Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream
1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
(973) 640-3200
Customers' Favorites
Cookies & Cream
Sea Moss
Grapenut
Soursop
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Only rating the service. I finally went in after passing by since they opened. Was intrigued by the list of flavors; tried 3. Settled on the cherry soursop but sadly like the other flavors I tried it only tasted like condensed milk. I wouldn't go back. The service was great though.
The man that runs this shop opened on time. I put some money in the meter and walked in. He sells flavors that are not common to find. He gives you 3 tastes of ice creams. I ordered the cherry soursop. He sells grape nut, which is hard to find. I tasted the peanut flavor ice cream and it tasted spot on. He fills the ice cream tubs to the brim. I did not see cones when I walked in. I'll have to ask if he carries them. He also makes milk shakes. Maybe one day, I'll try...
Wow! 🤩 Soursop flavour is definitely so delicious. Tried it for the first time and I really like it. It's really amazing! 5 🌟 Friendly staff. Highly recommend this fresh, homemade ice-cream 👌
You May Also Like
Ahmani's Jus Juice - 1403 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Juice, Dessert, Healthy, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Aunts et Uncles - 1407 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Vegan, Cafe, Vegetarian, Cocktail Bar
Immaculee Bakery - 1411 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Bakery, Haitian