Papa Johns Pizza
2124 Mermaid Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 265-7272
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Pizza
Dipping Sauce
Menu
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
As an Italian from Italy, this is the only pizza in Brooklyn that I actually enjoy, and I've tried them all, cheap and expensive. I don't understand the hate against Papa John's.
Good Pizza, Despite a Mix-Up
Pretty solid pizza for the price — definitely a good option when you're craving something quick and satisfying. We were disappointed that the order was mixed up and we received a completely different pizza instead of the pepperoni we were expecting. At least the price was about the same.
That said, the pizza we got was still tasty, and the brownie was actually pretty decent too. Mistakes happen, and the...
Pretty solid pizza for the price — definitely a good option when you're craving something quick and satisfying. We were disappointed that the order was mixed up and we received a completely different pizza instead of the pepperoni we were expecting. At least the price was about the same.
That said, the pizza we got was still tasty, and the brownie was actually pretty decent too. Mistakes happen, and the...
To be brutally honest, this store location has a lot be desired. There’s a minimum of 2-3 people in that store and needs to hire more people for it to run efficiently. Nobody should be handling multiple tasks such as prepping the food, cooking the food, serving it to the customers or delivering it. There should be one that could handle one or two tasks and that’s it.
You May Also Like
Surf pizza & wings halal - 2115 Surf Ave
![]()
Halal, Chicken Wings, Pizza, Seafood
Kennedy Fried Chicken - 2325 Mermaid Ave
![]()
Chicken, Chicken Wings