don’t wanna talk to me. This is bad. Bad bad customer service.
Billy Pratt
Excellent small pizza.... The children love having their own....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
John Sousou
Best Pizza on the PLANET! Jimmy is spectacular. 🍕 Dave Portnoy HAS to try it out 🙌🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sorry, I can't hear anyone
It's teast is good little salty
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Aziza Bilal
Usually the food is decent this time the wings were over salted....uhhh this was a delivery....I never asked for salt!!!
Darren Knights
Just got the $10 pie, with pepperoni no cheese. OMG the sauce is amazing. Best pizza not in Brooklyn but in New York... Hands down...
I bet they're ice cream comes warmer than a pie. 30$ for a personal pizza. Delivered? Never again. Talk about NYC bandits who tax for shit pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dionne Alexander
Food is great and service the only problem is when I order in the restaurant I’m seeing the workers preparing food without gloves! I been a customer for over 15 years and if this keeps up I’ll be going elsewhere
A staple of the neighborhood. When other pizza places come and go, these guys always endure it all, with good reason. It may not look all that fancy, but the food will make you feeeeel fancy. Their pizza is always the best (biased I know), the garlic knots are always the right mix of crispy outside and soft chew inside plus they are huge. The Sicilian slices are baked right where the crust doesn't destroy the roof of your mouth or take out a tooth. The sandwiches, when I get them, are always delicious and hot. Its familiar faces for years and years. Good food, good people. ❤️
Kid-friendliness: Elementary school kids get pizza here all the time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
victor michaels
I never been to the actual location but I’ve ordered here a few times. The pizza, calzones, mozzarella sticks are good. There a bit of a wait time (considering how busy they get), but the food arrives hot. Friendly staff and delivery guys. If you’re in the church Ave area come on and try it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nigel B Henry
Just ordered from this Lenny's Pizza via Uber Eats. I wanted to try something new...I ordered pies for the family: a Sicilian, Veggie, 2 personal pies pineapple and beef pepperoni.
The only person in the house who enjoyed their meal was my 6 year old who ordered the pepperoni pie. Everyone else disliked the taste and presentation/packaging. The pizzas all have a thin base and heavy cheese and sauce on-top so it easily falls apart.
The pies weren't sliced/cut deeply enough to allow you to pull it off the whole neatly. Importantly, the taste is bland.
We were disappointed. With such a large order, usually you can enjoy the rest into the next day, but with this pizza, I will have to throw it out...sad. Sometimes it is not worth trying new places....
Good evening. I ordered a gyro and a meatball Parmigiana, unfortunately the gyro was not lamb. It was DRY chicken. I was very disappointed. If you didn't have lamb when the order was placed, that information should have been shared with the customer. Bye bye Lenny's. our ties have been severed
Service: 1
They serve old food. Garlic knots were all burnt, mozzarella sticks were hard and dry, zeppolies were inedibly hard and were also just garlic knot bread covered in sugar, so it was obviously everything was recooked/ stale. Ordered cake and they didn't include it. Pizza crust was pale and unrisen meaning it was improperly proofed and cooked. It wasn't undercooked tho and the flavor was good. Maybe if you want the cheap slice this place could be worth it but I don't think it's worth coming here for anything
I’ve been going there for almost a decade now and the pizza is soooo good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They show as open and they are closed Aug/04/25 5:20pm
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
I keep asking them for deliveries they said yes and then they keep hanging up on my face. I’ll call them again. They said they don’t wanna talk to me. This is bad. Bad bad customer service.
Excellent small pizza....
The children love having their own....
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best Pizza on the PLANET! Jimmy is spectacular. 🍕 Dave Portnoy HAS to try it out 🙌🏼
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's teast is good little salty
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Usually the food is decent this time the wings were over salted....uhhh this was a delivery....I never asked for salt!!!
Just got the $10 pie, with pepperoni no cheese. OMG the sauce is amazing. Best pizza not in Brooklyn but in New York... Hands down...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This place has got to have a new name.
Lenny's stone cold pizzeria.
I bet they're ice cream comes warmer than a pie. 30$ for a personal pizza. Delivered? Never again. Talk about NYC bandits who tax for shit pizza
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food is great and service the only problem is when I order in the restaurant I’m seeing the workers preparing food without gloves! I been a customer for over 15 years and if this keeps up I’ll be going elsewhere
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks
A staple of the neighborhood. When other pizza places come and go, these guys always endure it all, with good reason. It may not look all that fancy, but the food will make you feeeeel fancy. Their pizza is always the best (biased I know), the garlic knots are always the right mix of crispy outside and soft chew inside plus they are huge. The Sicilian slices are baked right where the crust doesn't destroy the roof of your mouth or take out a tooth. The sandwiches, when I get them, are always delicious and hot. Its familiar faces for years and years. Good food, good people. ❤️
Kid-friendliness: Elementary school kids get pizza here all the time.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
I never been to the actual location but I’ve ordered here a few times. The pizza, calzones, mozzarella sticks are good. There a bit of a wait time (considering how busy they get), but the food arrives hot. Friendly staff and delivery guys.
If you’re in the church Ave area come on and try it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just ordered from this Lenny's Pizza via Uber Eats. I wanted to try something new...I ordered pies for the family: a Sicilian, Veggie, 2 personal pies pineapple and beef pepperoni.
The only person in the house who enjoyed their meal was my 6 year old who ordered the pepperoni pie. Everyone else disliked the taste and presentation/packaging. The pizzas all have a thin base and heavy cheese and sauce on-top so it easily falls apart.
The pies weren't sliced/cut deeply enough to allow you to pull it off the whole neatly. Importantly, the taste is bland.
We were disappointed. With such a large order, usually you can enjoy the rest into the next day, but with this pizza, I will have to throw it out...sad. Sometimes it is not worth trying new places....
Food: 2
Loading...