Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream

Only rating the service. I finally went in after passing by since they opened. Was intrigued by the list of flavors; tried 3. Settled on the cherry soursop but sadly like the other flavors I tried it only tasted like condensed milk. I wouldn't go back. The service was great though.

Fire! Love the soursop cherry

The man that runs this shop opened on time. I put some money in the meter and walked in. He sells flavors that are not common to find. He gives you 3 tastes of ice creams. I ordered the cherry soursop. He sells grape nut, which is hard to find. I tasted the peanut flavor ice cream and it tasted spot on. He fills the ice cream tubs to the brim. I did not see cones when I walked in. I'll have to ask if he carries them. He also makes milk shakes. Maybe one day, I'll try that.

Love the cleanliness of this shop. Customer service was great and the flavors are really good, I came all the way from Suffolk County to experience this goodness.

Delicious icecream, but the cakes are just cakes nothing special.

The sorrel ginger is quite literally the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life.

Bro front counter people need to get fired , they don’t own it so they don’t care how they talk/ treat customers …. My recommendation is hire a new squad , if they are friendly in interview hire them cus the one u girl u got there got to go … look at all the reviews you’ll see all the bad reviews are strictly about customer service and how they’re treating us in that place. I came there all the way from Long Island. I’m Trinidad and I came to bring my Italian girlfriend and it was a horrible experience the girl serving the ice cream was acting as if we told her to take that job as if it was our fault that she was at work like you should be happy to even have a job in 2025

Really good homemade ice cream with caribbean type flavors inclusive of vegan selections. Be sure to check it out.

Unimaginable taste! I was transported all the was back to Trinidad in my youth, turning the ice cream pail handle for my aunt. Top tier service and ambiance

Had the pleasure of having the sorrel, chocolate, mango and coconut ice cream. The sorrel was the best. Plan on going back to get other flavors

The chocolate flavor was very refreshing, didn't feel heavy at all. Would recommend on a hot day.

Wonderful people that serve some amazing ice cream and Bolba!!

Very flavorful icecream I must say but the soursop was very soft to begin with, and icecream must never ever be soft. That resulted in the 3 stars. The grapenut was very delicious.

Wow! 🤩 Soursop flavour is definitely so delicious. Tried it for the first time and I really like it. It's really amazing! 5 🌟 Friendly staff. Highly recommend this fresh, homemade ice-cream 👌

Delicious and so happy they have vegan coconut so my whole family can enjoy!