I've ordered a few times for delivery. The food always comes fast and is fresh. Their regular pie is pretty good and still affordable. I've tried their meatball slice, my kids and I weren't crazy about the meatballs flavor. We also had the square pie and garlic knots, which was not a hit In our home. The square is too soggy, the sauce oddly enough was watery compared to their regular slice. The garlic knots are very oily and fall short on flavor. My partner tried the grilled chicken Caesar salad, he thoroughly enjoyed it. I'll still give them a 4 star on service, a decent slice of pizza and the fact that we'd eat it again.
Raphael Rivas
It's still good to get pizza at the price I paid for it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pizza
abdullah jawad
Always brightens my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawn Gabriel
Very bad customer service experience, and while I guess the extra topping (the gross hair) was free, I would not order again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
F ..
Cannot STAND how much I love this place. Hot tip: CALL your order in. Speak to the super efficient person who will take your order and charge you far less than web based orders. What is a veggie pizza? Who knows? Could be anything. I CALLED AND ASKED (OMG). Told: spinach, broccoli, peppers, mushrooms. These are not some garbage canned nonsense - this is fresh everything, except the spinach but froz spinach for pizza purposes is just as good. Added feta cheese. Told 30 mins. Came in 25. Very nice delivery person. Other hot tip: order your large pie pan style - the crust is SO good like that. I paid $22 for a large, pan style pie, with FIVE toppings. AND it's a neighborhood joint. Maybe the veggie pizza changes over time with customer preferences, cost of ingredients, what they have that they need to use up. CALL fool. Love it. Can't beat it!
alyce Serrano
Friendliest workers best pizza my granddaughter won't eat it anywhere else
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
Egyptt B.
I recently had a disappointing experience at Mike's Pizza located at 2026 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11226. The owner's response to my concerns about the quality of my order was quite disheartening. Despite the incomplete and subpar food I received, the owner seemed indifferent, offering a free order next time but warning me against further complaints or he will not deliver to my address again. I've always been treated respectfully by the evening staff, they are wonderful individuals, but the owner's lack of concern for customer satisfaction is alarming. Previously, I've written exceptional remarks and reviews, but once this encountered with the boss offending me and trying to intimidate me. I won't be ordering from Mike's Pizza again due to the rude and dismissive treatment I received. Attached is a picture illustrating the disparity between what I ordered and what was delivered. The owner needs to understand business 101 if a business doesn't have customers, there is no business. I hope one can change such manner and offensive words towards consumers. *Below I've attached my previous kudos and my current order (not edible)
Jarred (JD)
Delicious pizza !?? My fav slice in Flatbush!Get the 2 for 5$Just one costs
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
William Phelps
The absolute best. Every time I think of pizza, I want Mike's. Their pies are delicious, and I'm a big fan of their chicken rolls.
Food: 5
Monica Morrison
I ordered take out. I was not impressed. I grew up in the outskirts of NY and have had great pizza. I was visiting my kids so I thought we’d have some good pizza. Well, not so much. I mean it tasted ok but to me it was not the true NY pizza ? you think you’re getting. This was more like an upscaled Papa John’s if you will. Sorry but I wouldn’t order again.
Been going here for 3 years and never been disappointed. Delivery is quick
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Cole Hafezi
We frequently order from Mike’s. Tonight we ordered “light baked” pizzas and they delivered us an old, burnt pizza. When we shared photos with them, they claimed it was a light baked pizza and refused to remake or refund. Very disappointed in the lack of service and inability to follow directions. We will not order again in the future after this poor experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sharon
Buffalo chicken and Nona are my favorites and go-to’s! Fast service and great quality.This might not be what one typically associates with NY (thin crust) pizza, but personally, I don’t care much about that, it just has to be good!The flavors, dough, crust, and service are spot on here. I always know we’ll get delicious fresh pizza here, and swiftly. I love that we can trust them for quality and service; they’ve never disappointed, and we order here a lot.Thank you, Mike’s Pizza!
