Luigi's Pizza
686 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 499-3857
Customers' Favorites
Pizza - Half Pepperoni & Half Fresh Mozzarella Margherita
Plain Cheese Pizza Pepperoni Slice
Plain Margarita Grandma Pizza
Fresh Mozzarella Pizza Slice
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza Slice
Grandma Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza Slice
Pizza Margherita Pie
Pepperoni Mushrooms
Margherita Pizza
Menu
Photos
+44 photos
+43 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I've been wanting to go here for a long time based on all the recent hype videos I've seen, and because of their lengthy reputation. But I must have gone on an 'off day' cause it was average at best. Went with classics like plain, peperoni, and square slices. All of them had dry (not crispy) crust. I would go back again. Shout out for their fountain soda, it was super bubbly.
Pizza was good, but I didn't find it to be especially better than what you'd get from a big chain (which is obviously cheaper and more convenient). I also didn't love that the only choices as far as sizing were slices or gigantic full pies.
Typical old school thin crust pizza joint. Does it live up to the hype though? Not really - it wouldn't be in my top list. I found the pizza to be missing some flavor, it was a bit bland. I've had better pizza elsewhere.
The dough is pretty chewy at the thicker parts and mostly crispy at the thinner parts.
The dough is pretty chewy at the thicker parts and mostly crispy at the thinner parts.
You May Also Like
Girasol Taqueria & Bakery - 690 5th Ave
![]()
Bakery, Mexican, Pet Friendly, Tacos, Vegetarian
Sandy Jack's - 683 5th Ave
![]()
Bar, Wine Bar, Beer Bar, Sports Bar, Pet Friendly