Papa Johns Pizza

1011 Broadway, Brooklyn
(718) 443-7272

Recent Reviews

YRIS ALCANTARA

Wonderful service and very excellent qualityThank you for being so special

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Seran Gee

Order is over half an hour late. The driver claimed to have called me but my phone log shows no calls. He could have just used the door buzzer but bizarrely chose not to. Oh, and the pizza is lukewarm and he wouldn't deliver it to my door (I had to come out and get it from him).

Dani Luv

Customer service is horrible. They got my order wrong then blaming me for it. the manager was rude and the pizza made me felt sick, pls dont order from this store smfh.

Food: 1

Service: 1

taps246

Pizza was subpar even for fast food pizza. Will not be going to this place ever again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Despite Very

No price on anything on the menu so prepare for made up charges for a small one

NOTE DAVIS

Do not order from them. They've consistently gotten my order wrong. Order a pepperoni pizza and they will deliver a cheese everytime.

Food: 1

Tereance Shannon

Ordered online 8/19/23. Food was perfectly made and delivery was on time. Would order again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Sticks and Stuffed Crust Makes Your Own, Dipping Sauce, Create Your Own

Jarlene may

Good variety, still hot upon delivery, need more staff or space very small location. Always busy , but gets orders done.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Large Pizza

mateus porto

Cancelled my order even though I ordered a half hour before closing.

Dr M.

Quality has plummeted at the West Orange location in the past year...this order was the last straw. Will use our remaining "Papa Dough" to order chicken wings next time and that'll be our last visit ever. Sad..

Delareen Kennedy

Food was good for the price, wait was not too long.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Small Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak

Iksheeta S.

I am not a huge fan of chain pizza restaurant, this one is ok! The ambiance is what you'd expect!

Andres Hernandez

they send me to order online (at the store) because they were so busy with online orders and they weren’t able to take orders on site

Destiny S.

If I can give this store Zero stars I would I ordered the new Oreo desert item that comes with Cream cheese icing & when I received it I opened the box and the "icing" was " Blue Cheese"!!! They gave me Blue Cheese with a desert item what's up with that! Mind you I've purchased 2 of them ‍‍‍

Reliable Expert Reviewer with Standards in NY

2nd time I ordered a pizza via Uber EATS and THEY DON'T SEAL THE BOX WITH TAPE OR A STICKER LIKE OTHER RESTAURANTS DO!!!!Because of my experience with this last week, TODAY I CALLED THE RESTAURANT AND SPOKE TO THE MANAGER BEFORE I MADE THE ORDER AND EXPLAINED TO HIM MY ISSUE WITH THIS RESTAURANT WITH NOT SEALING THE FOOD FOR SAFETY. THE MANAGER PROMISED TO SEAL MY PIZZA BOX... WELL GUESS WHAT???I GET MY PIZZA FROM THE DELIVERY GUY AND MY PIZZA IS NOT SEALED!!WHAT REALLY IS THE MANAGER GOOD FOR?I WILL NOT ORDER AGAIN. A SIMPLE REQUEST COULD NOT BE HANDLED.

Load More