I've ordered a few times for delivery. The food always comes fast and is fresh. Their regular pie is pretty good and still affordable. I've tried their meatball slice, my kids and I weren't crazy about the meatballs flavor. We also had the square pie and garlic knots, which was not a hit In our home. The square is too soggy, the sauce oddly enough was watery compared to their regular slice. The garlic knots are very oily and fall short on flavor. My partner tried the grilled chicken Caesar salad, he thoroughly enjoyed it. I'll still give them a 4 star on service, a decent slice of pizza and the fact that we'd eat it again.
It's still good to get pizza at the price I paid for it.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pizza
Always brightens my
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very bad customer service experience, and while I guess the extra topping (the gross hair) was free, I would not order again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Cannot STAND how much I love this place. Hot tip: CALL your order in. Speak to the super efficient person who will take your order and charge you far less than web based orders. What is a veggie pizza? Who knows? Could be anything. I CALLED AND ASKED (OMG). Told: spinach, broccoli, peppers, mushrooms. These are not some garbage canned nonsense - this is fresh everything, except the spinach but froz spinach for pizza purposes is just as good. Added feta cheese. Told 30 mins. Came in 25. Very nice delivery person. Other hot tip: order your large pie pan style - the crust is SO good like that. I paid $22 for a large, pan style pie, with FIVE toppings. AND it's a neighborhood joint. Maybe the veggie pizza changes over time with customer preferences, cost of ingredients, what they have that they need to use up. CALL fool. Love it. Can't beat it!
Friendliest workers best pizza my granddaughter won't eat it anywhere else
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice
I recently had a disappointing experience at Mike's Pizza located at 2026 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11226. The owner's response to my concerns about the quality of my order was quite disheartening. Despite the incomplete and subpar food I received, the owner seemed indifferent, offering a free order next time but warning me against further complaints or he will not deliver to my address again. I've always been treated respectfully by the evening staff, they are wonderful individuals, but the owner's lack of concern for customer satisfaction is alarming. Previously, I've written exceptional remarks and reviews, but once this encountered with the boss offending me and trying to intimidate me. I won't be ordering from Mike's Pizza again due to the rude and dismissive treatment I received. Attached is a picture illustrating the disparity between what I ordered and what was delivered. The owner needs to understand business 101 if a business doesn't have customers, there is no business. I hope one can change such manner and offensive words towards consumers. *Below I've attached my previous kudos and my current order (not edible)
Delicious pizza !?? My fav slice in Flatbush!Get the 2 for 5$Just one costs
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 4
The absolute best. Every time I think of pizza, I want Mike's. Their pies are delicious, and I'm a big fan of their chicken rolls.
Food: 5
I ordered take out. I was not impressed. I grew up in the outskirts of NY and have had great pizza. I was visiting my kids so I thought we’d have some good pizza. Well, not so much. I mean it tasted ok but to me it was not the true NY pizza ? you think you’re getting. This was more like an upscaled Papa John’s if you will. Sorry but I wouldn’t order again.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Crispy Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Been going here for 3 years and never been disappointed. Delivery is quick
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We frequently order from Mike’s. Tonight we ordered “light baked” pizzas and they delivered us an old, burnt pizza. When we shared photos with them, they claimed it was a light baked pizza and refused to remake or refund. Very disappointed in the lack of service and inability to follow directions. We will not order again in the future after this poor experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Buffalo chicken and Nona are my favorites and go-to’s! Fast service and great quality.This might not be what one typically associates with NY (thin crust) pizza, but personally, I don’t care much about that, it just has to be good!The flavors, dough, crust, and service are spot on here. I always know we’ll get delicious fresh pizza here, and swiftly. I love that we can trust them for quality and service; they’ve never disappointed, and we order here a lot.Thank you, Mike’s Pizza!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Ordered a large pepperoni pie and garlic knots and it was so good!! Will definitely be ordering from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: Custom pizza for the lactose intolerant
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza