Mill Basin Bagel Cafe

6319 Avenue N, Brooklyn
(718) 531-3630

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Viola Lebowits

Been coming here for 15years and the bagels still have my heart. Always on point!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Victoria Mordekhaiev

Ordered butter and jelly on a lightly scooped out bagel…

David

Whoever was handling the hot breakfast sandwiches this morning needs to be retrained, there should be no reason why I ordered a standard Bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and all I taste is lox. Spent $8 and change on a sandwich the least they could do is switch gloves between fish orders and regular ones. Unacceptable

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Jason T

July 2025 update: The price of everything jumped up overnight, What happened to this place, looks like new owners, but lots of same employees, but still went massively down hill. What the hell happened to the bagels? Why are they so small?? Bagels are legit palm size or smaller. 30 minutes in store for 1 egg sandwich, how? It wasn’t even busy. My coffee has been wrong 3 different times, even though they literally write the coffee order down on paper, the wrap I got recently was so small it looked like a McDonald’s snack wrap. I guess it’s time to stop going here, super sad as they used to be good and have good iced coffee.

Decent BEC, could use some more egg though

Ed

$10 for a BLT roll is wild. These guys think they're in Manhattan or something. Prices aren't listed for many things either. Beware and buy what's listed with prices or you'll get scammed.

Food: 3

Service: 3

Kimmy Kimk

The bagel and cream cheese was too much
$7 for a bagel with cream cheese (ridiculous)

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Miss Libby Stew

Something about the bagel I had tasted like bathroom cleaner

Food: 1

mujer Mujer

They must be under new management. The counter guys are great!

The new bosses are charging things incorrectly and trying to justify it.

A bacon, egg and cheese on a raisin bagel.
A wrap with egg whites, turkey and tomato
2 Bai drinks total 29.80.

I asked for the receipt and asked why it was that much. Well, they itemized every part of the wrap sandwich including the eggs, totaling almost 14.75.

I called them out on it and he told me that they had to charge me for each ingredient.

I told them there was no way wrap that fits in a cardboard container can be almost 15.00.

After much going back and forth he itemized again and gave me back 3.80.

I will not be going back. Check your receipts.

Alon Fischer

Best bagels in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cream Cheese Bagel, Classic Tuna Salad, Assorted Freshly Baked Muffins, Egg Sandwich

Abner Cosme

My last bagel delivered before new management takes over wish all employees the best and thank u for amazing service we appreciate you 3/29/25 hope nothing changes with new management god bless you all 🙏🏼❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

NY Ginzo Guide (Rick Sanchez)

Quick service, hot bagels.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The Big J

This bagel store charged me $4.75 for bagel with cream cheese. That’s highway robbery and the bagel tasted terrible and the owner is nasty as can be I complained. He didn’t believe finally someone spoke up never ever again. And the cashier smelled like 7 cigarettes my money I got back smelled like an ash tray stay away.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

BJ Schnaps

Today is National Bagel Day 😋 are you doing anything special for your customers ❤️ thx

bizzy izzy

A bit overpriced I think. But always fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jamie

The price for breakfast is way too much and not worth it. A bagel with cream cheese and bacon was $9.00.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Loading...