OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park

40 River St, Brooklyn
(718) 387-4676

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Choco Torta Peanut Butter S'Mores
Sticky Pecan Bun in a Waffle Cone
Vegan Coconut Mango Sticky Rice
Buddis Spaghetti Sundae
Almond Cherry Praline
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Chocolate Ice Cream
Screw on Ice Cream
PB S'Mores Pint
Chocolate Chunk

Classics Collection
Sweet Cream and Sprinkles
Sweet cream ice cream base with sprinkles. So many sprinkles. Contains dairy, eggs, and sprinkles.
Coffee Crunch
Our most popular coffee-based, crunchy ice cream! Coffee base with our housemade coffee soil. Contains dairy, eggs, almonds.
Vanilla Bean
Our classic Vanilla ice cream base made with real Madagascar vanilla beans. Contains dairy and eggs.
Cookies and Cream
Sweet cream ice cream base with chunks of chocolate cookie. You might be interested to learn that Cookies and Cream was invented here in New York City. We were surprised to learn that it was invented at all we assumed it evolved from the ooze with us humans. Contains dairy, egg, and gluten.
Cookies + Mint
Mint ice cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Dark Chocolate Chunk
Dark chocolate base with tiny chunks of Valrhona "magicked" dark chocolate. Contains egg, dairy, coconut oil.

OddFellows Favorites
Chocotorta
Sour cream and cream cheese ice cream base with chunks of dulce de leche and chocolate cookie bits. An OddFellows Favorite! Contains dairy, eggs, gluten.
Passionfruit Apricot Pistachio
Passionfruit ice cream base with apricot jam and crushed pistachios. Contains dairy, egg, pistachio.

Vegan Ice Cream Flavors
Vegan Chocolate PB Pretzel
Our vegan chocolate base is made with cashew milk giving it a smooth and creamy texture. With swirls of peanut butter and chocolate cover pretzels, you got an ice cream flavor you'd never know was vegan. Contains cashews, peanuts and macadamia.

Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Sandwich
An ice cream flavor of your choice in between two deliciously chewy chocolate chip cookies.

Beverages
Boylan's Soda
12 oz Glass Bottle
Water Bottle
Milkshake
16 oz. milkshake made with our homemade ice cream

Oddfellows Ice Cream Domino Park Menu
Cookies and Mint
Mint sweet cream base with chocolate cookie bits. Contains dairy, eggs, and gluten.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+44 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great Ice Cream and even better service. Angelo (please forgive me if I spell incorrect) is an absolute star, knowledgeable of the product and incredibly talented in customer engagement and establishing strong customer loyalty through top tier service. I will now be a regular Oddfellows customer.
March 2025
We visited this ( I believe the original?) location tonight, not for the first time. Always delicious, unique, modern flavors. The reason I decided to leave a review tonight though is that the staff was exceptionally lovely this evening, so genuine and friendly, yet professional. A fun way to end our evening. So refreshing, thank you!
September 2024
This place has a fantastic location and the flavors are creative and very well-made. The matcha and strawberry flavor was a favorite. The toppings are also delicious especially the olive oil and marshmallow fluff.
July 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Other Half Brewing Domino Park - 34 River St
Brewery, Beer Bar, Pet Friendly
Roberta's - 6 Grand St
American, Pizza, Italian
Two Hands - 262 Kent Ave
Australian, Cafe, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park

40 River St, Brooklyn, NY 11249
(718) 387-4676