Lucky Charlie
Customers' Favorites
Shaved Fennel Salad with Olives
Classic Pizza with Sausage
White Pizza with Garlic
Pepperoni Pizza
Caesar Salad
Antipasto
Tiramisu
Menu
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The crust has this paper thin texture but the charred edges have this nice hint of sour that complements the rich luscious and tangy tomato sauce and the cheese ties it all together. Really really phenomenal pizza. The stuff of legends. I also got the fennel salad in opposition to my friend’s pleas to not “waste” money on a salad 😒. Was 100% the right move. Will be coming back very soon.
Only once in a blue moon can you find a place as solitary in its greatness as Lucky Charlie. Competing with them isn’t hard because they source the most incredible Japanese A5 Wagyu or have the most celebrities walking through their doors. What allows them to stand out like no other restaurant is their ability to make you feel like you at home. The unique experience to be able to walk into a restaurant you’ve never been to before, and have things feel familiar.
In...
In...
Saw an article about this place and happened to be with my family and searching for something to eat. The situation felt serendipitous and we decided to venture on over... Thank goodness we did! The pizza is absolutely delicious and unique at that. I'm always looking for varieties when it comes to pizza in New York and this place definitely delivers a great take on the Gotham addiction. It doesn't feel like the neighborhood pizzeria, it's more like a sit-down restaurant...
You May Also Like
Boobie Trap - 308 Bleecker St
![]()
Bar, Dive Bar
Lucy's Vietnamese - Bushwick - 262 Irving Ave
![]()
Vietnamese, Noodles, Vegan
Cholula Restaurant - 1481 Myrtle Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian