Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream
1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
(973) 640-3200
Customers' Favorites
Cookies & Cream
Sea Moss
Grapenut
Soursop
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I haven’t tasted a flavor that I dislike yet. From butter pecan, to sorrel ginger omg. So good. Unfortunately they only have mango in the summer :( but these homemade flavors really hit different. 10/10.
love this spot so much. not even from BK but had to pay it another visit after going last year, upon discovering it via Righteous Eats. S/O to the bubbly vibrant and lovely employee who happily greeted us, explained the process, and had a light hearted heart to heart chat about ice cream flavours and astrology! We love a girl’s girl - even more, a perfect experience through and through. Flavours hit! Textures are perfect and the staff are truly so kind! Come to Mr. P’s to...
Wonderful small family-run ice cream parlor with creative and delicious Caribbean flavors. The place is popular with the locals and there can be a line but the wait is worth it. The ice cream is fresh and taste authentic without a strong heavy cream feel, more a natural texture.
It’s $4 for a 4 Oz cup, $8 for a 8oz, $13 for a 16oz and $25 for a 32oz container.
You can mix and match flavors in those cups.
It’s $4 for a 4 Oz cup, $8 for a 8oz, $13 for a 16oz and $25 for a 32oz container.
You can mix and match flavors in those cups.
You May Also Like
Ahmani's Jus Juice - 1403 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Juice, Dessert, Healthy, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Aunts et Uncles - 1407 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Vegan, Cafe, Vegetarian
Immaculee Bakery - 1411 Nostrand Ave
![]()
Bakery, Haitian