I don't know which type it is exactly, but the loaf of bread that I got on Sunday was amazing. Lovely caramelized flavor in the crust, just right chewy crispy, stayed fresh for days. Best bread of the year so far. Half off in the late afternoon.
Hugo Tam
I’m a regular at this bakery and have always enjoyed their pastries, but lately the quality seems to have declined. Most recently, the Kouign-amann was disappointingly dense and slightly burnt. I hope they take a closer look at quality control before serving items—I’d love to see them return to the high standards they used to maintain.
Julissa Sanabria-Markowitz
Otway Bakery is hands-down one of Brooklyn’s best hidden gems. Every pastry I’ve tried has been exceptionally fresh and flavorful—it’s clear they care deeply about quality. The crullers alone are worth the trip (seriously, if you haven’t had one yet, you’re missing out big time)
Yes, there’s often a line, but it’s well deserved and moves quickly thanks to the warm, friendly staff who always make the wait feel worth it. Otway strikes the perfect balance of neighborhood charm and top-tier baking. Can’t recommend it enough
Lily Zhang
The best baguette!
Elizabeth Graham
Everything I’ve ever had here is 111/10
Rachel T
Another great spot for pastries in an area with a lot of competition. I love their baguette sandwiches, as well as their croissants.
Kevin Zeng
Great neighborhood cafe. Croissants I ate fresh baked. And the baguette is very nice. I would come back for that.
This spot is small with just a few high chair. They aren’t that busy after 2pm and it’s a good spot to meet friend.
Friendly service.
Sydney Marrazzo
i cannot believe this place doesn’t have a line around the corner it’s so good!! tried the kimchi savory roll which was my favorite, the bread is so soft and pillowy. the babka loaf wasn’t my fav (the sticky toffee one from lafayette has my heart) but it was good. wish there was more chocolate though. overall love the selection and can’t wait to go back! also don’t feel like things are too overpriced
Lesley Myers
Their baked goods and veggie sandwiches are excellent. Try the cardamom bun - lots of flavour and not too sweet.
Fred D.
Ask for Macchiato, received espresso 🤷🏻. Didn’t want to say anything and just walked out. Good espresso though.
What a cute little bakery down the street from me! Their pastries are top tier in Brooklyn—rivalries include L'Appartment 4C, Saraghina Bakery, and Radio Bakery. Not one to be missed! My dog is a pastry queen and gives it 5/5 paws 🐾
Natalie
Cute little bakery with amazing pastries and delicious coffee! Come early (before 10 AM if there’s a specific pastry you want- they run out). Their seeded kouign-amann is AMAZING- so nutty, light and flaky!
Maggie Love
best bread in brooklyn! everything is delicious
Jerry Zhang
very nice
Eleanor M
good pastries and cute interior! got the coffee cake and a limited edition danish (which was so good). wanted to try the cardamom bun but it sold out, seems like you have to come pretty early to grab them
I don't know which type it is exactly, but the loaf of bread that I got on Sunday was amazing. Lovely caramelized flavor in the crust, just right chewy crispy, stayed fresh for days. Best bread of the year so far. Half off in the late afternoon.
I’m a regular at this bakery and have always enjoyed their pastries, but lately the quality seems to have declined. Most recently, the Kouign-amann was disappointingly dense and slightly burnt. I hope they take a closer look at quality control before serving items—I’d love to see them return to the high standards they used to maintain.
Otway Bakery is hands-down one of Brooklyn’s best hidden gems. Every pastry I’ve tried has been exceptionally fresh and flavorful—it’s clear they care deeply about quality. The crullers alone are worth the trip (seriously, if you haven’t had one yet, you’re missing out big time)
Yes, there’s often a line, but it’s well deserved and moves quickly thanks to the warm, friendly staff who always make the wait feel worth it. Otway strikes the perfect balance of neighborhood charm and top-tier baking. Can’t recommend it enough
The best baguette!
Everything I’ve ever had here is 111/10
Another great spot for pastries in an area with a lot of competition. I love their baguette sandwiches, as well as their croissants.
Great neighborhood cafe. Croissants I ate fresh baked. And the baguette is very nice. I would come back for that.
This spot is small with just a few high chair. They aren’t that busy after 2pm and it’s a good spot to meet friend.
Friendly service.
i cannot believe this place doesn’t have a line around the corner it’s so good!! tried the kimchi savory roll which was my favorite, the bread is so soft and pillowy. the babka loaf wasn’t my fav (the sticky toffee one from lafayette has my heart) but it was good. wish there was more chocolate though. overall love the selection and can’t wait to go back! also don’t feel like things are too overpriced
Their baked goods and veggie sandwiches are excellent. Try the cardamom bun - lots of flavour and not too sweet.
Ask for Macchiato, received espresso 🤷🏻. Didn’t want to say anything and just walked out. Good espresso though.
Restaurantji Recommends
What a cute little bakery down the street from me! Their pastries are top tier in Brooklyn—rivalries include L'Appartment 4C, Saraghina Bakery, and Radio Bakery. Not one to be missed! My dog is a pastry queen and gives it 5/5 paws 🐾
Cute little bakery with amazing pastries and delicious coffee! Come early (before 10 AM if there’s a specific pastry you want- they run out). Their seeded kouign-amann is AMAZING- so nutty, light and flaky!
best bread in brooklyn! everything is delicious
very nice
good pastries and cute interior! got the coffee cake and a limited edition danish (which was so good). wanted to try the cardamom bun but it sold out, seems like you have to come pretty early to grab them
Loading...