Mike's Island Grill

326 E 98th St, Brooklyn
(718) 346-3494

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Shayla Theodore

today I went to the restaurant that lady was so rude. When you open the door to enter the restaurant She was very loud on her phone talking as low as ever plus before she serve you, she supposed to wash her hands because she was touching her phone. Dang she was over the phone talking as loud to the person on the phone when she serve me I asked her for more meat on the food. She did not give me a chance to say I will pay for it. She was very rude and she said I was never going to pay for the meat she did not give me the opportunity to say I’m going to pay for the extra meat that is not the way you do hospitality when you are in a restaurant serving the public she’s very rude and she needs to be fired. She have no respect when she’s serving people that enter the restaurant. The debt was July 5, 2025 at one or four in the afternoon and that is not good service for that restaurant whoever is serving people, especially that lady

DAMIAN COX

The place could use a little paint but other than that I would come back even though I don't go there often

lola harris

The food was nasty! The oxtails had no flavor and were rough! They were not edible. What a waste of money. NEVER AGAIN!!!

Michael Russell

Fabulous

G San

The place might look a bit rough around the edges, but sometimes those spots have the best food. Unfortunately, this wasn’t one of those times. I ordered a beef patty with coco bread, jerk chicken with rice and peas, and mac and cheese.

The beef patty lacked crispiness, and the coco bread was hard. The jerk chicken was dry and didn’t come with any jerk sauce. When I requested sauce, what I got was watered down and didn’t help the taste or dryness of the chicken. The rice and peas were okay, but the mac and cheese was disappointing. The only thing I enjoyed was the drink.

As a foodie who eats out every day and appreciates good flavor, I can’t recommend this place.

KissMe

This place looks a little rough around the edges but they serve up a really great salmon plate. Cabbage and carrots fresh green and orange in color. Coco bread and rice/peas with gravy all EXCELLENT.
I will return if I am in the area again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Edwards

Mike cater my brother bday party. Food amazing and price reasonable. Take out only. Ty!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ackee and Saltfish

Killa Ca

Grilled Salmon was ????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Forever Maryland

Michael gotta stop changing the chefs. Over the years the food has been tasting worst and worst.BlandColdVery small portions of proteinMichael you’re a beautiful human being but your food reputation in community is going down the drain.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 5

Lishelle Moore (Shelley)

Good food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Lishelle Moore

Good food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Kaydee Morris

The food taste good but the price isn't worth the amount they put in a plate I paid 15$ and there's barley anything in it for medium

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sierra P

Got salmon, mash potatoes, and vegetables with gravy. 10/10. The customer service from Mike was amazing. Also got sorrell. Everyone was so friendly and the food was great. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessica Janniere

My husband picked up a large oxtail with rice and peas, boiled dumpling and steamed vegetables. We added a side of mac and cheese bake.This was our first time trying the place and since they had a A rating we said we'd give it a try. We also try to support local and small businesses and never like to leave negative reviews.But it's really difficult to find something good to say about our experience.The rice and peas tasted mediocre, the gravy was watery and not rich, thick and brown like we're used to. The steamed vegetables did not taste fresh or they may have been overcooked. The boiled dumpling had a weird aftertaste. And sadly the oxtail were not cooked fully. There were too many pieces (out of 9-10 pieces for a large size) that were rough and tough to eat.I ordered the Mac and cheese for myself (my husband isn't a fan of mac and cheese) and I could not finish it. It was flavorless, overcooked and just not good.We will not be returning.If you're looking for good Jamaican food, there are so many other options in the area that deliver on flavor, freshness and a positive overall experience.Another thing to note- they charge you a dollar for debit card purchases. One positive thing is that their prices are affordable.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Kyra Atekwana

I was skeptical walking in but the fish, shrimp, & fries combo was ?. Piping hot and crispy and so good.

Loading...