Mermaid's Garden
644 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 638-1910
Menu
Photos
+17 photos
+16 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Mermaid’s Garden at the top of a very short list of best retail fish stores in NYC. Their product is meticulously sourced and the quality is always top notch and leans into supporting sustainably sourced options. Their carefully chosen little market of pantry gems has that cuttlefish ink for your squid risotto and yes, I would love a lemon or lime with my order.Everyone on the team cares and again their quality is unimpeachable.
Excellent fish store with sustainable sourcing and delicious fish, as well as other odds and ends. It’s not inexpensive but in my experience with seafood you get what you pay for. They are my go to and have been a staple of our Christmas Eve for many years.
You May Also Like
Dough Doughnuts - 646 Vanderbilt Ave
![]()
Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Vegan
Olmsted - 659 Vanderbilt Ave
![]()
American, Bar, New American, Vegan, Vegetarian
Dilly Dally - 626 Vanderbilt Ave
![]()
New American, Salad, Cocktail Bar
A bit expensive maybe, but you get what you pay for. Good source for hard to find items like shrimp / lobster stock, fish stock, smoked haddock, razor clams, interesting pantry of tinned fish / various sauces and pastas.