Monte's

451 Carroll St, Brooklyn
(718) 852-7800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Enrique Cafaro

Stopped by for the first time last week and had a very enjoyable meal. We started with a large Margarita Pizza pie that was cooked in the wood burning oven to perfection, nice crust and lovely sauce. We followed up with the linguine and seafood special that was outstanding with mussels, clams, calamare and shrimp. Cannoli's were a great dessert, we will be back again especially for the pizza's. Menu could use a few more dishes that are compatible with pizza.

Phyllis Ayers

First time customer. Just ordered chicken parm with spaghetti. Food came fast and was delicious. One complaint: NO bread or eating utensils. Not even the option to add bread to the order. This meal was not cheap. I took away a star.

Tom Wipf

A step back in time to old Brooklyn! One of the oldest establishments- great menu, great staff, great service. Garden, Dining Room options. A must see.

Lee Williams

I occasionally walk by this location, but it wasn't until this past weekend that I made the decision to stop in and eat there. It was enjoyable even though some of the dishes were too salty for my tastes. An added advantage was the excellent service.

Kim

I got the Margherita pizza, and it was just waaaaaaaay too salty. I couldn't enjoy it. And it was a bit too overpriced for my taste

A Esp

Cute little restaurant with amazing food. The pizza is ? ? and the pasta ?.

Robert Bailey

Absolutely fabulous, I can't say enough. Service was great and food was just phenomenal. Highly recommend for excellent Italian

Willie Washington

The food is amazing her and the service is always A1, I recommend trying them out when you chance. They have an awesome menu and the prices are reasonable.

Ed Rodriguez

Pretty sick spot. Great decor. Small. Not noisy. The pastas are great, pizza is alright. Great service

RIchard Sheridan

Unbelievable food. ambiance.service lovely dining experience the bread is the best bread I’ve ever tasted @ a restaurant Beautiful Warm caring staff. surely my favorite Italian experience in NYC it’s not just a restaurant it’s an experience

Omar Pineda

The meal was ok, but the icing on the cake was when my credit card charge posted with $40 more than what I paid at the restaurant. Two weeks later, and they still haven’t refunded me. Never going again.

David Leathers

Awesome experience. Jovan is great and provided great service and some great stories. Food very tasty. Recommend

Michael Pallotto

Good food. Waitress must be new. She forgot 3x my order.

Bruce Gottlieb

Food is borderline inedible. Pasta overcooked (almost jello) and tasteless. Calamari rubbery and tasteless. Cioppino was ok.I don’t review often but want to warn others.

elless s

Monte's is a neighborhood landmark... red sauce Italian. Always OK. Keep drinks simple. You'll be happier. But, just like that old pair of shoes that you no longer wear outside, it's so comfortable.

Loading...